Capped Bust Half Dollars: The Expert’s Guide to Authentication and Avoiding Fakes

With Counterfeits Flooding the Market, These Diagnostic Details Could Save Your Collection

After thirty years authenticating early U.S. silver coins, I’ve handled more counterfeit Capped Bust Half Dollars in the past five years than in my first twenty-five combined. These stunning pieces – featuring John Reich’s elegant Liberty cap design – have become prime targets for sophisticated forgers. But fear not, fellow collectors! With the right knowledge coursing through your numismatic veins, you can confidently build a collection worthy of display.

Why Capped Bust Halves Captivate Collectors

Minted from 1807 through 1836, these fifty-cent pieces represent America’s first standardized silver coinage. Reich’s masterpiece – Liberty facing left with her iconic cap and LIBERTY scroll – became a blueprint for future U.S. designs. With mintages ranging from a mere 6,000 (1815) to over six million (1836), the series offers thrilling challenges for specialists. Here’s where authentication becomes your greatest ally in preserving both historical value and numismatic worth.

The Four Cornerstones of Authentication

1. Weight and Composition: Your First Defense

Every genuine specimen should feel right in your palm – weighing between 13.36g and 13.48g with a precise 32.5mm diameter. The authentic 89.24% silver composition creates a distinctive “ring” when gently tapped. Modern counterfeits often betray themselves here – like the supposed 1818/7 overdate that landed on my scale at 14.2g (clearly a base metal imposter).

2. The Magnet Test: Silver’s Telltale Reaction

A rare earth magnet (N52 grade) becomes your truth-teller. Genuine bust halves show zero magnetic attraction but create fascinating eddy currents. Tilt your magnet at 45 degrees – authentic silver-copper alloy slides slowly like honey, while plated fakes either stick or skitter down like a kid on ice skates.

3. Die Markers: The Collector’s Fingerprint

As forum member @pursuitofliberty astutely observed, die study separates the novices from the experts. Each Overton variety sports distinctive birthmarks:

• 1813 O-108a: Die crack knitting stars together like celestial string
• 1818 O-112: Double-nose profile that gives Liberty an almost three-dimensional quality
• 1813 Single Leaf reverse: Heavy die lapping creating a “ghost valley” between leaves

The Bust Half Nut Club’s Die State Progressions reveals how cracks evolve – watching an O-108.3’s hairline fracture grow from date to star is like reading a coin’s personal diary.

4. Surface Storytelling: Where History Meets Metal

Authentic surfaces whisper their provenance through:

• Precisely lettered edge reading “FIFTY CENTS OR HALF A DOLLAR”
• Granular “orange peel” texture under magnification – impossible to perfectly replicate
• Toning that follows the metal’s flow lines like topographic maps

Counterfeits often scream their falseness through:

• Mushy eyelash details that lack Reich’s sharp strike
• Artificial “cartwheel” luster that looks painted rather than earned
• Seam lines along the edge – the calling card of casting

Spotting Wolf in Sheep’s Clothing: Common Fakes Exposed

From examining over 200 counterfeit bust halves, I’ve cataloged these frequent offenders:

“The Chinese Wave” (2018-present): Struck counterfeits mostly of 1820s dates. Correct weight but wrong magnetism. Die markers resemble Overton listings like a forgery of Shakespeare’s signature – close but never right.

“The Lima Specials” (Peru, 2010s): Cast fakes with surfaces resembling acne-scarred skin. Weight typically 14-15g. Stars appear as if someone pressed thumbprints into the design.

Altered Date Coins: Particularly 1815/2 and 1831/0 varieties. Under oblique lighting, tool marks often shimmer like guilty consciences around the dates.

The Collector’s Authentication Arsenal

When that heart-pounding auction lot catches your eye:

1. Start with a 10x loupe – hunt for unnatural tool marks on Liberty’s cheekbone and cap
2. Deploy digital calipers like Excalibur – diameter must be 32.5mm ±0.1mm
3. Conduct the specific gravity test (should be 10.30-10.35) – silver’s density never lies
4. Consult your battered copy of Overton like a holy text – dog-eared pages mark true devotion
5. Seek counsel from niche experts – the David Kahns of this world eat counterfeiters for breakfast

Protecting Your Numismatic Investment

Consider @pursuitofliberty’s AU55 1813 O-108a – properly authenticated, it commands $4,500-6,000. Without die marriage verification? Half that value evaporates. For crown jewels like the 1818/7 overdate, authentication transforms a $1,500 coin into a $15,000 centerpiece. Remember: In mint condition with provenance, these pieces aren’t just silver – they’re time machines connecting us to 1830s Philadelphia.

Conclusion: Keeping History Genuine

While counterfeiters grow more sophisticated, our passion for these historical treasures only deepens. Like @mrbrklyn’s magnificent collection demonstrates, properly authenticated Capped Bust Halves offer more than numismatic value – they’re tactile links to America’s monetary adolescence. Master these authentication techniques, and you’ll join that elite circle who can spot fakes faster than a 1794 Flowing Hair dollar crosses the auction block.

Here’s the final word from my three decades in the trenches: True collectibility begins when you can look a counterfeit in its lifeless eyes and declare – with Brooklyn swagger – “Not today, pal.” Keep your loupe clean, your references closer, and your collector’s fire burning bright.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Unearthing Hidden Treasures: The Roll Hunter’s Guide to 1982-1983 US Mint Souvenir Sets – The Thrill of the Hunt: Why These Hidden Gems Matter Let me share a collector’s secret: Some of America’s mo…
• Grading ‘What are you going to do with all those pennies’: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – Let’s cut straight to the chase: in numismatics, condition isn’t just important—it’s everything. Picture thi…
• Is Your 1837 Bust Half or 1877/6 Overdate Authentic? The Collector’s Guide to Spotting Counterfeits – With Counterfeits Flooding the Market, Mastering These Diagnostic Details Could Save Your Collection As I gently rotated…