Crafting With History: Assessing the $20 St. Gaudens Double Eagle for Jewelry Making

Not Every Coin Belongs on the Ring Mandrel

After fifteen years of transforming history into wearable art, I’ve developed a jeweler’s intuition for coins that whisper “transform me” versus those that demand preservation. While collectors debate condition census rankings and population reports, we artisans assess more tactile qualities – the way light dances on a coin’s fields, how its alloy responds to the hammer, whether its story justifies rebirth. Today, let’s examine an American icon through our workshop loupe: the legendary pre-1933 $20 St. Gaudens Double Eagle.

Where Numismatic History Meets the Artisan’s Bench

Commissioned by Theodore Roosevelt himself and brought to life by master sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, these Double Eagles represent the pinnacle of U.S. coinage artistry. Struck from 1907 through 1933, each contains nearly a full troy ounce of gold (90% pure, 10% copper). While investors track market premiums – now hovering around 6.4% for MS-65 examples – we craftsmen evaluate different virtues entirely.

The Alchemist’s Secret: Understanding the Alloy

• Gold Purity: 0.900 fine (22 karat equivalent)
• Strengthening Agent: 10% copper for resilience
• Ideal Weight: 33.436 grams – substantial without being cumbersome

This particular blend creates what I call “jeweler’s gold” – soft enough to work beautifully under the hammer, yet durable enough for generations of wear. Pure 24K gold would deform like putty, but that 10% copper infusion boosts tensile strength by nearly a third. When coaxing a coin into ring form, this balanced composition allows us to preserve intricate details while creating a piece that stands up to daily life.

Spotting the Perfect Transformation Candidate

“Common dates at MS-65 or below? That’s our raw material right there.”
– Wisdom from the CoinRingArtisans Forum

This collector sentiment mirrors our workshop philosophy. While high-grade specimens (MS-66 and above) deserve protection in numismatic collections, there’s poetic justice in converting near-mint examples with limited collectibility into enduring art. Here’s what we look for:

Prime Candidates for Artistic Rebirth

• Condition Sweet Spot: MS-63 to MS-65 (retains detail without destroying significant numismatic value)
• Date Selection: 1920s issues (plentiful supply with modest premiums)
• Surface Considerations: Light hairlines acceptable (polished out during crafting)
• Handle With Care: Never touch 1907 High Reliefs, 1927-D, or other rare varieties

Why Saint-Gaudens’ Masterpiece Shines in Ring Form

Three design elements make these Double Eagles sing when transformed:

1. Sculptural High Relief Details

From Lady Liberty’s wind-swept gown to the eagle’s individual feathers, these elements translate magnificently to signet rings. When domed, the central motifs maintain their depth while the reeded edge frames the design like a museum display.

2. The Mesmerizing Sunrise Reverse

Those radiating sunbeams become kinetic art when wrapped around a finger. As the wearer moves, the pattern catches light differently with every gesture – numismatic theater on an intimate scale.

3. The Golden Ratio of Ring Crafting

At 34mm diameter, these coins offer remarkable versatility:

• Men’s rings (sizes 10-13) using the full coin
• Women’s sizes 6-8 with elegant center cutouts
• Stunning pendants when bisected vertically

The Art of Value Transformation

Converting rare coins is numismatic heresy, but transforming bullion-value specimens creates wearable prosperity:

With Great Collections archives showing premiums shrinking from 19% (2014) to today’s 6.4%, artistic conversion can actually preserve value by enhancing eye appeal and wearability.

Mastering the Craft: Challenges & Solutions

Preserving Detail During Transformation

The copper alloy forgives shaping, but demands respect:

• Anneal at cherry red (1200°F/648°C) between hammer stages
• Use brass-faced hammers to prevent metal contamination

Sizing Without Sacrificing Integrity

Avoid aggressive stretching:

• Employ internal shanks for size increases
• Precision laser cutting for reductions

Maintaining Original Character

Protect that mint luster and patina:

• Micro-abrasive polishing (5-10 micron grit)
• Ultrasonic baths before and after fabrication

The Collector-Artisan Compact

Before any transformation, we ask:

• Is it certified? (Never alter graded coins)
• Is it rare? (Check PCGS/NGC populations)
• Does it have historical significance? (1933 issues are legally protected)

“Our craft breathes new life into forgotten coins while revering true numismatic treasures.”
– The Ethical Artisan’s Oath

Conclusion: Wearable American Legacy

The $20 St. Gaudens Double Eagle represents a perfect storm of artistry, history, and metallurgy. While pristine specimens belong in museum cases, common-date examples trading near melt value – especially those MS-65 and below – offer extraordinary potential. The copper-alloyed gold withstands generations of wear, while Saint-Gaudens’ design ensures each piece carries a century of American spirit. For those of us who cherish both history and craftsmanship, these coins aren’t just bullion – they’re miniature monuments waiting to be worn, loved, and passed down through time.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving the Legacy: Expert Conservation Strategies for Your $20 St. Gaudens Double Eagle – The Fragile Legacy in Your Hands Let me share a hard truth from my conservation lab bench: nothing pains me more than se…
• Decoding the $20 St. Gaudens Double Eagle: How Grading Transforms Bullion into Treasure – The Allure of the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle In numismatics, condition isn’t just important—it’s everything….
• Authenticating Your $20 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle: Essential Guide to Spotting Counterfeits – The Ultimate Authentication Guide for Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles In a market flooded with increasingly sophisticated fa…