Finding the 1920 Hudson Half Dollar in the Wild: A Cherry Picker’s Guide

Ever felt that jolt of adrenaline when a glint of silver catches your eye in a roll of ordinary coins? As a veteran roll hunter, I’ve unearthed some of my most prized finds in the unlikeliest places—teller trays at small-town banks, coffee cans at estate sales, even tucked beneath buttons in a flea market sewing kit. Among these hidden treasures, few spark as much passionate debate as the 1920 Hudson Half Dollar. This coin isn’t just silver—it’s a 90% pure slice of American ambition, controversy, and what many call “acquired taste” design. Consider this your field guide to spotting history in the wild.

The Beautiful Ugly Duckling of Numismatics

Forged in controversy and steeped in local pride, the 1920 Hudson Half Dollar stands apart from federal issues. The Hudson County Chamber of Commerce commissioned 50,000 pieces to celebrate their 250th anniversary, but the celebration turned sour when speculators cornered the market. Today, that turbulent backstory fuels its collectibility. When you hold one, you’re gripping a physical argument about art versus commerce—a tangible “what if?” from America’s roaring twenties.

Design-wise? Let’s call it polarizing. John R. Sinnock’s Liberty stares back with what collectors either see as classical gravitas or “crusty schoolmarm” severity. (Personally, I love her no-nonsense gaze—it screams Jersey attitude.) The reverse seal divides opinion too: some praise its heraldic crispness; others mutter “clip art before computers.” This aesthetic tension is precisely what makes finding one thrilling. That “Is this…?” moment when you spot distinctive lettering in a pile of Walkers? Pure numismatic magic.

Hunting Grounds: Where History Hides

Modern “Circulation” Myths and Realities

Will you find a Hudson jingling in a Coinstar reject tray? Let’s be honest—dream on. Most vanished from pockets by the 1930s. But “circulation finds” take new meaning today:

• Bank roll surprises: While hunting silver halves (1964-back), I once found a Hudson nestled between Franklins. The elderly customer who deposited them? “Just grandpa’s pocket change.”
• Dealer “junk silver” bins: Many lump commemoratives with common 90%. Inspect every rim!

Estate Sales: The Collector’s Goldmine

Nothing beats the musty thrill of an untouched estate box. Families often sell coins en masse, unaware of rare varieties hiding among Mercs and Barbers. My best Hudson find? Inside a cigar box labeled “Costume Jewelry—$20.” The coin’s patina blended with cheap brooches—until sunlight hit its reeded edge.

“I vote real. If price is right…” — Wise words from the trenches

This forum wisdom is gospel. Buy bulk silver near melt value, and any Hudson becomes gravy. But beware “too good” deals—which brings us to authentication.

The Art of Spotting Truth in Tarnished Silver

That forum debate about “genuine but ugly” Hudsons? Textbook case. These coins practically invite skepticism. Here’s how to separate history from hoax:

Strike: Embrace the Mush

Genuine Hudsons suffer notoriously soft strikes—like Liberty’s features were pressed through velvet. Compare high points:

• Obverse: Her jawline should show gradual metal flow, not sharp tool marks
• Reverse: Seek shallow-but-consistent shield details. Counterfeits often over-engrave

Edges and Heft Don’t Lie

Run your thumb along the edge. Authentic reeding feels uniform, not jagged like cast fakes. Pocket-worn examples weigh light (clipped coins excepted), but anything below 12g screams “reproduction.”

Patina Tells the Truth

Real Hudsons age like blue-collar hands—honest wear on Liberty’s cheek, smoother fields where thumbs gripped. Artificial toning looks sprayed-on, with chemical rainbows. As one collector quipped: “If it’s ugly but consistent, it’s probably real.”

Red Flags from the Collecting Trenches

1. Princess in the Pigpen: Mint-state luster in a junk box? Suspicious
2. Pricing Paradox: If they know it’s “rare,” why sell bulk? Trust melt-value deals
3. Character Beats Cosmetics: That scratched 1920 survivor? It witnessed flappers and speakeasies—value beyond grade

Value Spectrum: More Than Melt Worth

While no 1913 Liberty Nickel, the Hudson’s numismatic value holds steady:

• Good-VG: $15-$30—ideal for type collectors
• F-VF: $40-$75—details emerge, eye appeal improves
• EF-AU: $100-$250—glimpses of original luster
• MS: $500+—less than 5% survive in mint condition

Silver content guarantees a floor, but true worth lies in provenance. That “ugly” VG example? It circulated through Prohibition-era Jersey City. Hold history, then decide.

Mastering the Cherry Picker’s Craft

1. Source Intelligently: Befriend small-town bank tellers. Attend estate sales early. Online auctions? Filter “mixed lots” + “local pickup”
2. Systemize Searches: Scan half-dollar rims first—90% silver? Check dates next. Spot 1920? Isolate immediately
3. Authenticate Relentlessly: Carry a 10x loupe. Know Sinnock’s design quirks. Doubtful? Snap macro photos for forum reviews
4. Collect What Connects: Value Hudsons as historical artifacts first, investments second

“Pass, regardless if fake or not.” — Know when to walk

Wisdom stings but saves money. Not every silvery glint is treasure. The hunt continues.

Why We Chase These Controversial Coins

The 1920 Hudson Half Dollar embodies why we hunt: It’s not the prettiest, rarest, or most valuable. But find one, and you’ve rescued a storyteller. That worn-down Liberty? She rode in Al Capone’s pocket. That scratched reverse? Funded some long-forgotten Jersey library. In a grade-obsessed hobby, Hudsons remind us: coins are time machines first, assets second. So next time you’re knee-deep in bank rolls or estate dust, look sharp—history hides in plain sight, waiting for your keen eye.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Collector’s Playbook: Acquiring Hudson Half Dollars Without Falling for Fakes or Overpaying – The Market Analyst’s Guide to Navigating Hudson Half Dollar Purchases If you’re considering adding the elusi…
• Can This Hudson Half Dollar Be Made Into Jewelry? A Coin Ring Artisan’s Guide to Crafting Potential – For coin artisans and collectors alike, few questions spark more debate: when does a coin transcend numismatic value to …
• Preserving the 1936 Hudson Sesquicentennial Half Dollar: A Conservationist’s Guide to Avoiding Common Mistakes – I’ve Witnessed Heartbreak: Save Your Hudson Half Dollar from Numismatic Tragedy After thirty years holding history…