Grading Old School BampMs: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000

The Art of Grading: Understanding What Makes Coins Valuable

Condition is everything in numismatics. The difference between a $10 common date and a $1,000 gem specimen often comes down to subtle variations in wear patterns, luster, strike quality, and eye appeal. As a professional grader, I’ve learned that understanding these nuances is what separates casual collectors from serious investors.

Wear Patterns: Reading the Story on a Coin’s Surface

When examining a coin, the first thing I look for is how wear has affected the high points. Every coin series has specific areas that wear first – for Morgan dollars, it’s typically the cheek and hair above the ear; for Walking Liberty halves, the left hand and right leg show wear first. Understanding these patterns is crucial for accurate grading.

Light wear that affects only the highest points might indicate an AU-50 grade, while wear that extends into the fields suggests a lower grade. The key is consistency – uniform wear across the entire surface typically indicates honest circulation, while isolated wear spots might suggest improper storage or cleaning.

“I remember the rotating glass cases were always my favorite. I still have a silver certificate I bought there.” – Forum Member

Luster: The Mirror of a Coin’s Soul

Luster, or the way light reflects off a coin’s surface, is perhaps the most misunderstood aspect of grading. Original mint luster has a distinctive cartwheel effect that’s difficult to replicate. When a coin circulates, this luster breaks down, starting at the highest points and progressing across the surface.

Professional graders use specific terminology to describe luster quality: “blazing” for coins with exceptional reflectivity, “satiny” for a softer glow, and “frosty” for that characteristic white appearance on business strikes. The presence of original luster is often what separates a MS-63 from a MS-65 coin.

Strike Quality: The Foundation of Grade

Even a perfectly preserved coin can be limited by poor strike quality. Weak strikes result in soft details, particularly on the obverse portrait and reverse devices. When grading, I always consider whether weakness is due to wear or simply a poor strike from the beginning.

Certain mints and dates are notorious for weak strikes – San Francisco Morgan dollars from the 1880s often show weakness on the eagle’s breast, while many Denver mint coins from the 1920s-30s exhibit softness on Liberty’s head. Understanding these characteristics helps determine if a coin is truly circulated or just weakly struck.

Eye Appeal: The X-Factor in Grading

Eye appeal is subjective but critically important. A coin might technically grade MS-65 but possess such exceptional toning, strike, or luster that it merits a plus designation or even a star designation from NGC. Conversely, a technically solid MS-65 might be downgraded due to unattractive toning or contact marks in prime focal areas.

Professional graders develop an instinct for eye appeal through years of experience. We learn to recognize when a coin has that special something that makes it stand out from its peers – whether it’s rainbow toning on a silver coin, exceptional strike sharpness, or simply a particularly attractive example of its type.

PCGS/NGC Standards: The Industry Benchmark

Understanding PCGS and NGC grading standards is essential for any serious collector. These services have established consistent grading criteria that most of the market follows. While there can be slight variations between graders, the standards remain remarkably consistent.

Key grading points include:

• MS-60: No wear, but may have contact marks, dullness, or poor eye appeal
• MS-63: Mint luster may be slightly impaired, few contact marks
• MS-65: Above average mint luster, minor contact marks, excellent eye appeal
• MS-67+: Nearly flawless, exceptional eye appeal, full original luster

The Evolution of Grading Standards

Grading standards have evolved significantly since the “old school B&Ms” era described in the forum posts. In the 1960s-80s, grading was more subjective, and terms like “gem uncirculated” could mean different things to different dealers. The advent of third-party grading in the 1980s brought much-needed consistency to the market.

Today’s grading standards are more stringent. A coin that might have been considered MS-65 in 1980 might only grade MS-63 by today’s standards. This evolution has made the market more transparent but also more challenging for new collectors to navigate.

Practical Grading Tips for Collectors

For collectors looking to improve their grading skills, I recommend:

1. Study certified coins to understand grade standards
2. Examine coins under proper lighting – a 100-watt incandescent bulb is ideal
3. Use a good quality loupe (5x-10x magnification) for detailed examination
4. Handle coins by the edges only, using cotton gloves
5. Compare multiple examples of the same grade to understand variations

Remember that grading is as much art as science. Even professional graders can disagree on borderline cases, which is why you’ll sometimes see coins resubmitted for re-evaluation.

The Market Impact of Accurate Grading

Accurate grading directly impacts value. A coin that grades MS-64 might be worth $100, while the same coin in MS-65 could be worth $300 or more. This three-fold difference underscores why professional grading became essential to the market’s growth.

The forum posts about finding valuable coins in discount bins or rotating cases highlight how grading knowledge can lead to exceptional finds. The collector who found 1922 no-D cents in a bowl of wheat cents for 10 cents each understood grading well enough to recognize their true value.

Conclusion: The Lasting Value of Grading Knowledge

The nostalgia for “old school B&Ms” reflects a simpler time in numismatics, but today’s more sophisticated grading standards have created a more stable and trustworthy market. Whether you’re examining coins in a modern shop or reminiscing about those rotating glass cases, understanding wear patterns, luster, strike quality, and eye appeal will always be valuable.

The next time you’re examining a coin, take a moment to really study it – look at the high points, assess the luster quality, consider the strike sharpness, and evaluate the overall eye appeal. These skills, developed over time, are what separate casual collectors from true numismatists who can recognize that $10 coin from the $1,000 treasure.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Is Your Old School B&Ms Real? How to Spot a Fake – Introduction With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for this item is critical. Th…
• How to Spot Rare Errors on Vintage Coin Shop Finds – Introduction Most collectors overlook the subtle details that transform ordinary coins into extraordinary rarities worth…
• Rediscovering the Golden Age of Coin Shops – Introduction: A Bygone Era of Numismatic Discovery Every relic tells a story. To understand the culture of coin collecti…