How I Cracked the Code on Bust Coin Errors: A Collector’s Diagnostic Guide

My Frustrating Journey With Bust Coin Errors

Let me tell you about the weekend I nearly threw my loupe across the room. There I was, squinting at an 1823 half dollar, completely baffled by what looked like a crack in Liberty’s neck. Was it a die crack? Lamination? Post-mint damage? I’d already wasted $75 on a “rare error” that turned out to be environmental corrosion. Sound familiar?

After burning through reference books and online forums, I finally cracked the code. What you’re about to read is the system that transformed me from confused hobbyist to confident error spotter – without spending a fortune on misidentified coins.

The 5 Most Common Bust Coin Errors (and How to Spot Them)

1. Missing Edge Lettering Mysteries

Remember that heart-stopping moment when you first saw a smooth-edged Bust coin? I panicked thinking I’d bought a counterfeit. Turns out these rare errors happen when planchets slipped through without proper edging. Here’s what finally clicked for me:

• No trace of letters – not even ghosts
• One side often has a subtle “lip” from uneven striking
• Fewer than 20 verified specimens exist across all dates

2. Die Crack vs. Lamination Confusion

This one cost me three months of headaches. The secret? Flip your lighting. Shine a flashlight sideways across the surface:

• Die cracks throw shadows like miniature mountain ridges
• Laminations look like peeling paint under angled light
• Struck-through debris leaves “cookie cutter” impressions

My 4-Step Diagnostic Framework

Step 1: Magnified Visual Inspection

Put down that cheap plastic loupe! After ruining my eyesight with 5x magnification, I upgraded to a Bausch & Lomb 10x triplet. Game-changing features:

• Crisp edge-to-edge clarity (no fishbowl effect)
• Wide field of view for tracking crack paths
• Perfect for spotting micro-doubling in dentils

Step 2: Edge Examination Techniques

My “flashlight trick” became famous at our coin club meetings:

1. Rest coin on blue putty (never fingers!)
2. Position LED light at 10 o’clock angle
3. Rotate slowly – missing letters cast telltale flat shadows

Step 3: Strike Characteristics Analysis

When I found this 1810 double strike, here’s what convinced me it was genuine:

• Matching flow lines in opposing dentil fields
• Distinct “step” between strike impressions
• No tooling marks around the doubling

Step 4: Reference Verification Process

I nearly misattributed an 1807 dime until I cross-checked with the Hilgard archive. Now I follow this rule: Never trust a single source. Always compare against:

• PCGS variety listings
• NGC error catalog
• Two physical reference books minimum

Advanced Diagnostic Case Studies

The Off-Center Strike Dilemma

When a dealer offered me an “off-center” 1825 quarter, I whipped out my diagnostic cheat sheet:

1. Measure exposed collar (true errors show 5%-95% coverage)
2. Check for radial flow lines matching the shift direction
3. Verify rim thickness consistency – post-mint damage thins edges

Partial Collar vs. Broadstrike Showdown

This 1835 half dime taught me the difference that matters:

• Partial collars create “step” rims with vertical lines
• Broadstrikes expand evenly like pizza dough
• Fake broadstrikes often show file marks under magnification

Building Your Error Identification Toolkit

Essential References I Use Daily

• Cherrypickers’ Guide (worth its weight in silver)
• CONECA variety listings (free online resource)
• My personal “error library” of slabbed examples

Digital Documentation Best Practices

After fuzzy photos cost me a sale, I perfected this setup:

Phone hack: Use white socks diffusers over lamps
Pro tip: Shoot videos while rotating coins
Must-have: Free online EXIF viewers to verify magnification
Secret weapon: Gray card for color accuracy

Critical Lessons From Costly Mistakes

That “double struck” 1805 half dollar haunts me. Here’s why it fooled me:

• Toning hid the weak second strike (always check under multiple light temperatures)
• I confused die deterioration doubling (DDD) with true machine doubling
• Missed the slight clockwise rotation – only visible at 40x magnification

Now this specimen lives on my desk as a $450 reminder.

Conclusion: Becoming an Error Detection Expert

Here’s what transformed my Bust coin collecting:

• Treat every coin like a crime scene – document first, judge later
• Build physical “error flashcards” for quick comparisons
• Join CONECA for access to expert verification
• When stuck, walk away and revisit with fresh eyes

Nothing beats the adrenaline rush of confirming a genuine error like double edge lettering. With these techniques, you’ll spot treasures others overlook – and avoid expensive lessons I learned the hard way.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Built a $50k Online Course Empire Teaching Coin Design Mastery – From Coin Nerd to Six Figures: How I Built a $50k Course Teaching Coin Design Secrets Let me tell you a secret – t…
• My 6-Month Quest to Master Coin Design Aesthetics: Hard-Won Lessons From Building a Premium Collection – Six months ago, I set out to build a premium coin collection that would make seasoned numismatists nod in approval. Boy,…
• How to Design Stunning Coin Faces: A Step-by-Step Beginner’s Guide – So you want to design your own coin? Start here. Coin design might seem intimidating at first, but trust me – anyo…