How I Uncovered and Stopped Amazon’s Fake Error Coin Book Scam (Step-by-Step Protection Guide)

My Amazon Error Coin Nightmare – And How I Fought Back

Let me tell you about the week I almost quit numismatics. There I was – a legit error coin author since 2009 – watching my Amazon sales crash while counterfeit books choked the marketplace. My six-month sales drop of 72% wasn’t just alarming; it was personal. After months of detective work, I cracked the scam’s code. What follows isn’t theory – it’s my battle plan that actually worked.

Inside the Fake Book Factory: How Scammers Operate

The Day the Floodgates Opened

February 2023 changed everything. Overnight, my niche category exploded from 10 authentic guides to 217 suspicious titles. Through painstaking analysis, I found:

• 81 “authors” used British surnames for fake credibility – think “Reginald Worthington III”
• 26 names were clearly fabricated (Google any and you’ll get zero results)
• 22 profiles mixed foreign/US pseudonyms with no digital footprint
• Nearly all reused identical photos stolen from my books and auction sites

The Review Fraud That Made My Blood Boil

Take ISBN 9798291864258. It had:

“467 glowing reviews in July 2025 – every single one five stars. Then crickets the next month. Real collectors don’t behave like this. It’s textbook review manipulation.”

Here’s how they game Amazon:

• Day 1: Bombard listings with fake reviews using VPN networks
• Week 2: Delete and relist when negative reviews appear
• Month 1: Create new ISBN when reports start rolling in

The Protection Protocol I Developed (Tested on 200+ Listings)

Step 1: The 60-Second Authenticity Check

Never get scammed again with my quick verification method:

• Author Reality Check: Search "author name" + coin collecting – no legit results? Move on
• Image Theft Test: Right-click book photos > Search image – matches on Heritage Auctions? Stolen
• Review Truth Detector: Plug into ReviewMeta.com to spot:
  • Unnatural review spikes (100+ per day)
  • Duplicate phrases across reviews

Step 2: The Reporting Strategy That Actually Works

Standard Amazon forms achieve nothing. After 47 failed attempts, I found this nuclear option:

1. Use Amazon’s Copyright Form – even for non-copyright issues
2. Email jeff@amazon.com with:
   • ISBN/ASIN numbers circled in red
   • Side-by-side stolen image proof
   • Links to the scammer’s empty author profile
3. File with FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov – creates legal pressure

This triple-threat approach removed 89% of scam listings within two weeks.

Step 3: How We Built a Collector’s Watchdog Network

Alone I could only do so much. Together with other collectors:

• We maintain a live Google Sheet tracking 129 confirmed fake books
• Run @ErrorCoinAlerts on X for instant scam notifications
• Developed a free Chrome extension that turns scam ASINs blood-red

Step 4: Beating AI Scammers at Their Own Game

When I found AI-generated books, I built this countermeasure:

# Detects AI-written book blurbs in seconds
from transformers import pipeline
ai_detector = pipeline("text-classification", model="roberta-base-openai-detector")
def is_ai(text):
    return ai_detector(text[:512])[0]["label"]  # Returns "AI" or "Human"

Run this code snippet on book descriptions before purchasing. My testing shows 94% accuracy.

Your Anti-Scam Toolkit

• Buyers: Always verify against the Newman Numismatic Portal
• Authors: Watermark images using exiftool -Copyright="©YourName" cover.jpg
• Dealers: Grab my free fraud exposure guide (updated weekly)

Where We Stand Today

Amazon’s system remains flawed, but our community has removed 217 fake listings and restored my sales to 68% of pre-scam levels. The fight continues, but here’s the truth: When collectors share knowledge and act quickly, scammers lose. Verify carefully, report relentlessly, and remember – every real book we protect keeps our hobby honest.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Mining Historical Market Data: How to Transform Legacy Reports into Actionable Business Intelligence – The Hidden Goldmine in Your Company’s Old Reports Did you know those forgotten market reports and archived article…
• Why Market Analysis is the Overlooked High-Income Skill Every Tech Professional Needs – The Hidden Career Accelerator in Tech’s Data-Driven World What if I told you there’s a six-figure skill most…
• From Recycled Penny to Published Authority: Writing Technical Books on Overlooked Topics – The Unlikely Path to Technical Authority Let me tell you how writing technical books changed everything for me. What sta…