How to Properly Store and Preserve Your Rare Multi-Date Penny

A Collector’s Take on Your Unique Find

I’ve seen countless valuable pieces ruined by improper cleaning or storage. Here’s how to protect this for future generations.

What You Actually Have

Before we dive into preservation, let’s clear up what’s really happening with your penny. That phenomenon you’re seeing—multiple dates when tilting the coin—is a classic case of pareidolia, where our brains perceive familiar patterns in random visual data. This is especially common with coins that have suffered from struck-through grease errors.

Those raised features aren’t multiple dates at all. They’re the result of grease and debris clogging the die during minting, which prevented certain areas from being struck properly. When you tilt the coin at different angles, your brain naturally tries to make sense of the incomplete or distorted features, creating the illusion of different numbers.

Why Proper Preservation Matters

Even though this isn’t a multi-date error (which would be impossible from a minting perspective), it’s still a legitimate error coin that deserves proper care. Many collectors have accidentally damaged their coins through well-intentioned but harmful cleaning attempts or improper storage.

The Dangers of Improper Storage

Coins are particularly vulnerable to environmental damage. Here are the main threats:

• PVC damage: Many older plastic holders contain polyvinyl chloride, which can leach chemicals onto coins, creating a slimy green residue that permanently damages the surface
• Oxidation: Exposure to air, especially in humid environments, can cause toning or corrosion
• Physical damage: Coins can scratch each other if stored together without protection
• Environmental contaminants: Oils from fingers, dust, and other particles can cause long-term damage

Proper Storage Solutions

Immediate Protection

First and foremost, never handle your coin with bare hands. The oils and acids on your skin can cause permanent damage. Use cotton gloves or hold the coin by its edges only.

Choosing the Right Holder

For a coin like this, I recommend a high-quality 2×2 cardboard holder with Mylar windows. These are inexpensive, archival-safe, and allow you to view both sides of the coin without removing it. Make sure the staples are flattened to prevent scratching.

For long-term storage, consider these options:

• Air-tite holders: These are hard plastic capsules that create an airtight seal
• Slab storage: If you do submit the coin for grading (though it likely won’t grade highly due to the error nature), the slab provides excellent protection
• Archival flip holders: These are soft plastic holders made from non-PVC materials

To Clean or Not to Clean

This is perhaps the most critical advice I can give: do not clean this coin. Cleaning, even with mild solutions, will almost certainly reduce its value and can cause irreversible damage. The patina and toning that develops naturally on coins is actually protective and often valued by collectors.

If the coin appears dirty, resist the urge to polish it. Professional conservators have specialized techniques that should only be used in extreme circumstances. For a circulated error coin like this, cleaning would be completely unnecessary and harmful.

Understanding Toning and Oxidation

Natural Toning

Copper coins like your penny will naturally develop a brown patina over time. This is called toning and is completely normal. In fact, many collectors prefer original, untoned coins. The various shades of brown on copper coins tell a story about the coin’s journey through time.

Harmful Oxidation

While natural toning is fine, watch for signs of harmful oxidation like green spots or powdery residue, which could indicate active corrosion. If you notice these signs, store the coin in an even drier environment and consider consulting a professional.

Long-term Preservation Strategy

Environmental Control

Store your coin collection in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Ideal conditions are:

• Temperature: 60-70°F (15-21°C)
• Humidity: 40-50%
• No direct UV light exposure

Organization and Documentation

Even though this coin isn’t worth a fortune, proper documentation adds to its historical value. Create a simple record including:

• Date of acquisition
• Where you found it
• Its current condition
• Any interesting observations about its appearance

Insurance and Appraisal Considerations

While struck-through grease errors typically have minimal numismatic value (usually just a few dollars above face value), your coin has sentimental and educational value. If you’re concerned about loss, consider adding a rider to your homeowner’s insurance for valuable collectibles.

For formal appraisal, seek out a professional numismatist who belongs to organizations like the American Numismatic Association. They can provide documentation of your coin’s condition and authenticity.

Educational Value

This coin represents an excellent teaching opportunity about minting errors and human perception. Consider sharing your find with local coin clubs or online communities where others can learn from your experience. Many collectors enjoy studying error coins precisely because they reveal so much about the minting process.

Conclusion

Your “multi-date” penny, while not actually containing multiple dates, is still a fascinating piece of minting history. By storing it properly in an archival-safe holder, avoiding any cleaning attempts, and controlling its environment, you’ll preserve this conversation piece for years to come.

Remember that the coin collecting community values honesty and accurate representation. While it’s tempting to believe we’ve found something extraordinary, the real joy often comes from understanding what we actually have and preserving it correctly. Your struck-through grease error penny, properly cared for, will remain an interesting part of your collection and a testament to the quirks of the minting process.

Happy collecting, and may all your future finds be both exciting and properly preserved!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Grading Multi Date Penny: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – Understanding the Multi Date Penny Phenomenon Condition is everything. Here is how to look at the high points and fields…
• Is Your Multi Date Penny Real? How to Spot a Fake – The Rise of Counterfeit Coins in Today’s Market With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagno…
• How to Spot Rare Errors on Multi Date Penny: A Die Crack & Double Die Guide – The Thrill of the Hunt: Finding Hidden Treasures As any seasoned collector knows, the devil is in the details. Those tin…