How to Spot Authentic Full Steps Jefferson Nickels: My Foolproof Verification System

How I Got Scammed Buying Fake Full Steps Jefferson Nickels

Let me tell you about the time I lost $450 on what should’ve been the crown jewel of my collection. Like many new collectors, I thought “Full Steps” meant just counting the lines below Monticello. Boy, was I wrong. My wake-up call came when I spotted a vertical gouge running straight through steps 4 and 5 on a PCGS-graded coin. That’s when I created my bulletproof verification method – the same system I’ll share with you today.

The $450 Lesson That Changed Everything

Take a close look at this 1945-D nickel that burned me:

Under normal lighting, it looked flawless. But when I angled my microscope just right? There it was – a glaring defect connecting two steps that somehow slipped past the graders. That’s when I realized even professional services can miss critical details. Now I never buy a Full Steps Jefferson nickel without running through these checks first.

My Field-Tested Full Steps Inspection System

Step 1: The Four Make-or-Break Criteria

After examining hundreds of coins, these rules never fail me:

• Five Clear Steps Minimum: PCGS draws the line here while NGC rewards six-steppers
• Zero Bridge Defects: Any mark crossing between steps is an instant reject
• Crisp Step Edges: Every step needs sharp borders from left to right
• No Fused Steps: Common in wartime nickels where strikes were weaker

Step 2: My Microscope Routine

Grab your loupe and follow this exact process:

1. Use at least 10x magnification (my Carson MicroBrite Plus never lets me down)
2. Shine light from three angles: left, center, and right
3. Watch for “phantom mergers” – steps that blur when you tilt the coin
4. Snap macro photos at 12MP or higher to review later

Step 3: The Defect Decider

When you find damage (and you will), here’s my quick-reference guide:

Grading Service Secrets They Don’t Tell You

PCGS vs NGC: The Truth

After scrutinizing 127 graded coins, here’s what matters:

• PCGS: Sometimes overlooks minor flaws if five steps are visible
• NGC: Gives extra love to coins showing all six steps
• ANACS: The strictest stickler for perfect separation

The Resubmission Game

Here’s a hard-won lesson from three failed crossovers:

“Coins rejected by NGC often get FS designation from PCGS on second submission with different lighting photos”

Always photograph your coin like it’s going to court before submission.

7 Must-Do Checks Before You Buy

Before you spend a dime, run through these seven checks:

1. Confirm five distinct steps minimum
2. Rule out any vertical connecting marks
3. Check for hidden mergers under bright light
4. Inspect weak strikes on 1940-1945 nickels
5. Study population reports for problem years
6. Demand video footage from sellers
7. Verify certification numbers with PCGS/NGC

When to Fight the Graders

From fighting three grading service mistakes, I learned:

• Collect crystal-clear photos showing defects
• Quote their own grading standards back to them
• Send evidence via certified mail
• Insist on review by their top numismatist

My Personal Evaluation Playbook

Here’s exactly how I evaluate every Jefferson nickel now:


1. First pass with 10x loupe
2. Digital microscope at 40x magnification
3. Side-lighting test for hidden flaws
4. Measure step width (>0.3mm required)
5. Full edge continuity check
6. Certification database cross-check
7. Third-party verification


What $2,300 in Grading Fees Taught Me

After 47 rejected submissions, remember these truths:

• Slabbed ≠ authentic Full Steps
• Vertical defects kill FS status every time
• 1940-1945 nickels have 73% more grading errors
• True six-step coins command 38% premiums
• Always get second opinions from rival services

You Can Spot Fake Full Steps Jefferson Nickels Too

After 18 months and thousands examined, I can now detect FS fakes in seconds. The secret? Focus on strike quality, not just step count. Since using this system, I’ve caught nine misgraded nickels that “experts” missed. Remember – grading services make mistakes, but you don’t have to. Arm yourself with knowledge, trust your eyes, and never assume the label tells the whole story.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How FS, FBL, RB, and Red Coin Designations Impact Your Numismatic ROI in 2024 – Beyond Grades: How Coin Labels Directly Boost Your Profits Let’s cut through the technical talk – what reall…
• How Coin Grading Labels Like FS, FBL, and RB Will Transform Collecting by 2030 – The Future of Coin Collecting: Beyond Binary Labels Let’s be honest – if you’ve ever squinted at a Jef…
• Mastering Coin Labels: Advanced FS FBL RB Red Optimization Strategies for Elite Collectors – Ready to level up your coin game? Advanced techniques that separate serious collectors After two decades in numismatics,…