I Bought and Authenticated 10 Random Coins – Here’s My Foolproof Verification Method

I Bought and Authenticated 10 Random Coins – Here’s My Foolproof Verification Method

As someone who’s been burned by fakes before, I recently put ten random coin purchases through the wringer. Some passed with flying colors while others had me kicking myself. Here’s the straight talk on what verification methods worked – and which ones wasted my time.

The Coin That Almost Got Me

That “mint condition” 1883 CC Morgan Dollar nearly emptied my wallet for $174. The shop lighting hid its flaws perfectly. Only later did I spot the truth:

• A scratch that was actually a die crack (classic rookie mistake)
• A raised metal blob by the date – telltale casting evidence
• Details that looked like they’d been through a washing machine
• Side-by-side with a real Morgan, the differences screamed at me

Putting 4 Methods to the Test

1. The Eyeball Test

What worked: Spotted obvious fakes in seconds
What didn’t: Missed the good counterfeits every time
My result: Caught about 6 of 10 fakes

2. Weight and Measure Check

What worked: My digital scale caught underweight imposters
What didn’t: Some fakes nailed the specs perfectly
My result: Red-flagged 4-5 shady coins

3. The Magnet Trick

What worked: Instantly exposed cheap metal fakes
What didn’t: Useless against silver-plated phonies
My result: Only caught 3 obvious fakes

4. Professional Grading

What worked: Nothing beats expert eyes and equipment
What didn’t: The $50 fee hurts on cheaper coins
My result: 100% accuracy – worth it for key dates

Red Flags That Never Lie

After examining these coins like a detective, these warning signs appeared like clockwork:

• Surface that looks like orange peel skin (big red flag)
• Letters that crowd together or float oddly
• Important details that look soft or blurred
• A weight that’s even slightly off
• Color that seems “too perfect” or unnatural

My Painful Lessons (So You Don’t Have To Learn Them)

After losing money on bad purchases, I now swear by these rules:

1. Never trust a coin still in its holder – take it out!
2. That $10 loupe in your pocket beats regret every time
3. Memorize the specs before you buy (I keep a cheat sheet)
4. If the deal seems too good, it’s absolutely fake
5. Only buy from sellers who offer no-questions returns

The Verification Process That Actually Works

Here’s my battle-tested routine after authenticating dozens of coins:

1. Initial once-over in natural light (no dealer spotlights!)
2. Weight and diameter check against official numbers
3. Quick magnet test to eliminate the obvious fakes
4. 10x magnification inspection of key details
5. Comparison to a known authentic reference coin
6. For anything over $200 – straight to the grading service

This combo caught nearly every fake in my testing. That $30 investment in a scale and loupe has saved me at least ten times that amount. Even after years of collecting, I still get fooled sometimes – but this method keeps the mistakes to a minimum.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Built and Scaled My SaaS Startup Using Lean Methodologies: A Founder’s Roadmap – From Zero to SaaS: How I Built and Scaled My Startup on a Shoestring Budget Let me tell you something most SaaS founders…
• Cartoon Character Coins: My Take on Collecting Pop Culture Numismatics – I’ve always been fascinated by how coin collecting crosses paths with pop culture, especially those pieces featuri…
• Lady Godiva: Unraveling Myth, Legend, and Numismatic Wonders – As a lifelong coin collector, I’ve always been drawn to pieces that blend captivating stories with tangible histor…