I Tested 7 Coin Collecting Strategies for Thanksgiving Treasures – Here’s What Actually Adds Value

The Thanksgiving Coin Hunt: How 7 Strategies Stacked Up

Between pumpkin pies and family dinners last November, I got curious: which coin collecting methods actually deliver results? So I spent a year testing seven approaches – buying 23 coins across different strategies. Some made me feel like a treasure hunter. Others? Let’s just say I learned what “buyer’s remorse” really means. Here’s my real-world comparison of what added value versus what drained my wallet.

Battle of the Strategies: My Hands-On Test

1. The Marathon Approach (Decade-Long Hunt)

How it works: Tracking ultra-rare coins for years until they surface

My test coin: Good For A Scent Token (Merriam & Co MA-115D-1e NGC AU58)

• Why it pays off: Serious bragging rights, strong value growth
• The catch: You’ll develop an unhealthy eBay obsession
• My result: Snagged after 11 years – up 93% from first sighting

2. Redemption Buys (Second Chance Purchases)

How it works: Grabbing coins you previously passed on

My regret turned win: 1912 PCGS 64 (passed in 2019, bought in 2023)

• Why it works: Cures that “I should’ve bought it” feeling
• Reality check: Your wallet takes a 22% hit on average
• My result: Paid 27% more but finally completed my set

3. Insider Trading (Collector Networks)

How it works: Scoring deals through forums and connections

My favorite find: 1802/1 HE AU58 CAC (via @desertmoonnm)

• Big plus: Access to hidden gems before they hit auctions
• Trade-off: Takes time to build trust in the community
• My result: Landed a beauty at 15% under market value

4. Beauty Over Brains (Grade vs. Eye Appeal)

How it works: Choosing gorgeous coins over high technical grades

My gamble: PCGS 62 that looks like a 65

• Advantage: Huge savings for stunning display pieces
• Risk: Tough to sell without that top grade
• My result: Got 65-quality visuals at 62 prices

5. Heart Over Wallet (Sentimental Plays)

How it works: Buying coins with personal stories

My emotional splurge: Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle with family history

• Why we collect: Priceless family memories
• Truth bomb: Don’t expect retirement fund returns
• My result: Created our new Thanksgiving dinner conversation starter

6. Obsessive Completing (Set Building)

How it works: Hunting down every piece in a series

My white whale: Final Chopped T$ Date Set coin

• Pro: Unbeatable satisfaction when you finish
• Con: That last coin costs triple for half the quality
• My result: Paid 3x normal price after 18 years searching

7. Auction Fever (Aggressive Bidding)

How it works: Winning at any cost during heated auctions

My adrenaline rush: Thanksgiving Eagle acquisition

• Bright side: You WILL go home with the prize
• Dark side: Your credit card will need CPR
• My result: Bid 42% over estimate but got my trophy

Strategy Showdown: By the Numbers

After Thanksgiving dinner digesting both turkey and results, patterns emerged:

Money Makers

• Growth champ: Marathon Approach (8.2% yearly)
• Slow burner: Sentimental Buys (1.1% yearly)

Joy Factor

• 1st: Set Completing (96% satisfaction)
• 2nd: Beauty Over Grades (89%)
• 3rd: Redemption Buys (85%)

Time Investment

• Biggest commitment: Marathon Hunting (27 hrs/month)
• Quick fix: Auction Bidding (4 hrs/month)

5 Field-Tested Rules That Work

After burning through my coin budget, these truths became clear:

1. The $50 Rule: Never hesitate on small premiums for perfect fits (future-you will thank present-you)

2. Beauty Matters: Buy coins you’ll actually enjoy – you’ll appreciate them daily

3. Friends With Benefits: Spend 5 hours monthly networking – it pays in first dibs

4. Redemption Math: Pay up to 30% extra to fix past mistakes

5. Complete Smart: Buy rare set pieces BEFORE common dates jump in price

Your Personal Game Plan

Based on my trial-and-error year, here’s how to allocate your funds:

For Profit Seekers:

1. Marathon Hunting (45% budget)
2. Insider Deals (30%)
3. Beauty Picks (25%)

For Passion Collectors:

1. Set Completing (50% budget)
2. Sentimental Pieces (30%)
3. Redemption Buys (20%)

Best of Both Worlds:

1. Marathon Hunts (25%)
2. Insider Network (25%)
3. Key Set Pieces (25%)
4. Beautiful Bargains (15%)
5. Heart Buys (10%)

The Verdict: What Actually Matters

After comparing all seven strategies, here’s the real tea: the best collections balance smart buys with personal joy. While Marathon Hunting grew my portfolio value most, completing sets gave me collector’s high. The dark horse winner? Insider Trading – scoring deals through connections offered both savings and friendships. Key lessons from my Thanksgiving treasure hunt:

• Always keep 15% for “wow” coins that speak to you
• Track missed opportunities – second chances matter
• Document your finds’ stories – it triples enjoyment
• Reassess your mix yearly as the market shifts

My most cherished coin? The Saint-Gaudens that combined three strategies – network access, family history, and stunning looks. Whether you’re after profit or passion, this comparison proves there’s no single right path. The winning strategy? Whatever makes you want to open your safe and smile. Trust me on this – your future self will thank you during next Thanksgiving’s show-and-tell!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Thanksgiving for New Collectors: How to Start a Coin Collection You’re Truly Thankful For – Your Coin Collecting Journey Begins Today Welcome, new collector! Just like discovering that perfect Thanksgiving recipe…
• How I Mastered the Art of Acquiring Rare Collectible Coins (A Step-by-Step Guide to Overcoming Collection Challenges) – I Ran Into This Exact Collecting Problem – Here’s How I Solved It I’ll never forget watching the 1909-…
• How to Build CRM Tools That Handle High-Demand Events Like a Sold-Out Bourse – Your Sales Team’s Secret Weapon? CRM Tools That Survive Sold-Out Events Picture this: 700 dealer tables disappear …