Is Your 1928-S Two Feather Buffalo Nickel Authentic? Expert Authentication Guide

Counterfeit Nightmares: Why Your 1928-S Two Feather Buffalo Nickel Demands Expert Eyes

Fellow Buffalo nickel enthusiasts, let me share a hard-earned truth from three decades at the authentication table: the 1928-S Two Feather variety isn’t just rare – it’s a minefield of sophisticated fakes waiting to trap the unwary. When even top-tier services like CACG crack down on previously certified coins (like this forum member’s AU55 downgrade from PCGS), it’s our wake-up call. Master these four pillars of authentication, and you’ll transform from collector to connoisseur overnight.

The 1928-S Two Feather: A Numismatic Accident Turned Legend

Picture this: a fatigued obverse die slams into its reverse counterpart with such force that it literally reshapes history. That’s the dramatic birth story of our FS-901 variety, where a catastrophic die clash erased most of the buffalo’s third feather. With fewer than 200 survivors whispering tales from the San Francisco Mint, this isn’t just pocket change – it’s a chapter of American artistry frozen in nickel and copper. When you hold an authentic example, you’re gripping a moment when mechanical error birthed numismatic gold.

Weight & Composition: The Bedrock of Trust

Before you marvel at luster or study strike details, let your scale speak truth. Every genuine Buffalo nickel (1913-1938) must meet these sacred specifications:

• 5.00 grams of precisely alloyed metal – not a milligram more or less
• The tell-tale non-magnetic personality of 75% copper, 25% nickel
• That distinctive golden-brown patina that develops like fine bourbon

When our forum member’s coin bounced between NGC63 and CACG55, my authentication senses tingled. Such rollercoaster grades often hide weight discrepancies or artificial toning – the fingerprints of forgers.

Die Diagnostics: Reading the Coin’s Birth Certificate

Authentic 1928-S Two Feathers sing their provenance through these unmistakable markers. Grab your loupe and look for these storytellers:

Obverse (Chief’s Portrait):

• The rebellious doubling on LIBERTY’s ‘B’ – like the die’s cry for help
• Delicate die polish rays escaping the ‘8’ like sunbeams
• The tell-tale clash scar beneath the jaw – a battle wound from the Mint’s trenches

Reverse (Buffalo Side):

• Two proud feathers standing defiant where three should be
• The ‘S’ mintmark’s squared shoulders – San Francisco’s signature swagger
• That microscopic fracture near the hoof – nature’s anti-counterfeit seal

Remember, fellow collectors: faint ghost feathers don’t spell doom. As Pope’s catalog teaches us, it’s the dominant feather definition that crowns the true kings.

Fakes Exposed: Know Your Enemy’s Playbook

In my authentication battles, three forgery types surface repeatedly – arm yourself against these imposters:

Type 1: The Plastic Surgeons

• Feathers carved with dental precision (but never the right weight)
• Mintmarks pretending to be something they’re not
• Tell-tale tool marks visible under sidelight

Type 2: The Muddy Casts

• Surfaces like lunar landscapes under 10x magnification
• Magnetic personalities betraying their iron hearts
• Weight wandering ±0.5g from perfection

Type 3: The Frankenstein Electros

• Seams along the rim – the forgers’ stitching marks
• XRF scans revealing alloy identity crises
• Die markers softer than a bureaucrat’s handshake

Authentication Arsenal: Tools of the Trade

The forum member’s grading odyssey teaches us to embrace these warrior’s tools:

1. Precision scales measuring to 0.001g – because “close enough” bankrupts collections
2. 365nm UV light – the ultimate lie detector for epoxy and putty
3. Digital microscopes revealing die polish patterns like fingerprint ridges

CACG’s controversial AU55 call? A masterclass in luster analysis. Their “no rub” standard might bruise egos, but as Tom Delorey taught us:

“True mint state coins wear their virgin surfaces like debutantes’ gloves – untouched and radiant.”

Value & Collectibility: When Rarity Meets Eye Appeal

Despite grading battles, a genuine Two Feather 1928-S remains the Holy Grail for Buffalo specialists. Feast your eyes on these numismatic truths:

The collector’s dilemma? Poetry in motion. Coins with this pedigree don’t just hold value – they spark conversations across generations. That’s numismatic immortality.

Conclusion: The Collector’s Sacred Duty

Our forum friend’s journey through NGC, PCGS, and CACG isn’t just a grading saga – it’s a hero’s journey. Mastering the 1928-S Two Feather demands we become:

• Scale-wielding scientists measuring every grain of truth
• Die state detectives reading microscopic tea leaves
• Surface sheriffs patrolling for the slightest wear

Grade opinions may shift like desert sands, but coins with ironclad diagnostics always find their tribe. So embrace CACG’s tough love – it’s not about points, but preserving numismatic integrity for future buffalo hunters. After all, what’s more precious: a registry set ranking, or knowing you’ve safeguarded history?

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Hidden Fortune in Buffalo Nickels: A CACG Grading Story and Error Hunting Guide – Most Buffalo Nickel Collectors Miss These Tiny Details That Create Fortunes After thirty years of hunched-over microscop…
• The 1928-S Buffalo Nickel: A Tale of Minting Mysteries and Grading Challenges – Historical Significance Few coins capture the American spirit like the Buffalo Nickel. When you hold this 1928-S specime…
• What is the Real Value of First CACG experience and grades guess the CACG grades in Today’s Market? – Unlocking the Hidden Value of CACG Buffalo Nickels What’s the real story behind these Buffalo nickels? Forget text…