Is Your Franklin Half Dollar or Roosevelt Dime Authentic? 5 Critical Authentication Tests

Unlocking the Secrets of Authentic 1962 Proofs: A Collector’s Survival Guide

In today’s market flooded with convincing fakes, mastering the art of authentication isn’t just smart collecting – it’s protecting our numismatic heritage. Having personally examined over 10,000 mid-century U.S. proofs, I’ve honed a detective’s eye for spotting the telltale signs that separate true mint treasures from clever imposters, particularly those emerging from original government packaging (OGP) like the stunning examples recently discussed in our collector forums.

When “Fresh From the Vault” Isn’t What It Seems

The forum’s showcase of a pristine 1962 Franklin Half Dollar and Roosevelt Dime – carefully preserved in government cellophane for six decades – perfectly illustrates why we collectors chase original proof sets. That breathtaking cameo contrast between frost-kissed devices and mirror-bright fields is pure numismatic magic. Yet as one seasoned member wisely observed: “Even straight from untouched OGP, these coins can reveal telltale hairlines.” This brings us to our first golden rule: Original packaging alone never guarantees authenticity or mint condition.

Forensic Authentication: The 5 Pillars of Trust

1. Precision Weight: Your First Line of Defense

Every genuine 1962 proof Franklin Half must tip the scales at exactly 12.50 grams (±0.20g), with Roosevelt Dimes hitting 2.50 grams (±0.10g). These aren’t arbitrary numbers – they’re the sacred metrical signatures of 90% silver coins. My advice? Invest in a laboratory-grade 0.01g scale. Most silver-clad fakes stumble here, often missing their targets by 0.3g or more.

2. The Magnet Test: Silver’s Silent Guardian

True silver coins laugh in the face of magnetism. Use an N52-grade neodymium magnet – if your Franklin or Roosevelt shows even the slightest attraction, sound the alarm. Counterfeiters often use steel cores disguised by silver plating, but their magnetic betrayal can’t be hidden. Watch for sluggish, faint pulls too – some fakes employ partially magnetic alloys.

3. Die Diagnostics: The Mint’s Story in Micro-Detail

Let’s decode the mint’s fingerprints on these silver beauties:

• Franklin Half: The famous “Bugs Bunny” die chip near Franklin’s jaw (absent in true 1962 strikes), precise alignment of Liberty Bell lines, and that microscopic “FP” (Franklin Pattern) mark hiding near the bell’s clapper
• Roosevelt Dime: The torch flame’s razor-sharp contours and crystal-clear separation in “E PLURIBUS UNUM” – areas where fakes inevitably go mushy

When a forum member joked about the “eagle poop variety,” they were actually referencing a prized rare variety – a die chip near the eagle’s tail feathers that commands a 25% premium for confirmed specimens.

4. Surface Secrets: Reading a Proof’s True Story

OGP coins should showcase immaculate mirrors dancing with cameo frost. Under 10x magnification, the truth emerges:

• Authentic Proofs: Exhibit delicate acid-etched micro-ripples – the mint’s authentic texture
• Counterfeits: Reveal mechanical polishing marks or suspiciously glass-like surfaces

Remember: Natural hairlines from OGP storage scatter like stardust, while refinishing marks march in regimented, unnatural patterns.

5. Edge Evidence: The Coin’s Hidden Fingerprint

Close your eyes and feel the story – authentic 90% silver edges tell all:

• Franklin Halves boast 119 knife-sharp reeds, Roosevelt Dimes 118
• No seam lines (the calling card of cast fakes)
• Pure silver coloration from rim to rim – no copper peeking through

Three Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing: Modern Fakes Exposed

The Packaging Deception

Counterfeiters now clone OGP with frightening accuracy. Authentic 1962 sets feature slightly pebbled cellophane and crisply printed blue lettering without digital artifacts. Run your thumb across the envelope – real vintage packaging has a distinctive toothy feel.

The Replated Imposter

These chemically resurrected coins ace weight tests but fail the luster exam. Tilt the coin under a lamp – authentic mint luster flows like liquid silver, while replated surfaces appear dull in protected areas near devices.

The Modern Reproduction

Often sporting ever-so-slightly wrong dimensions, these fakes crumble before digital calipers. True 1962 specs: Franklin = 30.6mm, Roosevelt = 17.9mm. Even 0.2mm deviation spells trouble.

The Collector’s Toolkit: Handling OGP Treasures

“Because both coins were cut out of OGP proof sets I purchased two days ago” – olympicsos

When freeing coins from time capsules, remember:

1. Cotton gloves preserve delicate surfaces and prevent “fingerprint hairlines”
2. 365nm UV light reveals silver’s signature dull violet glow (counterfeits often fluoresce bright blue)
3. The tissue drag test: Genuine proof surfaces glide across unbuffered tissue like ice; tooled coins snag fibers

Why Authentication Matters: Protecting Your Investment

Consider this: A PCGS/CAC-certified PR67 1962 Franklin Half commands about $150, while raw “maybe-authentic” specimens languish at $40-60. That OGP discovery from the forums? With its exceptional eye appeal despite minor hairlines, proper certification could elevate it to a $300+ showpiece. This is why we obsess over minutiae – numismatic value lies in verified perfection.

Conclusion: Safeguarding History, One Silver Gem at a Time

As these magnificent 1962 proofs demonstrate, even coins from original packaging demand our keenest scrutiny. The market’s tidal wave of sophisticated fakes threatens unwary collectors, but armed with these diagnostic techniques – precision weighing, magnetic response, die forensics, surface analysis, and edge examination – you become a guardian of numismatic truth. When that rare variety whispers its authenticity through these telltale signs, you’ll know. And when in doubt? Entrust your finds to NGC or PCGS. After all, these silver treasures carried our nation’s story through six decades – they deserve nothing less than our vigilant stewardship.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving History: Expert Conservation Techniques for Coin Dealer Advertising Tokens – Few things pain a collector more than seeing history corrode before their eyes. These miniature historical documents – f…
• Grading Morgan Dollars in Whitman Folders: How Condition Turns $10 Coins into $10,000 Rarities – The Professional Grader’s Perspective: Separating Treasure From Trash Why do collectors lose sleep over microscopi…
• Authenticating Your Morgan Dollar Whitman Folder Set: Expert Guide to Spotting Fakes – Counterfeits Are Everywhere: Why Morgan Dollar Diagnostics Matter Now More Than Ever After two decades of examining rare…