Is Your Morgan Dollar Real? Expert Authentication Guide for Collectors

Historical Significance

The Morgan Silver Dollar, minted from 1878 to 1904 and again in 1921, stands as one of America’s most beloved coin series. Named after its designer, George T. Morgan, these coins were produced at five different mints: Philadelphia (no mint mark), New Orleans (O), San Francisco (S), Carson City (CC), and Denver (D) for the 1921 issue. With millions produced across various dates and mint marks, Morgan dollars offer collectors a rich field for study and collection, with numismatic values ranging from modest to extraordinary.

Why Authentication Matters

With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for this iconic series is critical. The value of authentic Morgan dollars ranges from modest to extraordinary, with rare dates like the 1889-CC commanding premium prices. As evidenced by recent forum discussions, collectors are constantly acquiring new specimens, making authentication knowledge essential for every enthusiast seeking to protect their investment.

Weight and Physical Specifications

Authentic Morgan dollars have precise specifications that serve as your first line of defense against counterfeits:

• Weight: 26.73 grams (412.5 grains)
• Diameter: 38.1 mm (1.5 inches)
• Composition: 90% silver, 10% copper
• Edge: Reeded (177 reeds)

Any significant deviation from these specifications should raise immediate red flags. Modern counterfeiters have improved their techniques, but most fakes still fail basic weight tests. A precision scale accurate to 0.01 grams is an essential tool for any serious collector building a collection of mint condition specimens.

Magnetic Properties Test

Authentic Morgan dollars are non-magnetic due to their 90% silver composition. This simple test can quickly identify many fakes:

• Authentic: Non-magnetic (will not attract to magnet)
• Common Fakes: Often magnetic due to steel or iron cores

While not foolproof—some sophisticated counterfeits use non-magnetic metals—this test eliminates many obvious fakes instantly. Keep a strong magnet handy when examining potential purchases to protect your investment.

Die Markers and Design Details

Expert authentication requires knowledge of specific die markers and design details. Each date and mint mark combination has unique characteristics that affect collectibility:

Key Design Elements

The obverse features Lady Liberty in profile wearing a Phrygian cap with the motto “E PLURIBUS UNUM” above. The reverse displays an eagle with outstretched wings, clutching arrows and an olive branch, with “IN GOD WE TRUST” above the eagle’s head.

Common Die Varieties

Certain dates are known for specific die varieties. For example, 1878 Morgan dollars exist in seven tail feather varieties and two reverse varieties. The 1878-S has distinct characteristics that differ from Philadelphia-minted examples, with each variety commanding different market values.

High-Relief vs. Low-Relief

Early 1878 Morgans were struck in high relief, creating a different appearance than later issues. The high-relief coins show more detail but were discontinued due to stacking issues in banks, making them particularly desirable to collectors seeking rare varieties.

Common Fakes and Counterfeits

Understanding the types of counterfeits helps collectors avoid costly mistakes:

Cast Counterfeits

These are made by creating molds from genuine coins. They often show:

• Pitting or porosity on the surface
• Soft, indistinct details
• Incorrect weight (usually lighter)
• Often magnetic due to core materials

Struck Counterfeits

More sophisticated fakes created using transfer dies or unauthorized dies. These can be challenging to detect and may:

• Have correct weight
• Show proper details
• Require expert examination

Altered Dates and Mint Marks

Collectors should be particularly cautious with rare dates like 1889-CC or 1893-S. Common alterations include:

• Changing 1898 to appear as 1893
• Adding or modifying mint marks
• Tool marks around date or mint mark areas

Professional Authentication Methods

While basic tests can identify obvious fakes, professional authentication provides certainty:

Third-Party Grading Services

PCGS and NGC are the most respected grading services. As discussed in the forum, early PCGS holders (“rattlers”) from 1986 are particularly collectible. A first-generation white label PCGS holder with cert #1080017 recently sold for $119,062, demonstrating the value collectors place on early authentication and the importance of provenance.

Die Variety Attribution

Services like VAMworld specialize in Morgan dollar die varieties. Each die marriage has unique characteristics that can be identified by experts, with some varieties commanding significant premiums due to their rarity.

Advanced Testing

Professional services may employ:

• X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analysis for composition verification
• Microscopic examination of surface characteristics
• Die state analysis

Visual Examination Techniques

Even without professional equipment, collectors can perform detailed visual examinations:

Luster and Surface Quality

Authentic Morgans exhibit distinctive cartwheel luster when rotated under light. Counterfeits often lack this characteristic sheen or show unnatural toning patterns that affect eye appeal and value.

Edge Examination

The reeded edge should be consistent and complete. Cast counterfeits often show weakness or irregularities at the edge, a telltale sign of forgery.

Strike Quality

Genuine Morgans show full, sharp details in high points. Weakness in expected areas or overly sharp details in protected areas may indicate problems that affect both authenticity and grade.

Building Your Authentication Skills

The forum discussions reveal collectors at various experience levels sharing their acquisitions. Here are tips for developing your authentication expertise:

1. Handle genuine coins regularly to develop familiarity with weight and feel
2. Invest in basic testing equipment: scale, magnet, calipers
3. Study certified examples to understand proper details and grading standards
4. Join collector communities to share knowledge and experiences
5. When in doubt, seek professional authentication

Conclusion

The Morgan Silver Dollar remains one of America’s most collected coins, with values ranging from affordable common dates to six-figure rarities. As the forum posts demonstrate, collectors are constantly acquiring new specimens, from raw coins to certified examples in various holders. Whether you’re building a date set, collecting by mint mark, or seeking high-grade specimens, authentication knowledge is essential.

Remember that even experienced collectors rely on professional authentication for valuable specimens. The market for early PCGS holders shows how authentication itself has become collectible. By mastering the techniques outlined in this guide—from basic weight and magnetic tests to understanding die markers and seeking professional authentication—you’ll be well-equipped to build a collection of genuine Morgan dollars that will bring satisfaction for years to come.

Happy collecting, and may all your Morgans be genuine!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How to Spot Rare Errors on Morgan Silver Dollars: A Collector’s Guide – Introduction: The Devil is in the Details Most people look right past the tiny details that can turn a common item into …
• The Hidden History Behind America’s Most Iconic Silver Dollar: The Morgan Dollar – Every Relic Tells a Story Every relic tells a story. To understand this item, we have to look at the era in which it was…
• What is the Real Value of Post your new Morgan images in Today’s Market? – Introduction: Understanding Morgan Dollar Market Values Determining the true value of Morgan dollars requires looking pa…