Market Analysis: CACG Grading Results and Value Assessment for Buffalo Nickels

Introduction: The Thrill of True Value in Buffalo Nickels

What separates a good Buffalo nickel from a great one? As a collector who’s handled thousands of these American classics, I can tell you it’s not just about the numbers in a price guide. Let’s examine how CACG’s grading impacts market realities for these two exceptional coins, comparing them to their PCGS counterparts with the keen eye of someone who lives and breathes numismatics.

Coin #1: 1928-S Buffalo Nickel – A Study in Scarcity

The 1928-S Buffalo nickel sets collectors’ hearts racing for good reason. With just 6.4 million struck – practically a sneeze in minting terms – finding one with strong eye appeal feels like uncovering buried treasure. What truly elevates its numismatic value? The perfect storm of low mintage and heavy circulation means specimens boasting original luster and crisp strikes command serious attention.

Grading Insights That Shape Value

Seasoned collectors in our forum debate spotted telltale signs of circulation: that subtle rub on the buffalo’s noble cheekbone and front leg that whispers “AU55” rather than shouting “mint state.” This distinction matters tremendously. In today’s market, that single grade difference between AU55 and AU58 isn’t just academic – it’s the gap between an accessible key date and a premium showpiece.

Current Market Reality Check

Recent auction hammer prices prove this series remains red-hot. Let’s break down what collectors actually pay:

• VF20: $25-35 (honest wear tells its story)
• XF40: $60-80 (starting to show its true character)
• AU50: $150-200 (teasing mint-state allure)
• AU55: $300-400 (our coin’s sweet spot)
• AU58: $800-1,200 (bridging the gap to perfection)
• MS60: $2,500-3,000 (true blue-chip territory)
• MS63: $6,000-8,000 (for the connoisseur)

At AU55, this 1928-S offers the perfect balance – substantial history visible in its patina, yet enough detail to showcase Fraser’s iconic design. It’s the savvy collector’s choice for series building without breaking the bank.

Coin #2: 1913-S Type 1 – The Holy Grail of Buffalo Nickels

Hold your breath – we’re entering rarified air. The 1913-S Type 1 (raised mound) Buffalo nickel’s mintage of just 2.1 million makes even seasoned collectors weak in the knees. This isn’t just another coin; it’s a numismatic landmark where history, artistry, and scarcity converge.

The Devil’s in the Design Details

That raised mound beneath the buffalo’s hooves? It’s more than a design element – it’s a time capsule from the brief window before the Mint hastily reworked the model. Our forum sharp-eyed members confirmed this crucial Type 1 attribution, but noted the characteristic softness on Black Diamond’s head – a feature that gives this issue its personality while challenging eye appeal.

Investment-Grade Performance

When a 1913-S Type 1 crosses the auction block, bidding wars erupt. Current valuations tell the tale:

• G4: $300-400 (a battered beauty)
• F12: $600-800 (building character)
• VF20: $1,200-1,500 (commanding attention)
• XF40: $2,500-3,000 (approaching elite status)
• MS60: $8,000-10,000 (museum-worthy)
• MS63: $15,000-18,000 (portfolio centerpiece)
• MS65: $35,000-40,000 (the pinnacle)

Our MS63-64 contender sits squarely in “statement piece” territory. Yes, the soft reverse strike might trim 10-15% off its potential – but that’s the poetry of numismatics. Each imperfection tells a story of 1913’s minting challenges.

CACG vs. PCGS: The New Frontier in Attribution

The collector’s journey with these coins reveals a sea change in our hobby. While PCGS and NGC remain gold standards, CACG’s razor focus on accurate variety attribution – particularly for series like Buffalo nickels – is winning converts. For these coins, proper identification isn’t just academic; it’s value-defining.

That two-feather versus three-feather debate on the 1928-S? That’s where CACG’s specialists earn their keep. And correctly distinguishing Type 1 from Type 2 on the 1913-S? That’s the difference between a premium coin and an ordinary date. This is where the future of collecting meets traditional numismatic rigor.

Why Buffalo Nickels Keep Winning Hearts (and Portfolios)

After three decades tracking this market, I’ve seen Buffalo nickels weather every economic storm. Their enduring collectibility rests on three pillars:

The Scarcity Factor

Time is the ultimate grader. A century of circulation has winnowed high-grade Buffalo nickels to a precious few survivors. For the 1913-S Type 1, finding one with strong luster and minimal bag marks feels like holding history itself.

Demand Dynamics

From type collectors to completists chasing the “Big Five” keys, Buffalo nickels offer something rare: approachable entry points and Everest-grade challenges in one iconic series. These coins bridge generations of numismatists.

The Tangible Asset Edge

When markets wobble, collectors turn to series with proven staying power. Certified Buffalo nickels combine historical significance with portability and liquidity – the trifecta of smart tangible investing.

The Attribution Revolution

CACG’s emergence creates healthy competition where collectors win. Their laser focus on proper variety identification – whether it’s that elusive two-feather strike or confirming a true Type 1 – adds layers of value traditional grading sometimes overlooks.

The Authentication Imperative

In the rarefied air where these coins live, trust is everything. The 1913-S Type 1 ranks among the most counterfeited U.S. coins – which makes third-party verification non-negotiable. Forum members saw no red flags, but that expert consensus is precisely why we grade.

For the 1928-S, the two-feather attribution debate highlights why we collect: the thrill of discovery, the satisfaction of expert consensus. Whether CACG’s call holds up to scrutiny, the discussion itself enriches our hobby.

Final Verdict: Collecting With Wisdom

After living with these coins through photographs and provenance, here’s my heartfelt assessment: The 1928-S at AU55 represents the sweet spot for collectors wanting a meaningful key date without stratospheric premiums. At $300-400, it’s a cornerstone coin that anchors any Buffalo nickel collection.

The 1913-S Type 1? At MS63-64 and $15,000-25,000, we’re discussing a legacy piece. Yes, the reverse strike may cost it 10-15%, but that’s the poetry of numismatics – perfection isn’t always the point. Sometimes it’s about owning a tangible piece of 1913 minting history.

To fellow collectors I say this: These coins remind us why we pursue this passion. Beyond metallic content and price guides, we preserve artistry, history, and the human stories stamped into every surface. Whether you’re holding an AU55 warrior or an MS63 masterpiece, you’re keeping American numismatic heritage alive – one buffalo at a time.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• When Metal Content Trumps Collector Value: Understanding Machine Doubling in Classic Coins – The Bullion Investor’s Dilemma: Metal Content vs. Collector Premium What’s more valuable – the silver …
• Hunting Machine Doubling Miracles in Circulation: The Roll Hunter’s Ultimate Guide – You don’t need a dealer to experience that heart-pounding rush of discovery. As someone who’s sorted through…
• Preserving Machine Doubling Errors: Expert Conservation Strategies for Numismatic Treasures – The Fragile Nature of Doubled Die Variants Nothing breaks a collector’s heart faster than seeing a prized machine-…