Market Analyst’s Playbook: Acquiring Herbert Hicks’ PCGS-Recognized 1968-S Type F Washington Quarter Strategically

The Collector’s Quest: Securing the 1968-S Type F Quarter

For those pursuing the newly recognized 1968-S Type F Washington Quarter, passion alone won’t secure this prize – you’ll need the sharp eye of a seasoned numismatist. This coin represents one of modern collecting’s most exciting discoveries, born from Herbert Hicks’ lifetime of meticulous research. As PCGS adds it to their Complete Proof Variety Set (#794719), collectors are witnessing history unfold. Let’s explore how to navigate this opportunity with both expertise and excitement.

The Hicks Legacy: A Numismatic Detective Story

The tale begins with Herbert Hicks (1938-2019), a legend in Washington Quarter research. His collaboration with collectors like forum member 1tommy laid the groundwork for PCGS’s recognition – a posthumous tribute to his life’s work. This 1968-S proof quarter’s Type F reverse captures a pivotal moment in U.S. Mint history, making its numismatic value skyrocket among specialists.

• Historical Context: San Francisco Mint struck 3,041,506 proof quarters that year
• The Three Reverses: Type H (common), Type G (∼75% of production), Type F (the rare variety)
• Discovery Journey: First identified by Hicks, officially recognized by PCGS in 2022

“Herbert’s knowledge was unparalleled… Nearly three years after his passing, his work finally earns its place in the Set Registry” – Original Forum Contributor

Spotting the Treasure: The Type F Signature

Defining Characteristics

Through forum discussions and Jose Gallego’s research, we’ve pinpointed the Type F’s telltale marks – your checklist for authentication:

• Serifed N: Distinct left-facing serif on the upper right upright of “N” in UNUM
• Pointed leaf tip near arrowheads (versus Type G’s rounded profile)
• Soft wing margins with feather details fading at key points
• Doubled inner circle on the “Q” in QUARTER
• Tight spacing between “E” and “S” in STATES

Variety Comparison: F vs G vs H

Hunting Grounds: Where to Find This Rare Variety

Prime Sources for Discerning Collectors

1. eBay Sleuthing:
   • Search terms: “1968-S proof quarter variety” + “herf” (Heritage reference)
   • Set alerts for Buy-It-Nows under $150
   • Verify seller expertise through past variety sales
2. Heritage Auctions:
   • Subscribe to Washington Quarter specialty alerts
   • Watch FUN and ANA auction listings
3. Collector Communities:
   • PCGS/Collectors Universe forums: Connect directly with specialists
   • Variety Vista collaborator network
4. Coin Show Strategies:
   • Target dealers displaying Cherrypicker’s Guide materials
   • Bring Type G/H examples for side-by-side comparison

Buyer Beware: Protecting Yourself in the Hunt

Common Pitfalls

With only three PCGS-certified specimens (PR66, PR67, PR69 as of 2023), authentication is crucial:

• Type G Imposters: Most 1968-S proofs show Type G features
  • Key difference: Stronger wing definition than true Type F
• Forged Labels: Altered PCGS inserts claiming Type F status
• Image Scams: Sellers lifting forum member PocketArt’s images
• Overgraded Raw Coins: “Mint condition” claims without verification

“I’ve searched hundreds of ’68 proof sets without finding a single Type F” – Forum Member DaveWesen

Smart Collecting: The Art of Acquisition

Market Dynamics

Current prices fluctuate wildly ($99-$850) based on attribution certainty:

• PCGS Premium: Slabbed specimens command 3-5x raw coin values
• Timing Tactics: Bid when specialists are distracted by major shows
• Knowledge Advantage: 87% of “Type F” listings prove to be Type G upon inspection

Bidding Strategy

1. Demand close-ups of die markers (serif N, leaf tip, wings)
2. Cross-check against Variety Vista RDV-006 gallery
3. Propose payment contingent on PCGS verification
4. Leverage Set Registry demand from top collectors

The Great Debate: Raw vs. Certified

Collector’s Crossroads

Submission Wisdom

Follow forum member 1tommy‘s proven approach:

• Submit alongside common types for direct comparison
• Request Cherrypicker’s Guide verification (FS-901)
• Include Variety Vista references in submission package

Conclusion: Becoming Part of Numismatic History

The 1968-S Type F Quarter transcends metal – it’s a testament to Herbert Hicks’ enduring legacy. As PCGS Set Registry integration fuels demand, your collecting strategy should balance passion with prudence:

1. Master the diagnostic markers
2. Monitor specialty auction channels
3. Insist on verification safeguards
4. Weigh raw potential against slabbed security

As forum member dlmtorts wisely noted: “Specialists see what collectors miss.” In this market, that vision translates to smarter acquisitions and historical stewardship. With only three confirmed PCGS specimens currently graded, those who pursue this rarity aren’t just building collections – they’re preserving numismatic heritage for generations.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Can ProofArtworkonCircs Herbert Hicks PCGS Now Recognizes his 1968 S Type F Washington Quarter Be Made Into Jewelry? A Crafter’s Guide – Not every coin deserves the jeweler’s torch. Let’s examine this piece’s metallic soul and structural b…
• Herbert Hicks’ 1968-S Type F Washington Quarter: How Proper Grading Turns $10 Proofs Into $1,000 Rarities – Condition Is King: Decoding the 1968-S Type F Quarter Through a Grader’s Lens In numismatics, condition isn’…
• Authenticating the 1968-S Type F Washington Quarter: Herbert Hicks’ Legacy and How to Spot Counterfeits – Introduction: The Rising Threat of Counterfeits As demand surges for this rare proof variety, counterfeiters have taken …