Mexico City Pillar Dollar Mystery: Diagnosing Pitting, Blobs & Counterfeit Red Flags

The Authentication Crisis in Colonial Coinage: Protect Your Collection

In today’s flooded market, mastering the telltale signs of genuine Spanish Colonial Pillar Dollars isn’t just smart collecting – it’s essential armor. Take last month’s bombshell discovery: an NGC-certified ‘AU Details’ Mexico City 8 Reales with suspicious pitting that left even veteran numismatists scratching their heads. With two decades spent studying every strike and patina on these colonial treasures, I’ll walk you through the forensic markers separating history from deception.

Why Forgers Love Pillar Dollars: A Target Through Time

Born between 1732-1772 in mints stretching from Mexico to Lima, Pillar Dollars (columnarios) weren’t just coins – they were the lifeblood of global trade. Their .9167 silver purity and dramatic Pillars of Hercules design made them the ultimate status symbol, attracting counterfeiters then and now. Modern fakers exploit this legacy, artificially aging replicas to target collectors chasing that sweet spot between numismatic value and affordability. As forum sage @SimonW warned:

“Never assume a slabbed pillar’s safe. The best Chinese forgeries mimic XF-AU wear patterns with frightening accuracy.”

The Collector’s Survival Guide: 5 Diagnostic Checks

1. Weight & Magnetism – First Line of Defense

Genuine Mexico City 8 Reales should feel substantial in your palm – 26.86g to 27.47g substantial. Any deviation beyond half a gram warrants suspicion. Always keep a rare earth magnet handy; authentic silver coins laugh at magnets while modern alloy fakes cling desperately. Though NGC certification suggests proper weight, true guardians of the hobby double-check.

2. Die Markers – The Mint’s Hidden Signature

Mexico Mint coins whisper secrets through these features:

• Assayer Initials: Sharp ‘MF’, ‘FM’, or ‘FF’ huddled near the crown like royal guards
• Column Texture: Authentic dies left fingerprint-like horizontal lines at pillar bases
• Flow Lines: Radiating metallic “sunburst” patterns from the coin’s heart

The forum’s heated debate over “metal blobs” near the columns? As one member astutely noted:

“Could be die rust, poor alloy, or damage – but fakes never get the progression right.”

True die deterioration tells a story across multiple strikes, while counterfeit flaws look like random vandalism.

3. Pitting Patterns – Nature’s Autograph vs. Forger’s Smudge

When forum members argued over concentrated pitting, they tapped into numismatics’ great divide:

The thread’s star observation rings true:

“Annealing pitting respects the devices – metal flow protects raised areas during striking.”

Exactly what we see in the OP’s field-focused imperfections.

4. Surface Blobs – Beauty Marks or Frankenstein Scars?

Those mysterious seed-sized bumps in the photos? Here’s how to read them:

Genuine quirks include:

• Die Rust: Sandy texture, never discrete lumps
• Lamination Errors: Delicate metallic “peeling” like ancient parchment

Counterfeit giveaways:

• Casting Bubbles: Perfectly round imposters screaming “modern cast!”
• Tooling Marks: Harsh, angular additions where no mint hand touched

Compare to the Lima 4R example in the thread – its surface tells a coherent story of age, not a forger’s checklist.

The Chinese AU Onslaught: Know Your Enemy

Today’s most dangerous fakes target mid-grade collectors with chilling precision:

• Weight Wizardry: 27.0g ±0.2g – the Goldilocks zone of deception
• Patina Puppeteers: Chemical toning hiding casting’s sins
• Laser Sorcery: Micro-pitted dies mimicking authentic wear

Hailing primarily from Guangdong, these .800 silver wolves in sheep’s clothing pass basic tests but crumble under a loupe’s stare.

Beyond the Slab: The Collector’s Arsenal

1. Loupe Warfare (10X Minimum): Hunt for:
   • Die mark “clones” across multiple coins
   • Micro-bubble constellations hiding in plain sight
   • Tooling scars on the crown (like OP’s suspect)
2. Edge Archaeology: Authentic pillars boast:
   • Denticles spaced like soldiers on parade
   • Crisp edge lettering shouting “hand-engraved!”
   • No casting seams – the forgers’ fatal footprint
3. Specific Gravity Trial: True coins sink to 10.30-10.42
4. Ultrasonic Truth Serum: Professional-grade revelation of hidden sins

Conclusion: The Thrill of the Real

While our Mexico City contender shows promising signs of authenticity (those field pits know their place!), those unexplained blobs remain like uninvited guests at a numismatic ball. As one sharp-eyed forum member mused:

“Localized pitting? That’s the universe testing how badly we want to believe.”

Never rely solely on encapsulation – cross-reference NGC images with hands-on scrutiny. When verified, AU-details Pillar Dollars aren’t just metal; they’re time machines. Prices currently dance between $1,200 for Mexico’s common dates to $5,000+ for Lima’s rare varieties. In the end, collecting colonial coinage isn’t about avoiding risk – it’s about arming yourself with enough knowledge to make risk irrelevant.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Unearthing Hidden Treasures: Expert Guide to Error Detection on Pillar Dollars – The Hidden Fortune in Flaws: Why Error Hunters Obsess Over Pillar Dollars While most see only age and wear, seasoned col…
• The Silent Testimony of Pitting: Decoding a Mexican Pillar Dollar’s Colonial Legacy – Every relic whispers its secrets to those who listen. When you hold this NGC-graded Pillar Dollar with its distinctive p…
• Pitting & Profit: Decoding the Market Value of NGC-Graded Spanish Colonial Pillar Dollars – The Appraiser’s Dilemma: When Flaws Tell a Story Hold that Pillar Dollar to the light – how do you separate …