My 6-Month Obsession With Lincoln’s Final Cents: A Collector’s Hard-Won Lessons

For six months, my kitchen table disappeared beneath coin tubes and magnifying glasses. Let me share what my Lincoln cent obsession taught me – the hard way.

The Grocery Store Wake-Up Call

I’ll never forget paying for milk with a full roll of pennies as the last circulation strikes were minted. The cashier’s eye-roll mirrored my own realization: These weren’t just coins anymore. That afternoon, I spread out my grandfather’s wheat cents and made a vow – I’d document the end of an era before these tiny copper time capsules vanished forever.

3 Mistakes That Cost Me $1,427

1. Shiny ≠ Valuable

The first month, I blew $300 on “BU” (Brilliant Uncirculated) 2020 pennies before finding Grandpa’s scratched 1909-S VDB in an old tobacco tin. That worn cent sparked my real education after a Chicago dealer offered me $800 cash on the spot. I learned collectors pay for stories, not shine.

2. Mint Errors ≠ Damage

My hands still shake remembering how I almost traded a 1955 Double Die cent for a common silver dollar. “Kid, that’s not damage – that’s retirement money,” a grizzled dealer growled, showing me:

• The telltale “split doubling” on LIBERTY
• Flow lines frozen in the metal
• The thickness difference between real errors and mechanical doubling

3. Pockets Kill Value

That “pristine” 2017-S cent I carried for good luck? After 18 months rubbing against my keys, it graded VF-20. Now I protect my finds like museum pieces:

My Storage Setup: Cotton gloves for handling + Saflips for display + Dessicant-packed ammo cans (yes, really) for long-term storage

The Real Lincoln Cent Hall of Fame

1909-S VDB: The Million-Dollar Initials

Tracking this legend became my winter obsession. Why does a penny smaller than your thumbnail command $2,000+ even when worn smooth? Three reasons gripped me:

• Victor David Brenner’s initials got scraped off mid-production
• San Francisco made just 484,000 vs. Philly’s 28 million
• Americans lined up blocks to get them in 1909 – I found photos!

2017-S: My 73-Day Hunt

This proof-only cent broke me. Only 210,419 exist, mostly sealed in government sets. After striking out with 4 eBay sellers, I finally landed one through:

• A 3 AM CoinTalk forum alert
• Cross-country dealer networking
• Verifying the “frosted” Lincoln portrait under 10x magnification

My Authentication Cheat Sheet:
1. Proof fields: mirrors finish
2. Raised elements: frosted texture
3. Edge: razor-sharp (no wear)
4. Weight: precisely 2.5g

The Penny Apocalypse Price Tracker

When minting stopped, the market went wild. Here’s what my spreadsheet recorded:

This volatility taught me to focus on:

1. First-year issues (1909)
2. Final-year strikes (2023)
3. Metal change years (1943 steel, 1982 zinc)

Turning Pennies Into Time Machines

Holding a 1910 cent with thread-thin Lincoln details, I realized: These outlived two World Wars. My preservation routine became ritual:

Digital Immortality

Using my DSLR and lightbox, I created “coin passports”:

• 40-megapixel obverse/reverse shots
• 360° edge scans
• Yearly condition comparison overlays

The Story Project

Each cent now gets a mini-biography. My favorite:

“1943 Steel Cent – Pulled from USS Arizona wreckage debris in 2002. Still smells faintly of Pearl Harbor saltwater.”

Why You Should Save Pennies Now

After 387 cents and one very patient spouse, I see coins differently. They’re:

• History You Can Hold: My 1943 steel cent survived WWII rationing
• Inflation Calculators: That 1909 penny bought a loaf of bread – now it buys dinner for two
• Family Time Capsules: My kids fight over who’ll inherit Grandpa’s tobacco tin collection

The last Lincoln cents aren’t the end – they’re your chance to grab living history before it slips into collector vaults forever. Start looking in your couch cushions tonight.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 5 Critical Mistakes That Make Dealers Abandon Trade Shows Early (And How to Stop the Exodus) – 5 Critical Mistakes That Make Dealers Abandon Trade Shows Early (And How to Stop the Exodus) After twenty years in the c…
• 5 Penny Redemption Mistakes That Cost Collectors Hundreds (And How to Avoid Them) – I’ve Seen These Penny Redemption Mistakes Destroy Value – Here’s How to Avoid Them After years of watc…
• How I Converted $500 in Spare Pennies Into $1000 Worth of Gift Cards (The Complete Step-by-Step Guide) – I Ran Straight Into a Brick Wall of Pennies – Here’s How I Doubled Their Value Let me tell you about the day…