Preserving America’s First Small Cent: Expert Conservation Strategies for Flying Eagle Cents

I’ve held too many Flying Eagle Cents where careless handling erased centuries of history. As someone who’s conserved these copper-nickel pioneers for decades, I can’t emphasize enough how proper preservation separates museum-worthy treasures from damaged relics. Let’s explore how to protect these groundbreaking coins – the 1856-1858 Flying Eagle Cents – while maximizing their numismatic value and eye appeal for future generations.

The Historical Significance of Flying Eagle Cents

These revolutionary coins didn’t just change pocket change – they reshaped American coinage forever:

• First small-sized cent (shrinking from bulky 27mm to sleek 19mm)
• Pioneering copper-nickel composition (88% copper, 12% nickel) that gave them distinctive “white cent” luster
• James B. Longacre’s iconic flying eagle design – a departure from classic Liberty heads
• The ultra-rare 1856 patterns, with only 2,000 struck for Congressional approval

“Flying Eagle Cents represent pure numismatic innovation: a new eagle design, experimental metal composition, compact size, and those legendary 1856 patterns. Their short three-year run makes every survivor special.” – @P0CKETCHANGE

Understanding Natural Toning vs. Harmful Oxidation

The Beauty of Natural Toning

Our community showcases stunning examples of desirable patina:

• Rainbow hues on @rnkmyer1’s PR61 that dance like oil on water
• @winesteven’s “Color Monster” with electric blues and fiery crimson borders
• An NGC 64 CAC/EEPS example whose champagne-toned surfaces doubled its collectibility

Through my years handling these coins, I’ve found natural toning forms protective layers when stored properly. The secret? Time and chemistry. I recommend:

• Photographing toning patterns annually – they’re fingerprints of a coin’s journey
• Using archival-quality holders that “breathe” while protecting delicate surfaces
• Keeping collections away from sunlight, which accelerates uneven color shifts

Combating Destructive Oxidation

Spot these danger signs before they ruin your coin’s eye appeal:

• Chalky white spots blooming like fungus (zinc oxide on planchets)
• Vertebrae-like green corrosion creeping along lettering
• The telltale black sulfur pits pockmarking @lermish’s raw example

If you spot early oxidation:

• Quarantine the coin in acid-free paper immediately – corrosion spreads
• Seek professional conservation – this isn’t a DIY situation
• Resist the urge to rub or clean – you’ll only amplify the damage

The PVC Menace: A Silent Killer

Several forum members shared coins in old holders – a heart-stopping sight for any conservator:

• @TomB’s AU58 in an early ANACS slab risks permanent PVC damage
• The greenish haze on @rnkmyer1’s raw coin screams previous PVC exposure

When PVC plastics degrade, they emit hydrochloric acid that:

• Etches surfaces like miniature acid baths
• Creates irreversible “green slime” that devours mint luster
• Demands immediate intervention if detected early

Four steps to save PVC-threatened coins:

1. Remove from suspect holders like you’re handling live ordnance
2. Inspect under 10x magnification for cloudy residues
3. Bathe affected coins in pure acetone (never drugstore varieties!) for 30 minutes
4. Rebirth them in PVC-free archival holders worthy of their provenance

Choosing the Right Holders: A Conservationist’s Guide

Professional Storage Solutions

Our community demonstrates textbook preservation techniques:

• @P0CKETCHANGE’s AU58 resting securely in a modern CAC-approved slab
• @rnkmyer1’s NGC MS66 in a pop-top holder with Photoseal documentation
• A PCGS PR63 w/CAC example showcasing perfect edge encapsulation

My hierarchy of protection for maximum collectibility:

Environmental Controls

Even perfect holders can’t compensate for poor conditions. Maintain:

• 40-50% humidity – Sahara-dry invites microfractures, Amazon-wet breeds corrosion
• A steady 65-72°F – coins hate temperature swings more than we do
• Darkness – light is the enemy of original surfaces

Pro Tip: Use silica gel packets in storage boxes (replace every 6 months) and monitor with hygrometers.

The Great Cleaning Debate: When Intervention Helps vs. Harms

“My recently submitted 1857 Flying Eagle cent came back Genuine – the grading equivalent of a death sentence.” – Anonymous collector

This collector’s pain underscores cleaning’s double-edged nature:

Never Clean These Crown Jewels:

• Proof coins like @ThePennyLady’s breathtaking PR63 with mirrored fields
• Coins boasting original mint luster (study @rnkmyer1’s MS66 for reference)
• Any piece with attractive natural toning – you can’t repatina history

When Professional Conservation Earns Its Keep:

• Active corrosion threatening structural integrity
• PVC contamination caught in early stages
• Verdigris outbreaks in encapsulated coins

Remember: Even expert cleaning reduces value for Mint State coins. @P0CKETCHANGE’s AU58 CAC example commands premium prices specifically because its surfaces remain untouched by human hands.

Special Considerations for Key Dates & Varieties

These rarities demand white-glove treatment:

• 1856 Patterns: Handle like ancient glass – their copper-nickel composition makes them prone to spotting. Store in inert plastic capsules with silica packets.
• 1858 Large Letters: Susceptible to edge nicks; use padded holders that cradle rather than constrain.
• Proof Issues: @rnkmyer1’s PR63 requires silica-controlled storage to preserve its cameo contrast.
• Clashed Dies: These diagnostic treasures (like the stunning example @Catbert shared) demand magnification to appreciate – and preserve – their unique stories.

Conclusion: Safeguarding Numismatic History

From @P0CKETCHANGE’s AU58 CAC warrior to @rnkmyer1’s trailblazing PR63 discovery coin, these Flying Eagle Cents represent a pivotal moment in American minting. Their experimental composition and brief lifespan (1856-1858) make them uniquely vulnerable – and infinitely precious.

By embracing these conservation strategies:

• You become a steward of numismatic heritage
• Preserve the premium value of CAC-approved quality
• Ensure future collectors can marvel at the coins that revolutionized U.S. currency

As @Catbert mused while examining a dramatic die crack: “Great thread. Have never owned one of these.” Let’s ensure these flying eagles soar through centuries more by combining our knowledge, passion, and respect for these copper-nickel pioneers.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Grading Flying Eagle Cents: The Critical Nuances Between $10 and $5,000 Coins – Condition is Everything: A Grader’s Perspective For Flying Eagle cent collectors, condition isn’t merely imp…
• Flying Eagle Cent Authentication: Expert Strategies to Detect Counterfeits – With Counterfeits Circulating, Knowledge is Your Best Defense Few coins capture America’s numismatic spirit like t…
• Hidden Fortunes in Flight: The Ultimate Guide to Error Detection on Flying Eagle Cents – Most People Walk Past Fortunes Every Day While casual observers see only weathered copper-nickel discs, the trained eye …