Small Size Alert: Authenticating the Rare Linked States George Washington Inaugural Button

Counterfeit Crisis: Why Your Magnifying Glass Matters

After handling thousands of Revolutionary-era artifacts, I still catch my breath when a genuine Linked States Washington inaugural button crosses my desk. These 1789 treasures – America’s first presidential commemoratives – have become minefields of modern fakes. Let’s dissect that eyebrow-raising $2,575 eBay “miniature” that set collector forums ablaze last week. Was it a undiscovered rare variety or another cautionary tale? Grab your loupes – we’re going detective mode.

History Alive: Touching Washington’s America

Crafted for citizens celebrating our first president’s journey to New York City, these brass beauties whispered revolution in their very design. That elegant script – “G.W. // LIGHT &/ORb\ GUIDE // LINKED STATES” – framed by 13 chain links wasn’t just decoration. It was wearable patriotism. Unlike military buttons, these civilian pieces were cherished keepsakes, passed through generations until antique dealers rediscovered them in the late 1800s.

“Original 1789 pieces feel like whispered secrets – thin, delicate, alive with hand-engraved imperfections,” notes @messydesk, whose eagle-eyed forum comment sparked our investigation. “Centennial souvenirs shout their presence with thicker planchets and mechanical perfection.”

The Authentication Dance: Five Telltale Signs

1. The Golden Rule: 34mm or Walk Away

Size separates kings from pretenders in this game. Every verified original in the Stack’s Bowers archives and Colonial Williamsburg collections measures 34mm – about the width of a silver dollar. Our eBay contender? A shrunken 23-24mm pretender. Remember:

• Caliper discipline: No “eyeballing” allowed – digital precision or bust
• Variety fantasies: Zero evidence of period miniatures exists – don’t fund a forger’s vacation
• Centennial confusion: Even 1889 souvenirs dwarf this Lilliputian imposter at 28-32mm

2. Weight Watchers: Historical Edition

Heft tells truths words can’t. My scale doesn’t lie:

• True 1789 warriors: 8.5-9.2 grams (featherlight from skilled colonial metalwork)
• 1889 tribute acts: 10.3-11.8 grams (thick as a Broadway ham)
• Modern junk: Often dips below 8g or spikes above 12g – dead giveaways

3. The Magnet Test: Science Meets History

Watch genuine buttons slide slowly down an inclined neodymium magnet like maple syrup down a January pane. Fakes? They’ll either stick like gum or race down like kids on a waterslide. True brass and copper alloys dance to their own non-magnetic rhythm.

4. Script Sleuthing: Penmanship Tells All

Original dies sang with artisan flair – modern fakes stutter with mechanical indifference. Compare:

• Authentic hallmarks:
  • Serifs that taper like 18th-century quill strokes
  • Chain links with organic oval shapes – no cookie-cutter perfection
  • Signature “chatter marks” from hand-engraving tools
• Forgery fingerprints:
  • Letters standing at attention like toy soldiers
  • “LINKED STATES” text floating unmoored from design elements
  • Flat, lifeless surfaces under 10x magnification

5. Surface Poetry: Reading the Skin

Time writes love letters on authentic buttons:

• Honest patina: Earth-toned gradients developed over centuries
• Original luster: Soft gleam in protected crevices
• Fake aging: Acid-dipped “antiquing” that resembles a bad spray tan

Three Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing

The Miniature Mirage

These pocket-sized pretenders prey on our thirst for discovery. Spot them by:

• Blurred details from reduction casting
• Wrong weight-to-size ratios
• Artificially darkened recesses

1889 Centennial Imposters

Legitimate antiques in their own right, but Revolutionary-era? Hard no. Telltales:

• Thick planchets (1.8-2.1mm vs. originals’ wafer-like 1.3-1.5mm)
• High-relief strikes screaming “machine-made!”
• Gilt surfaces too bright for their britches

21st Century Casting Couch Specials

Born in Chinese factories, these flood eBay with:

• Zinc’s telltale crystalline surface under magnification
• Fake provenance papers straight from Photoshop University
• Edge seams visible to naked eye

Your Authentication Toolkit: No Compromises

When a potential GW button calls your name, channel your inner museum curator:

Stage 1: The Measuring Gauntlet

• Digital calipers locked at 34.00±0.15mm
• Thickness gauge verifying ≤1.5mm
• Edge examination for subtle filing marks

Stage 2: Metal Mayhem

• Precision scale sensitive to 0.01g variations
• Neodymium magnet slide test (slow=good, fast=bad)
• XRF analyzer when possible – zinc spikes scream FAKE

Stage 3: Die Study Deathmatch

• Side-by-side comparisons with Stack’s Bowers certified images
• 20x magnification on serif terminals
• Chain link mapping – asymmetry is beautiful

Stage 4: Provenance Police Work

• Pre-1970 collection history or walk away
• Seller reputation deep dives (our eBay seller had a rap sheet of fake sales)
• Third-party certification – no exceptions over $1,000

Collectibility & Market Realities

True 1789 buttons command heart-stopping prices for good reason:

• Mid-grade warriors: $2,500-$3,500 (matching our suspect eBay sale)
• Mint condition monarchs: $8,000-$12,000 at Heritage Auctions
• 1889 centennial cousins: $400-$800 – historical interest, not revolutionary gold

That $2,575 price tag? Initially plausible for numismatic value, but dimensional lies and the seller’s shady history transformed it from treasure to trash. Always remember: provenance weighs more than price tags.

Final Charge: Guardians of History

These Linked States buttons are more than metal – they’re tangible connections to Washington’s America. Each fake purchased fuels forgers’ furnaces, while every authenticated piece preserves our legacy. Let’s close with wisdom from the trenches:

“Assume every unusual piece is guilty until proven innocent,” advises @messydesk. “That ‘unlisted variety’ could list your bank account straight to zero.”

Arm yourself with calipers, cultivate relationships with trusted experts, and share this knowledge freely. Our community’s vigilance determines whether future generations hold history… or hollow fakes. Now go forth – measure ruthlessly, collect wisely, and may your next find be the real deal.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Unmasking Rarities: The Truth Behind Small-Size George Washington Inaugural Buttons & How to Spot Errors – Hidden in Plain Sight: How Millimeter Differences Define Priceless Washington Relics After three decades scrutinizing co…
• Unraveling the Mystery: The Small-Size ‘Linked States’ Washington Inaugural Button in Historical Context – The Weight of History in a Button’s Design Few relics capture the imagination like an artifact that literally touched Am…
• Small Size Washington Inaugural Buttons: Authenticity Concerns and Market Realities – What separates a treasure from a trap in the wild world of collecting? The recent frenzy over a mysterious small-size &#…