Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy a 1916 Buffalo Nickel So-Called Doubled Die Obverse Without Getting Ripped Off

If you’re hunting for a 1916 Buffalo Nickel So-Called Doubled Die Obverse (SCDDO) to elevate your collection, buckle up—this isn’t just a purchase, it’s a treasure hunt. These coins command attention not just for their numismatic value, but for the thrill of uncovering a genuine rarity. As someone who’s handled countless Buffalos, I’ll share hard-won insights on navigating auctions, spotting fakes, and securing authentic pieces worthy of your cabinet.

Historical Background: The 1916 Buffalo Nickel’s Enduring Legacy

James Earle Fraser’s masterpiece—the Buffalo Nickel—has captivated collectors since its 1913 debut. Its bold design captured the spirit of the American West, with a Native American portrait that feels alive under proper luster. The 1916 Philadelphia issue stands apart with a mintage of just 3.8 million coins, making even well-worn examples scarce. But the true prize? The elusive SCDDO variety.

Unlike dramatic doubled dies, the SCDDO shows subtle doubling—almost a ghosting effect—on key obverse elements. When you find one with clear doubling in “LIBERTY” or the date, you’re holding a piece of minting history. I’ve seen collectors gasp when tilt-light reveals those telltale shadows—that’s when you know you’ve struck numismatic gold.

Spotting Authenticity: The SCDDO’s Diagnostic Markers

Don’t let excitement cloud your judgment—know these markers cold. A genuine 1916 SCDDO will make your loupe work overtime with unmistakable doubling in:

• The Date: Look for digit “doubling” that resembles a slight offset shadow
• LIBERTY Banner: Letters should show shelf-like doubling at their bases
• Feather Details: The large feather’s ridges often reveal diagnostic doubling

That controversial PCGS-certified coin (Cert #50731189)? Veteran eyes on collector forums immediately noticed its flatness where doubling should sing. As one sharp-eyed member put it:

“No doubling in the ribbon ties? That’s like a Buffalo missing its hump—something’s wrong.”

Moral of the story? Never outsource your due diligence, even to top-tier slabs.

Where to Hunt: Trusted Sources for Authentic SCDDOs

The marketplace is a minefield—here’s where to step safely:

1. Premier Auction Houses

Heritage and Stack’s Bowers remain the gold standard. Their imaging teams capture every nuance—essential when judging doubling. Remember the Great Collections lot (#1995928) that vanished after forum scrutiny? That’s why auction archives become your research bible.

2. Slabbed Coins with Pedigree

PCGS/NGC slabs offer a safety net, but treat them as starting points. Cross-reference certification images and compare strike quality. A true SCDDO’s eye appeal should leap through the holder.

3. Brick-and-Mortar Specialists

Nothing replaces holding a coin under proper light. At major shows like FUN or ANA, you’ll find dealers who’ll let you inspect every micron of patina. Watch how light dances across the fields—authentic doubling creates depth you can feel.

4. Collector Networks (With Caution)

Forums like Coin Community Forum offer leads, but move carefully. The best transactions happen after you’ve vetted sellers through years of thread history. When that long-trusted member offers an SCDDO? That’s when your pulse quickens.

Red Flags: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes

Over three decades, I’ve seen every trick. Steer clear when you spot:

1. “Variety” Claims Without Proof

If the listing photo doesn’t scream doubling in LIBERTY’s “B”, proceed with extreme caution. Authentic SCDDOs leave no room for doubt—their diagnostics are unmistakable under 10x magnification.

2. Mismatched Wear Patterns

That “G4” with blast white fields? Run. Acid-dipped coins lose original patina while retaining artificial sharpness—a deadly combo for novices. True circulated examples show harmonious wear across high points.

3. Pie-in-the-Sky Pricing

A $1,000 opening bid on a “Good” SCDDO reeks of desperation. Unless it’s pedigreed to a famous collection, market reality should anchor prices. Check PCGS auction archives religiously.

4. Shady Provenance

No auction history? No older holder photos? No deal. Legitimate SCDDOs leave paper trails. I once passed on a raw coin because its strike characteristics mismatched known specimens—later proven to be a clever cast counterfeit.

Negotiation Tactics: Getting Value Without Sacrificing Quality

Knowledge is bargaining power. Master these moves:

1. Arm Yourself With Data

Bookmark PCGS CoinFacts and NGC’s auction tracker. When a seller claims “MS65 quality,” show them recent sales of comparably-graded pieces. Numbers speak louder than adjectives.

2. Highlight Flaws Tactfully

“The reverse seems lightly cleaned—see those hairlines west of the mound?” This objective observation can unlock 10-20% discounts. But only cite flaws impacting eye appeal or strike quality.

3. Time Your Auction Bids

Set alerts for ending lots with zero bids. Sellers hate re-listing fees—I’ve snatched treasures at 65% of guide by pouncing in the final minutes. Just confirm the coin’s luster isn’t artificial.

4. Demand Diagnostic Images

No close-ups of the date and LIBERTY? Politely insist. One collector avoided a $2,500 mistake by requesting a 45-degree shot revealing missing doubling. Smart phones make this non-negotiable.

Raw vs. Slabbed: The Eternal Collector’s Dilemma

Your choice depends on goals and experience:

Raw Coins

• Pros: Lower premiums, hands-on inspection bliss. Nothing beats studying original patina under a loupe.
• Cons: Requires encyclopedic knowledge. I’ve seen even experts miss subtle tooling on raw SCDDOs.

Slabbed Coins

• Pros: Grade security enhances liquidity. My slabbed VF20 SCDDO sold in 48 hours—try that with a raw coin.
• Cons: Plastic mutes toning nuances. Some details hide behind glare. Always verify against the grading service’s online photos.

Remember—slabs aren’t force fields. That controversial PCGS coin proved even top services can err. Trust your eyes first, labels second.

Real-World Value Guide: What Your Money Buys

Prices reflect condition and eye appeal. Recent trends show:

• G4 (Good): $200–$500 for authenticated pieces with clear doubling
• VF20 (Very Fine): $1,000–$2,500 when original surfaces sing
• MS60 (Mint State): $5,000+ for coins with full cartwheel luster

Compare this to common 1916 Philadelphia issues—$50-100 in Good—and you see why collectors chase the SCDDO’s premium. But remember: condition rarity trumps all. An MS64 example last year fetched nearly $15,000 at auction!

Final Thoughts: Why This Coin Captivates Us

The 1916 SCDDO Buffalo Nickel represents everything we love about numismatics—history, artistry, and the satisfaction of authentic discovery. As the forum scrutiny proved, our community’s collective wisdom remains the best authentication tool. Stay patient, stay skeptical, and when you finally land that perfectly doubled specimen with original mint bloom? You’ll understand why we chase these metallic ghosts of history.

May your next Buffalo hunt bring both profit and pleasure—happy hunting!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The $10 vs. $1,000 Question: Grading the Controversial 1916 Buffalo Nickel (PCGS #50731189) – Condition Is Everything: A Professional Grader’s Breakdown Let’s cut to the chase: in our world, condition i…
• 1916 Buffalo Nickel Authentication Guide: Exposing Fake ‘Doubled Die’ Varieties and PCGS Slab #50731189 – The Hidden Dangers Lurking in Your Buffalo Nickel Collection Few things quicken a collector’s pulse like spotting …
• The 1916 Buffalo Nickel Error That Wasn’t: A Cautionary Tale for Die Variety Hunters – Most people walk right past the tiny imperfections that transform ordinary pocket change into rare treasures worth thous…