Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Bust Boo-Boos Post your bust errors Without Getting Ripped Off

Understanding Bust Coin Errors

If you are looking to add this to your collection, you need a strategy to get the best deal. Bust coin errors represent some of the most fascinating anomalies in American numismatics, encompassing everything from missing edge lettering to dramatic double strikes. These minting mistakes occurred during the early years of the U.S. Mint when quality control was far less stringent than today, making them both historically significant and increasingly valuable to collectors.

Where to Buy Bust Coin Errors

The marketplace for bust coin errors spans several venues, each with distinct advantages and considerations. Major coin auctions hosted by Heritage, Stack’s Bowers, and GreatCollections regularly feature error coins in their catalogs. These platforms offer authentication and professional photography but typically charge buyer’s premiums of 15-20%.

Specialized error coin dealers like Sheridan Coins, Mike Byers Rare Coins, and others maintain extensive inventories and can provide expert attribution. Working with established dealers offers the advantage of their expertise in identifying genuine errors versus post-mint damage, though prices may be slightly higher to account for their knowledge and guarantee.

Online marketplaces including eBay and Proxibid can yield exceptional deals, particularly for raw coins. However, these venues require the most caution. When buying from these sources, always request multiple high-resolution images showing all details, including edges, and ask specific questions about the error’s characteristics before bidding.

Local coin shops and coin shows provide opportunities to examine coins in person before purchase. Building relationships with shop owners can lead to first access to new inventory and potentially better pricing on raw coins they’ve held back from grading.

Red Flags When Buying Error Coins

Several warning signs should prompt caution when considering a bust coin error purchase. The most critical red flag is any indication of post-mint damage being misrepresented as a mint error. Common examples include coins damaged by machinery after leaving the mint being sold as “struck through” errors, or coins with chemical damage being marketed as lamination errors.

Be wary of sellers who cannot provide detailed attribution information or who use vague terminology like “error type unknown” or “mint mistake.” Legitimate error coins can typically be attributed to specific die marriages and error types based on established numismatic references.

Unusually low prices for seemingly rare errors should raise suspicion. While genuine errors do occasionally appear at bargain prices, prices that seem too good to be true often indicate problems with the coin’s authenticity or the seller’s understanding of what constitutes a true mint error.

Avoid sellers who are unwilling to provide additional photographs or who pressure you to make quick decisions. Reputable sellers understand that error coin purchases often require careful examination and comparison with known examples.

Negotiating Tips for Error Coin Purchases

Successful negotiation for bust coin errors requires knowledge and patience. Start by researching recent auction results for similar errors using resources like the Newman Numismatic Portal or specialized error coin price guides. Understanding the market value of comparable coins provides essential leverage in negotiations.

When dealing with raw coins, consider having them authenticated by a third-party grading service before finalizing the purchase. Many dealers will allow you to submit coins to PCGS or NGC with the agreement that you’ll complete the purchase if they authenticate as genuine. This protects you from counterfeits and provides additional value through professional grading.

For multiple purchases, ask about package pricing. Dealers often provide better per-coin pricing when buying several items, particularly if you’re building a specialized collection like die marriages or specific error types.

Be prepared to walk away from deals that don’t meet your criteria. The error coin market is active enough that similar opportunities will arise. Building a reputation as a serious collector who makes fair offers but doesn’t overpay will lead to better deals over time.

Raw vs. Slabbed Error Coins: Making the Right Choice

The decision between purchasing raw versus professionally graded error coins involves several considerations. Slabbed coins from PCGS, NGC, or ANACS offer authentication guarantees and protection, which is particularly valuable for expensive errors where the cost of a mistake could be substantial. Professional grading also provides a standardized assessment of the coin’s condition, though error coins are often graded more leniently than regular issues.

Raw coins typically sell for 10-30% less than their slabbed counterparts, offering potential savings for knowledgeable collectors. The price difference can be significant for common errors but may be minimal for rare varieties where authentication is crucial. Raw coins allow you to examine all details personally, which some collectors prefer for evaluating the severity and characteristics of the error.

For beginners in error collecting, starting with slabbed coins from reputable sources provides a safer entry point while building knowledge. As expertise develops, selectively purchasing raw coins can expand a collection more economically. Consider having particularly valuable raw purchases authenticated after acquisition to protect your investment.

Certain error types are more problematic in raw form than others. Doubled edge lettering, for instance, can be difficult to authenticate without professional examination, while more obvious errors like off-center strikes may be safer to purchase raw if the price reflects that risk.

Specific Error Types and Their Market Dynamics

Understanding the specific error types discussed in the forum helps inform buying strategies. Unlettered edge capped bust half dollars represent extremely rare errors, with perhaps only a dozen known examples. These command premium prices and require authentication due to their rarity and value.

Double struck coins with visible dentil tracks are more common but still valuable, particularly when the doubling is dramatic and the underlying detail is preserved. These errors often show better in higher grades, making the price difference between circulated and uncirculated examples more significant than with regular coins.

Off-center strikes on large size bust quarters are exceptionally rare, with perhaps only a handful known. The largest examples command the highest premiums, and provenance from notable collections like the Cohen collection adds significant value.

Planchet flaws and lamination errors are more common and often more affordable, making them good entry points for collectors new to error coins. However, distinguishing between genuine planchet flaws and post-mint damage requires experience.

Building a Collection Strategically

Successful error coin collecting requires a strategic approach. Consider focusing on specific error types, denominations, or date ranges rather than collecting random errors. Building a date run of error coins for a particular series can be more rewarding than scattered acquisitions.

Document your purchases thoroughly, including the error’s attribution, provenance when known, and the purchase price. This information becomes invaluable for insurance purposes and when considering future sales or trades.

Join error coin specialty groups and attend error coin-focused events to network with other collectors and dealers. The error coin community is smaller than the general coin collecting community, making personal connections particularly valuable for learning and finding rare pieces.

Be patient in building your collection. Exceptional error coins may only appear a few times per year, and rushing purchases often leads to overpaying or acquiring less desirable examples. Quality consistently trumps quantity in error coin collecting.

Authentication and Certification Considerations

For expensive bust coin errors, professional authentication becomes essential. PCGS and NGC both offer error coin certification services, though their expertise in early American errors varies. Some collectors prefer ANACS for certain error types due to their longer history with error coin authentication.

When submitting coins for authentication, provide all available attribution information and any provenance details. This assists the authenticators in making accurate determinations and can add value to the certification process.

Be aware that even professional grading carries some risk with error coins. The grading standards for errors differ from regular coins, and some error types are more challenging to authenticate than others. Building relationships with authenticators or working with dealers who have established relationships with grading services can improve outcomes.

Conclusion: The Rewarding Challenge of Error Coin Collecting

Collecting bust coin errors offers a fascinating intersection of history, rarity, and the unexpected results of early minting processes. While the market presents challenges including authentication concerns and price volatility, knowledgeable collectors can build exceptional collections by following careful buying strategies.

The key to successful error coin collecting lies in education, patience, and working with reputable sources. Start with more common, affordable errors to build knowledge, then gradually expand into rarer varieties as expertise develops. Document everything, network with other collectors, and don’t hesitate to seek second opinions on questionable purchases.

Whether you’re drawn to the dramatic visual impact of a double strike, the rarity of an unlettered edge coin, or the historical significance of early minting errors, bust coin errors offer a collecting specialty that combines the thrill of the hunt with the satisfaction of preserving these fascinating pieces of minting history. With careful strategy and informed decision-making, you can build a collection that not only brings personal enjoyment but also represents a sound numismatic investment.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Can Bust Boo-Boos Be Made Into Jewelry? A Crafter’s Guide – Introduction: Not Every Coin is Suitable for Crafting As a coin ring artisan, I’m often asked about using error co…
• Preserving Your Bust Coin Errors: A Conservationist’s Guide – I’ve seen too many valuable pieces ruined by improper cleaning or storage. Here is how to keep this safe for the n…
• Grading Bust Boo-Boos: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – Condition is Everything: Grading Bust Half Dollar Errors When it comes to bust half dollars, condition is everything. Th…