Smart Collecting: Navigating LiveAuctioneers and Harbor Auction for Authentic Morgan Dollars

Navigating the Morgan Dollar Minefield: A Collector’s Survival Guide

That 1878-CC Morgan dollar gleaming in an auction listing? It could be the crown jewel of your collection—or an expertly aged counterfeit ready to break your heart and your budget. As someone who’s handled more CC-mint Morgans than Carson City had silver deposits, I’ve seen firsthand how today’s counterfeiters prey on our passion. Let’s cut through the noise and arm you with battle-tested strategies to secure authentic pieces with real numismatic value.

Where Sharp Collectors Shop: Platform Truths Revealed

LiveAuctioneers functions like a digital El Dorado—overflowing with treasures but crawling with modern-day bandits. Unlike eBay’s standardized playground, this is the Wild West of numismatics. Key players include:

• Hibid – Your go-to for estate sale surprises (some good, many questionable)
• Proxibid – Where industrial liquidations meet occasional numismatic gold
• K-Bid – Regional auctions with hidden gems…and landmines

The critical distinction? LiveAuctioneers is merely the stage—not the bouncer. When Harbor Auction (a repeat offender in collector forums) lists an “1878-CC in mint condition,” that supposed Carson City beauty might’ve been born in a Chinese sweatshop yesterday. My boots-on-the-ground investigation found three shadowy entities operating from their listed address—a classic shell game that should make any collector’s Spidey-sense tingle.

The Collector’s Trust Pyramid

• Platinum Tier: Heritage, Stack’s Bowers (direct sales with ironclad guarantees)
• Silver Tier: Established local houses with ANA ties (check their membership!)
• Fool’s Gold Tier: Unverified sellers like Harbor Auction specializing in liquidations, not numismatics

Red Flags: Anatomy of an 1878-CC Fake

Let’s dissect a recent forum horror show—an “1878-CC” that made seasoned collectors gasp. With only 962,000 struck, this key date demands forensic-level scrutiny:

• The Reverse That Screams “Fake”: True 1878-CCs feature 8 tail feathers. This impostor used the common 7-feather reverse from later years—a dead giveaway when you know your VAMs.
• Mint Mark Uncanny Valley: Authentic CC punches show subtle human variations. This robotic replica’s mint mark looked like it was stamped by a CNC machine.
• Pitting That Betrays Its Roots: Cast fakes can’t replicate the smooth luster of authentic silver. Zoom in—porous surfaces never lie.

“I sent LA an image showing the wrong reverse design for this date/mm combination. Their response? Crickets. Without NGC/PCGS backing us, we’re shouting into the void.” — Bitter Collector

Three Deal-Breakers I Never Ignore:

1. Provenance Black Holes: No ownership history? Walk away.
2. Stock Photo Shadyness: If they won’t provide high-res edge shots, they’re hiding something.
3. Ghost Address Games: Virtual offices or multiple DBAs = numismatic no-go zones

Auction Psychology: Bidding Like a Battle-Scarred Pro

LiveAuctioneers’ “dynamic closing” turns bidding into psychological torture. When the clock resets with each last-second bid, only these strategies keep you sane:

• The Sniper’s Gambit: Set your absolute max at PCGS Price Guide minus 20% (buyer premiums add up!)
• The Raw Coin Discount: Demand 30% off slabbed prices to offset grading risk—that “mint luster” might be clever polishing
• The Escrow Lifeline: For big-ticket items, insist on third-party authentication before funds change hands

When Sellers Ghost You: The Nuclear Option

“Per your Terms section 4.2, I dispute Lot #XYZ’s authenticity. This coin heads to NGC tomorrow. If it fails—and I expect it will—I demand full reimbursement plus grading fees. Failure to comply triggers reports to LiveAuctioneers, the ANA, and three state AG offices.”

Raw vs. Slabbed: The Great Morgan Debate

That raw Morgan could be the steal of the century—or a very expensive lesson. Consider this breakdown:

My Hard-Won Verdict: Unless you watched that 1878-CC spill from an original bag (and even then!), only buy slabbed. Modern fakes replicate bag marks and toning with terrifying accuracy—I’ve seen counterfeits with “patina” more convincing than my grandmother’s silver tea set.

Conclusion: Preserving Collectibility in the Age of Fakes

The 1878-CC Morgan remains the holy grail of Western mintages, but its rarity fuels an entire counterfeit industry. While platforms like LiveAuctioneers offer unprecedented access, they demand merciless scrutiny. Stick with slabbed coins from ANA-affiliated sellers, deploy forensic bidding tactics, and report suspicious listings relentlessly. Remember: In today’s market, that “too-good-to-be-true” CC Morgan isn’t just a bargain—it’s a $20 fake masquerading as a $2,000 treasure. Keep your loupe handy, your references closer, and let third-party grading be your shield. Happy hunting!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Is Your 1878-CC Morgan Dollar Authentic? The Forensic Guide to Detecting Counterfeits – Safeguarding Your Collection: The Critical 1878-CC Morgan Dollar Diagnostic Points As someone who’s handled more C…
• Painted vs. Corroded Coins: When Melt Value Outshines Collector Appeal – When Hidden Metal Outshines Face Value What if a coin’s true treasure lies beneath its surface? Let’s explor…
• Mastering the Market: Expert Strategies for Buying Authentic Painted Coins – The Painted Coin Conundrum: Where Folk Art Meets Numismatic History For collectors who relish numismatic mysteries, pain…