Strategic Buyer’s Guide: Acquiring 1928-S and 1913-S Buffalo Nickels with CACG Expertise

Buffalo Nickel Hunting? Master These Collector-Approved Tactics

For those captivated by America’s most iconic coin design, Buffalo Nickels represent more than pocket change—they’re tangible pieces of Wild West romance stamped in copper-nickel. But let’s be honest: navigating the market for conditional rarities like the 1928-S or 1913-S Type 1 requires more than enthusiasm. As someone who’s handled thousands of these coins through grading stations and auction previews, I’ve seen too many collectors lose money on details even seasoned eyes miss. This isn’t just advice—it’s field intelligence distilled from recent CACG submissions and heated collector forum debates.

Where to Buy: Balancing Opportunity and Trust

Specialized Auction Houses

Seek out auctions featuring CACG or PCGS-certified coins with proper variety attributions. That 1928-S “Two Feather” designation isn’t just academic—it’s what separates a $200 coin from a $2,000 rarity. Houses like Heritage or Stack’s Bowers excel here, providing high-resolution photography that reveals critical details like strike quality and original luster. Remember: in buffalo nickel collecting, the difference between “Fine” and “About Uncirculated” often lives in the bison’s hind leg.

Trusted Dealers & Coin Shows

Cultivate relationships with dealers who eat, sleep, and breathe early 20th-century U.S. coinage. At major shows like FUN or ANA, you’ll handle coins under proper lighting to assess patina and surface marks firsthand. As one Chicago dealer told me last month: “The 1913-S Type 1’s value hinges entirely on whether that reverse head shows friction or environmental damage.” Bring your loupe—this is where provenance matters.

Online Marketplaces (Handle Like Uranium)

While eBay listings might tempt you with “RARE!” claims, collector forums overflow with horror stories. One member’s caution rings true: “Buffalo nickels break more hearts online than bad Tinder dates.” Without third-party grading, you’re gambling on blurry photos masking cleaned surfaces or tooled dates. If buying raw online, demand macro shots of the date, mint mark, and buffalo’s horn—the trifecta of authenticity checks.

Bloodhound Tactics: Sniffing Out Problem Coins

The Grading Gauntlet

When forum members debated a 1913-S Type 1, grades swung from AU55 to MS65—a $15,000 spread. Sellers claiming “gem quality” without certification? Proceed like it’s radioactive. Watch for:

• Unnatural Surfaces: Authentic buffalo nickels (1913-1938) rarely boast mirror-like fields. If you see cartoonish cartwheel luster, suspect cleaning.
• Variety Vacuums: That 1928-S listing avoiding the “Two Feather vs. Three Feather” debate? It’s either ignorant or deceptive—both dangerous.
• Ghostly Reverses: As forum guru “BuffaloBill92” noted, worn 1913-S coins often show a “faded chief” on the reverse—a red flag for overgrading.

The Authentication Imperative

Raw coins test even expert eyes. One collector’s confession says it all: “I’ve misjudged more Buffalo AU/MS transitions than my first marriage.” Protect yourself with:

• CACG/PCGS certification numbers (verify online!)
• Oblique lighting shots showing strike details
• Pedigree notes for key dates—no provenance, no deal above $500

Negotiation Secrets: Collectors’ Chess Moves

Exploit Grading Uncertainties

Forum debates over a 1928-S’s cheekbone wear created pricing chaos. For raw coins, cite these disagreements to shave 15-25% off asking prices. For slabbed pieces, watch for cross-grading opportunities—CACG’s newer holders sometimes trade at slight discounts versus PCGS, despite identical eye appeal.

Market Timing Mastery

Target dealers during the “numismatic off-season”—late July through August. With auctions scarce and vacation drains on cash flow, even rare varieties see softer pricing. And always mention cash in hand: before major shows like FUN, dealers often liquidate to fund new purchases.

The Two Feather Gambit

Since CACG began strict “Two Feather” attributions, properly designated 1928-S specimens command 40-60% premiums. If you spot an unattributed example (like the forum’s infamous “is it or isn’t it?” coin), offer 30% under Greysheet with plans to resubmit. It’s calculated risk with explosive upside.

Raw vs. Slabbed: The Eternal Collector’s Dilemma

When Raw Coins Shine

Forum members saved thousands submitting raw finds to CACG for variety checks. Consider raw buffalo nickels when:

• You’ve handled enough specimens to judge strike strength by feel
• Surface toning suggests original patina (no telltale cleaning swirls)
• You’re hunting “sleeper” varieties missed by previous owners

“My best score? A raw 1916-D in a junk bin—CACG called it MS62+” – BisonHunter on CoinTalk

Slabbed Security for Key Coins

While CACG’s 21-day turnaround aids raw submissions, certified holders dominate the $1,000+ market. Slab when:

• Eye appeal matters (toned MS65 examples can double plain equivalents)
• Selling online—buyers trust third-party grades over seller claims
• Handling conditional rarities like the 1920-S “Weak D”—where authenticity doubts abound

Conclusion: Buffalo Nickels – Where History Meets Profit

More than mere metal, these coins whisper stories of roaring twenties speakeasies and Great Depression breadlines. But as the forum wars prove, their numismatic value hinges on razor-sharp strategy. Whether you’re chasing that elusive 1928-S Two Feather in mint condition or building a circulated type set, remember: in buffalo nickel collecting, every detail—from strike quality to patina—carries weight. Master these tactics, and your collection won’t just grow—it’ll thrive.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving Buffalo Nickels: Expert Conservation Tips for Your 1913-S and 1928-S Coins – Save Your Buffalo Nickels From Heartbreaking Damage: A Collector’s Preservation Guide As a numismatist who’s…
• Is Your 1928-S Buffalo Nickel Real? Expert Guide to Authenticating Two Feather Varieties – Counterfeit Crisis: Why Every Buffalo Nickel Collector Needs This 1928-S Two Feather Guide As someone who’s held c…
• The Hidden History Behind Two Rare Buffalo Nickels: A Journey Through Time – Historical Significance Every coin whispers tales of America’s past. To truly appreciate these Buffalo nickels, we…