The 1909 VDB Cent: Spotting Rare Errors in Lincoln’s First Year

Historical Significance

Most collectors overlook the subtle details that can transform a common coin into a rarity worth thousands. The 1909 VDB Lincoln cent stands as one of American numismatics’ most captivating stories – a coin that sparked public controversy, was briefly withdrawn from production, and today commands significant premiums from discerning collectors.

The VDB initials (Victor David Brenner) appear on the reverse, positioned at the bottom between the wheat stalks. This placement was deemed too prominent by some, leading to public outcry and the quick removal of the designer’s initials after only a few weeks of production. This brief mintage window makes the 1909 VDB cent particularly desirable, especially in higher grades where original luster and sharp strike details remain intact.

Identifying Key Markers

When examining a potential 1909 VDB cent, several critical markers must be checked:

The VDB Placement

The reverse design features the VDB initials in small letters at the bottom center, between the wheat stalks. This is the defining characteristic that separates the 1909 VDB from the 1909-S VDB and regular 1909 cents. The letters should display crisp detail with full definition, not worn or faded from circulation.

Mint Mark Verification

The example discussed appears to be from the Philadelphia mint (no mint mark). However, the forum mentions seeking the San Francisco version (1909-S VDB), which is significantly rarer and more valuable. The 1909-S VDB had a mintage of only 484,000 coins compared to Philadelphia’s 27,995,000 – a difference that substantially impacts collectibility and market value.

Die Cracks and Doubling

When examining the coin’s details, look for:

• Die cracks: These appear as raised lines on the coin’s surface, often radiating from devices or along the rim. They can add character and sometimes value to a coin, particularly if they’re dramatic and well-defined.
• Double dies: Look for doubling in the date, lettering, or Lincoln’s profile. This occurs when the die receives multiple impressions slightly offset from each other, creating a collectible variety highly prized by specialists.
• Rim characteristics: The forum mentions “a decent rim,” which is important for grade assessment. A full, rounded rim indicates better preservation and often correlates with higher overall grade potential.

Condition Assessment

The forum discussion reveals several condition issues that affect value:

“Unfortunate scratch on lincoln but the reverse is mesmerizing and a perfect example to show off the short lived VDB placement.”

This obverse scratch is a significant detractor from the coin’s value. Additionally, the mention of cleaning is concerning, as original surfaces are highly prized by collectors. Cleaned coins often see substantial value reductions since artificial enhancement destroys the natural patina that develops over decades.

The reverse condition appears to be the coin’s strong point, with the VDB placement described as “mesmerizing” and “a perfect example.” This suggests the reverse devices remain well-defined despite the obverse issues, preserving the key design elements that make this variety so significant.

Value Guide

Based on the described condition issues (scratch, possible cleaning), this 1909 VDB cent would likely fall into the lower circulated grade range. However, even problem coins of this key date can be valuable:

• Problem-free examples: $500-1,000+ depending on grade and eye appeal
• Cleaned or damaged examples: $100-300 range, reflecting condition deductions
• 1909-S VDB (if found): $2,000-5,000+ even with problems due to extreme rarity

The forum poster mentions this was their “best $20 I ever spent” from an “unsearched” mixed wheat bag. This highlights the treasure-hunting aspect of coin collecting and the potential for significant finds in unexpected places – a reminder that valuable numismatic treasures still await discovery by careful observers.

Authentication Tips

For collectors seeking to authenticate their 1909 VDB cents:

1. Check the weight: Should be 3.11 grams, the standard for copper cents of this era
2. Verify composition: 95% copper, 5% tin and zinc – the classic bronze alloy
3. Examine the VDB letters: Should be sharp and well-formed with proper spacing
4. Look for signs of tooling or alteration: Particularly around the mint mark area on 1909-S VDB specimens
5. Consider professional authentication: For higher-value specimens or suspected varieties

Conclusion

The 1909 VDB Lincoln cent remains one of the most exciting coins for collectors to encounter. Despite the condition issues mentioned in this forum discussion, the historical significance and relative rarity of the VDB variety make it a noteworthy find. The hunt for the even rarer 1909-S VDB continues, representing the ultimate prize for wheat penny enthusiasts and a testament to the series’ enduring appeal.

Whether found in an estate sale bag or inherited collection, the 1909 VDB serves as a reminder that valuable numismatic treasures can still be discovered by careful observers who know what details to examine. The tiny VDB initials tell a story of artistic pride, public controversy, and the birth of one of America’s most beloved coin series – a legacy that continues to captivate collectors more than a century later.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Grading the 1916-1917 Type 1 Standing Liberty Quarter: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – The Art of Grading Standing Liberty Quarters Condition is everything. When evaluating a Standing Liberty Quarter, partic…
• Is Your Standing Liberty Quarter Real? Authentication Guide for This Classic Coin – The Standing Liberty Quarter: A Brief Historical Overview The Standing Liberty Quarter, minted from 1916 to 1930, repres…
• Finding Last Roll Luck in the Wild: A Cherry Picker’s Guide – The Thrill of the Hunt You don’t always need a dealer to find something special. Sometimes, the most rewarding dis…