The Hidden Economics of Coin Imaging: How NGC and PCGS Photography Decisions Impact Your Collection’s Value
December 8, 2025I Tested PCGS vs. NGC Coin Imaging Services: The Definitive Guide to TrueViews, Color Accuracy & Customer Support
December 8, 2025
Introduction: Why Your Coin Photos Matter More Than You Think
If you’re just starting your coin collecting journey, here’s something most beginners overlook: professional imaging can make or break your coin’s value. Let me share a hard lesson from my early days – one collector lost $1,500 on a Morgan dollar because of poorly lit photos. This guide will help you master coin imaging basics without the expensive mistakes.
Coin Photography 101: What Every New Collector Needs to Know
Grading services like PCGS and NGC don’t just grade your coins – they create permanent photo records that future buyers will study closely. Think of these images as your coin’s permanent digital ID card.
TrueViews vs Raw Photos: What’s the Difference?
Let’s clear up the jargon:
- TrueViews (PCGS): Official photos taken through the graded holder – your coin’s “passport photo”
- Raw/Crossover Images: Pictures taken without the holder, usually when resubmitting coins
Lighting Tricks That Fool Even Experts
Look at these two photos of the same silver proof:
“ vs ”
The angled shot makes toning look richer, right? That’s lighting magic at work. Silver coins especially need straight-on lighting to show true colors. Remember this next time you’re photographing proofs!
5 Photo Mistakes That Cost Collectors Money
After reviewing hundreds of downgraded coins, these are the most common imaging errors I see:
Is That a Fingerprint or Just Toning?
New collectors often panic over marks that turn out to be natural toning. One client almost cleaned a rare Mercury dime before proper photos revealed it was mint-made texture. Always get multiple light angles before worrying about surface issues.
How Plastic Holders Change Your Coin’s Look
 vs 
Notice how the same coin looks different in PCGS vs NGC holders? That’s plastic refraction at work. NGC’s holders tend to show warmer tones – something to consider when choosing grading services.
Your First Imaging Workflow: Simple Steps For Beginners
Follow this beginner-friendly process I’ve taught to dozens of new collectors:
Step 1: Take Better Photos at Home
Camera Settings for Coin Photography:
- ISO 100
- f/8 aperture
- 1/125 shutter speed
- Two diffused LED lights at 45° angles
Don’t have fancy gear? A smartphone with a simple lamp setup works too!
Step 2: The Magic Words Graders Notice
When submitting to PCGS, always write: “Please capture multiple toning angles if applicable.” This phrase signals you know what you’re doing and often gets special attention.
Secret Perk: How to Get Free Photo Redos
“PCGS Social saw this thread and reached out offering better photos – even for coins submitted months ago!”
Most beginners don’t know you can request image improvements. Here’s how:
- Check your TrueViews within 2 days of posting
- Politely message graders with specific requests (“Could we see more reverse detail?”)
- Reference their own imaging standards for stronger cases
3 Coin Photography Myths Debunked
Myth: “All Grading Services Use the Same Lighting”
Not true! Equipment varies between locations. If your coin’s photo has odd shadows, ask for a reshoot. You’re paying for this service!
Myth: “Holder Photos Always Lie About Color”
 vs 
Modern imaging can beat plastic distortion. The right lighting setup makes holder photos surprisingly accurate, as this comparison shows.
Bonus Tip: Easy Focus Stacking for Beginners
Want pro-level raw coin photos? Try focus stacking – merging multiple shots for perfect sharpness. You don’t need coding skills! Many free apps like Helicon Focus handle the tech stuff automatically.
Remember These 4 Essentials
- Review grading service photos immediately – don’t wait!
- Ask politely for reshoots when needed (yes, even months later)
- Different holders = different looks – factor this into buying decisions
- Keep your own photo archive for comparison
With these practical tips from my coin imaging journey, you’ll avoid costly mistakes and showcase your collection’s true value. Happy collecting!
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- How Counterfeit Hardware Practices Are Shaping Automotive Software Security Standards – Your Car is Now a Computer: Why Authenticity Matters More Than Horsepower Today’s vehicles aren’t just machi…
- How Detecting Counterfeit Coins Teaches Us to Build More Secure Automotive Software Systems – Modern cars are like rolling computers, packed with software that keeps us connected and safe. Let’s talk about ho…
- The Insider’s Guide to 1891cc GSA Morgans: Hidden Details That Could Make or Break Your Investment – Most folks miss the real story behind these coins. Let me pull back the curtain on what I’ve learned firsthand. The Unse…
