The Hidden Value in Washington Restrike Errors: A Collector’s Guide

The Mystery of the 1959 Washington Restrike

Most collectors overlook the tiny details that transform an ordinary piece into a numismatic treasure worth thousands. The 1959 George Washington Born Virginia medal restrikes exemplify this perfectly – what appears to be a simple steel bar could actually be a rare test piece from the production process.

Historical Significance

The Washington Born Virginia medal boasts a fascinating history dating back to the 1930s. In 1959, collector and dealer Collis created restrikes using a steel-to-steel transfer process to copy the original die. According to articles from The Numismatist (August 1959), this process involved creating copy dies from the original, resulting in multiple variations that collectors should be aware of.

Identifying Key Markers

When examining potential restrike pieces, several critical features demand attention:

Die Cracks and Breaks

The forum discussion reveals an important die crack pattern that starts between the “O” and “R” in “Born,” travels through Washington’s hairline, across his shoulder, and through the “B” in “Feb.” This specific crack pattern can help authenticate pieces and determine their place in the production sequence. Die cracks often create raised lines on the surface and can significantly impact value depending on their severity and location.

Surface Texture Analysis

One collector noted a “granular” texture on Washington’s bust that differs from known examples. This unusual texture could indicate:

• A test impression from a hub before final die creation
• A later production piece using different materials
• Polishing variations during the steel-to-steel transfer process

The Mysterious “Barcode” Marking

Perhaps the most intriguing feature mentioned is a small marking on the side of the steel bar that resembles a barcode. This could be:

• A production identifier from the original 1959 restrike process
• A quality control mark from the steel manufacturer
• A later addition that helps date the piece

Magnetic Properties and Metal Composition

The steel composition of these restrikes makes them magnetic – a key test for authentication. Original medals were struck in silver (with a mintage of 27 pieces according to December 1961 advertisements), copper, and other metals. The magnetic property helps distinguish steel test pieces from other variations.

Specific Errors to Look For

Based on the discussion, here are the most valuable errors and variations to examine:

Hub Impressions

Test impressions from the original hub before die creation can show reversed or incomplete designs. These pieces often have unique textures and may lack the refinement of final production pieces.

Transfer Errors

The steel-to-steel transfer process could introduce errors including:

• Distorted lettering or design elements
• Double strikes where the design appears twice
• Incomplete transfers showing only partial designs

Production Sequence Markers

Early production pieces might show:

• Polishing lines from die preparation
• Hub preparation marks
• Alignment variations in the design

Authentication Challenges

The grainy texture mentioned in the forum highlights a common authentication challenge. Original dies and early copper strikes typically don’t show this graininess, suggesting either:

1. A test piece from an intermediate production stage
2. A later recreation using different techniques
3. A damaged or worn die producing unusual surface characteristics

Current Market and Value Considerations

While specific values aren’t mentioned in the discussion, the rarity of these pieces and their historical significance makes them valuable to collectors. The fact that similar items appear on eBay suggests an active market, though authentication remains crucial.

Expert Input Needed

The forum participants wisely suggested consulting expert John Kraljevich, highlighting the complexity of authenticating these pieces. When dealing with potential restrikes and test pieces, expert opinion becomes invaluable, especially for pieces with unusual characteristics.

Conclusion: The Hunt Continues

The 1959 Washington Born Virginia medal restrikes represent a fascinating area of error and variety collecting. From magnetic steel test pieces to mysterious barcode markings, each variation tells a story about the production process. Whether you’re examining a potential die break, unusual texture, or production marker, remember that the smallest detail could be the key to unlocking a piece’s true history and value. As error coin hunters know, patience and attention to detail often reveal the most rewarding discoveries.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Hidden History Behind the 1959 Colis Washington Steel Restrike – The Forgotten Art of Steel Restrikes Every relic tells a story. To understand this item, we have to look at the era in w…
• What is the Real Value of Question About Colis 1959 George Washington Steel Restrike Impression in Today’s Market? – Historical Significance This 1959 George Washington steel restrike impression captures a fascinating moment in American …
• Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Proof Buffalo 5c Newp Without Getting Ripped Off – Why the Proof Buffalo Nickel Deserves a Place in Your Collection If you’re looking to add this iconic coin to your…