The Mint State Mystery: How a Morgan Dollar Jumped from NGC MS66 to PCGS MS67 – And Why It Matters

Condition isn’t just important—it’s everything in our pursuit of numismatic excellence. Let me share how examining high points and fields can reveal a coin’s true story. After decades of professional grading and handling thousands of Morgan Dollars, I’ve learned the difference between MS66 and MS67 isn’t merely technical. It’s an art form requiring keen observation of wear patterns, luster dynamics, strike quality, and that magical “eye appeal” we collectors cherish. Today’s case study proves why your knowledge is the ultimate authentication tool in this thrilling hunt for quality.

The Grading Mystery: When NGC MS66 Becomes PCGS MS67

Consider this ordinary-date Morgan Dollar—a perfect example of grading complexities in action. Originally slabbed by NGC as MS66, its owner sensed hidden potential. When CAC declined certification at that grade, our collector made a gutsy move: cracking the holder and resubmitting to PCGS. The result? A triumphant MS67 designation followed by CAC approval. This numismatic odyssey challenges us to consider:

• How holder technology shapes our grading perceptions
• The
  

  Related Resources

  You might also find these related articles helpful:

  • Is Your Morgan Dollar Genuine? Expert Authentication Guide for Key Date Coins – The Unseen Battle: Why Authentication Makes or Breaks Your Morgan Dollar Collection In today’s collector’s m…
  • Hidden Errors & Grading Secrets: How a Morgan Dollar’s Tiny Flaws Became Its Greatest Asset – The Devil in the Details: Why Error Hunters Find Fortunes Others Miss While most collectors glance at surface details, t…
  • The 1881 Morgan Dollar: Grading Controversies and Hidden Historical Significance – Every Relic Whispers History Hold this 1881 Morgan Dollar in your palm, and you’re not just gripping silver—you&#8…