The Silver & Gold Content of The 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickels really did have to go Explained

The Historical Context Behind the 1913 Buffalo Nickel Redesign

Sometimes the metal inside is worth more than the face value. Let’s break down the melt value versus the collector value.

Understanding the Type 1 Buffalo Nickel’s Design Flaws

The Type 1 Buffalo Nickel, designed by James Earle Fraser, featured a stunning portrait of a Native American chief on the obverse and a majestic American bison on the reverse. However, as beautiful as these coins were, they presented significant practical problems for circulation.

The rough, textured fields that gave the Type 1 nickels their distinctive artistic character created havoc with minting dies. These intricate surfaces caused premature die wear, leading to inconsistent strike quality and the development of small die cracks throughout production runs. But perhaps the most critical issue was the rapid wearing away of the denomination on the reverse.

The 1883 Liberty Nickel Fiasco: A Lesson Not Forgotten

In 1883, the United States Mint introduced the Liberty Head Nickel, which featured only a large Roman numeral “V” on its reverse to indicate its five-cent value. This design oversight proved costly when unscrupulous individuals gold-plated these coins and passed them off as five-dollar gold pieces. The similarity in size between the nickel and the half eagle gold coin made this deception possible, at least temporarily.

The black eye the Mint got reverberated for years. It became inevitable that a change had to be made.

According to numismatic historian David Lange in his authoritative work on Buffalo Nickels, the Mint remained “overly sensitive” to this issue when designing the new nickel series. The collective memory of that 1883 embarrassment influenced decisions about the Buffalo Nickel’s design, even though the buffalo motif itself was distinctive enough to prevent confusion.

The Technical Specifications: Purity and Weight Analysis

Metal Composition and Intrinsic Value

The Buffalo Nickel, like all nickels produced in the United States, contains a copper-nickel alloy consisting of 75% copper and 25% nickel. This composition has remained consistent throughout the series’ production from 1913 to 1938.

Each Buffalo Nickel weighs exactly 5 grams (0.1764 ounces). To calculate the melt value, we need to consider the current spot prices of both copper and nickel:

• Copper content: 3.75 grams (75% of 5 grams)
• Nickel content: 1.25 grams (25% of 5 grams)

Using current market rates, the melt value of a Buffalo Nickel typically ranges between 7-10 cents, depending on metal prices. This is significantly higher than the coin’s face value of 5 cents, making it an interesting consideration for bullion investors.

Spot Price Correlation and Market Dynamics

The relationship between precious metal spot prices and coin melt values follows a predictable pattern. When copper and nickel prices rise, the intrinsic value of these coins increases proportionally. During periods of economic uncertainty or inflation, industrial metal prices often surge, making even base metal coins more valuable for their content.

For bullion investors, tracking the correlation between spot prices and melt values helps identify optimal stacking opportunities. The Buffalo Nickel’s consistent composition makes it particularly useful for this purpose, as its value tracks more predictably than coins with varying silver or gold content.

Stacking Strategy for Buffalo Nickels

Building a Collection Based on Metal Content

While most collectors focus on numismatic value, bullion investors approach Buffalo Nickels from a different perspective. The stacking strategy involves acquiring these coins when their melt value approaches or exceeds their market price, creating a hedge against inflation and currency devaluation.

Key considerations for a stacking strategy include:

• Volume acquisition: Purchasing in bulk when prices are favorable
• Condition indifference: Focusing on melt value rather than grade
• Storage solutions: Proper containment to prevent environmental damage
• Market timing: Buying during periods of low collector demand

Type 1 vs. Type 2: Strategic Considerations

The Type 1 Buffalo Nickel, produced only in 1913 before the design modification, holds particular interest for both collectors and investors. While Type 2 nickels are more common and have slightly better die life due to their modified design, Type 1 coins represent the purest form of Fraser’s original vision.

From a bullion perspective, the metal content remains identical between both types, making the choice purely aesthetic or historical. However, Type 1 coins often command a small premium due to their historical significance and limited mintage period.

Authentication and Quality Assessment

Identifying Genuine Buffalo Nickels

Authenticating Buffalo Nickels requires attention to several key markers:

• Date and mint mark verification: Using reference materials to confirm legitimate varieties
• Weight verification: Ensuring the coin weighs exactly 5 grams
• Composition testing: Non-destructive testing to confirm copper-nickel alloy
• Wear patterns: Understanding how circulation affects different design elements

Common Counterfeits and Alterations

Counterfeiters have targeted Buffalo Nickels, particularly rare dates and mint marks. Common alterations include:

• Altering dates on common dates to resemble rare ones
• Adding fake mint marks
• Creating cast counterfeits with incorrect weight and composition

For bullion investors, the most important aspect is ensuring the coin is genuine and contains the correct metal composition, rather than focusing on numismatic details.

Market Analysis and Investment Potential

Historical Price Performance

Buffalo Nickels have shown remarkable price stability over decades, with their value typically tracking closely with industrial metal prices. During periods of high copper and nickel demand, such as the early 2000s commodities boom, these coins saw their melt value exceed $0.10 for the first time in decades.

The coins’ dual nature as both collectible items and bullion assets provides a unique investment proposition. Even during market downturns, the floor price remains relatively stable due to the intrinsic metal value.

Future Outlook and Considerations

Several factors could influence the future value of Buffalo Nickels:

• Potential changes in copper and nickel mining regulations
• Technological advances in metal recycling
• Economic policies affecting industrial metal demand
• Growing interest in historical American coinage

Conclusion: The Enduring Value of Buffalo Nickels

The 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel represents a fascinating intersection of artistic achievement, practical necessity, and investment potential. While the redesign to Type 2 addressed legitimate production concerns, both varieties offer bullion investors a tangible asset with inherent value beyond their face denomination.

For those building a diversified portfolio of physical assets, Buffalo Nickels provide an accessible entry point with several advantages: they’re inexpensive to acquire in quantity, easy to store and authenticate, and their value has a built-in floor due to metal content. Whether you’re a serious bullion investor or simply appreciate the historical significance of these coins, understanding the relationship between melt value and market price is essential for making informed decisions.

The story of why the Type 1 design had to go reminds us that even beautiful designs must serve practical purposes in circulating coinage. For modern investors, this historical lesson translates into an appreciation for coins that balance aesthetic appeal with intrinsic value – a principle that continues to guide smart bullion stacking strategies today.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Finding 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickels in the Wild: A Cherry Picker’s Guide – Historical Significance The 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel represents one of the most fascinating chapters in American numis…
• Smart Buying Guide: How to Acquire 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickels Without Getting Ripped Off – Historical Significance The 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel represents a fascinating chapter in American numismatic history. …
• Can The 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Be Made Into Jewelry? A Crafter’s Guide – Introduction: The Crafting Potential of the 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Not every coin is suitable for crafting. Let&#821…