The Ultimate Crafter’s Dilemma: Should You Transform an 1889-CC Morgan Dollar Into Jewelry?

Not Every Silver Dollar Makes a Worthy Ring: A Coin Artisan’s Confession

After hammering hundreds of Morgans into wearable heirlooms, I’ve learned this truth: nothing makes collectors clutch their pearls faster than hearing “1889-CC” and “jewelry project” in the same sentence. Yet here we stand at the crossroads of history and craftsmanship, examining the most legendary Morgan of them all through the jeweler’s loupe. Let me tell you why that tiny “CC” mintmark changes everything – for better and worse.

Historical Significance of the 1889-CC Morgan

When the Carson City Mint struck its final regular-issue dollars in 1889, it sealed the fate of what would become the Holy Grail of Morgan collectors. Only 350,000 pieces emerged before the mint’s doors creaked shut forever in 1893 – each one a tangible piece of America’s final frontier. These coins jingled in the pockets of silver barons, crossed gambling tables in Virginia City saloons, and financed the railroad expansion that tamed the West. Their provenance practically whispers tales of revolvers and rattlesnakes.

“In May 1968, my hands shook as we counted out 600 silver dollars on the banker’s worn oak counter. Two 1889-CC Morgans glinted in that hoard like diamonds in coal – our only real score that day. Fifty years later, I still see their soft Carson City luster when I close my eyes.” – Old West Coin Forum Member

Metal Composition & Durability Analysis

The 90% Silver Sweet Spot

Morgan Dollars possess that perfect numismatic alchemy we metalworkers dream about:

• 90% fine silver (24.057g) – the soul of the coin
• 10% copper (2.673g) – its backbone

This brilliant alloy balances beauty and brawn. Unlike pure silver’s frustrating softness, the copper-hardened Morgans withstand daily wear while maintaining that signature 19th-century glow. Watch how this composition works its magic:

• Develops rich, even patina instead of ugly tarnish
• Holds crisp details during forming without cracking
• Keeps its structural integrity better than modern sterling

The Hard Truth About Silver

Let’s talk Vickers hardness scale – the metalworker’s report card:

• Pure Silver: 25 HV (like warm butter)
• Morgan Alloy: 75-80 HV (the Goldilocks zone)
• Modern Sterling: 60-70 HV (decent but lacks character)

That extra stiffness means your 1889-CC ring will resist barroom dings better than contemporary pieces, while still allowing masterful repoussé work on Liberty’s profile.

Design Elements That Make or Break Jewelry Potential

Obverse (Front) Features

George Morgan’s Liberty remains the Mona Lisa of coin portraiture – but only if you preserve her glory:

• Hair Details: Those flowing locks demand at least EF detail to maintain eye appeal when domed
• Date Position: 1889 nestles perfectly beneath her neck – often the last detail to fade
• Star Alignment: 13 constellations framing her face create instant heirloom quality

Reverse (Back) Challenges

The eagle’s design separates weekend hobbyists from master artisans:

• Wingtip Thinness: High points wear faster than a miner’s denim – disastrous in G/VG coins
• CC Mintmark: That tiny wild west signature becomes the ring’s crown jewel when positioned correctly
• Olive Branch: Leaves must remain visible after forming – requires surgical annealing precision

The Rarity Factor: To Craft or Preserve?

Here’s where our worlds collide. With perhaps 17,500 survivors across all grades, the 1889-CC’s numismatic value isn’t just about silver weight – it’s about owning manifest destiny made metallic. Consider carefully:

“After 20 years hunting Carson City dollars, my 1889-CC remains the final ghost in the collection. When I finally bag one in mint state, you’ll hear my victory shout from Virginia City to Denver!” – CC Set Collector

Crafting Considerations: When an 1889-CC Might Become a Ring

Acceptable Candidates

• Coins with harsh cleaning (numismatic value already destroyed)
• Pitted surfaces where the strike still shows through
• VG specimens where Liberty’s profile remains proud

Master Craftsmanship Required

Transforming this legend demands reverence and skill:

1. Annealing: 1200°F exactly – enough to soften but preserve original luster
2. Forming: The CC mintmark must remain centered like a sheriff’s badge
3. Finishing: Liberty’s cheekbone curve – lose it and you’ve committed numismatic treason

Ethical Alternatives for History-Respecting Crafters

For those who crave CC romance without collector nightmares:

• Common-date CC Morgans (1891-93) with lower rarity but equal Wild West pedigree
• Strike custom “CC tribute” rounds in .999 silver – same drama, no guilt
• Pendant designs that preserve the eagle intact – wearable history without distortion

Conclusion: The Artisan’s Dilemma

The 1889-CC Morgan Dollar presents the ultimate test for silver-smiths. Technically, it’s perfect jewelry material – that resilient 90% silver alloy, the captivating strike, the frontier provenance. Yet holding one whispers cautionary tales. Would you melt a Colt Peacemaker for its silver content? Some coins transcend bullion value to become cultural touchstones. If you have a damaged, cleaned, or heavily worn 1889-CC, transforming it honors the West’s spirit of reinvention. But any example with original luster and strong details? That’s sacred ground, partners. As both artisan and historian, I reserve these frontier farewell pieces for only the most compromised specimens – preserving their legacy so future generations might feel the West’s last silver gasp in their palms.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 1889-CC Morgan Dollar: How Grading Transforms a $100 Coin Into a $10,000 Treasure – The Crown Jewel of Carson City: A Collector’s Obsession Nothing quickens a collector’s pulse like an 1889-CC…
• Treasure Hunting PCI-Graded Coins: The Roll Hunter’s Guide to Cherry Picking Hidden Gems – You Don’t Need a Dealer to Strike Gold Hear that satisfying clink of silver in a bankroll? Smell the musty cardboa…
• Unearthing the Future: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Science-Based Grading Tech Finds – You Don’t Need a Dealer to Find Tomorrow’s Grading Stars As I sorted through a $500 bag of mixed Wheat Penni…