Unearthing Hidden Treasures: The Roll Hunter’s Guide to George Soley Medals & Medallettes

Forget dealer markups—some of numismatics’ most thrilling treasures still surface in the wild! As a seasoned roll hunter and token enthusiast, I’ve learned that George Bache Soley’s exquisite 19th-century medals and medallettes offer collectors a perfect trifecta: breathtaking artistry, tangible Mint history, and surprising numismatic value. Let me show you how to spot these underrated gems in circulation finds, estate sale hauls, and bulk token lots.

Soley’s Legacy: Where Mint History Meets Artistic Ingenuity

George Bache Soley (1851-1896) stands at a fascinating crossroads in American coinage history. While crafting dies alongside the Barber dynasty at the Philadelphia Mint, this ingenious engraver simultaneously ran a private medal business using decommissioned Mint equipment. His story isn’t just about metal—it’s about the steam-powered revolution that transformed coin production.

“Soley wasn’t just reproducing Barber’s designs—he was miniaturizing masterpieces,” observes forum sage RogerB. “Building his own portable reducing machine? That’s the mark of a true numismatic pioneer.”

Why collectors cherish Soley’s work:

• Barber Connection: Hand-crafted reductions of iconic Barber designs, making elite artistry accessible
• Mint Souvenirs: Literally struck with US Mint equipment and sold to visitors—provenance you can feel
• Technical Brilliance: Owner of the first private steam press from the Mint, achieving jaw-dropping detail
• Notorious Creations: His 1894 Lord’s Prayer medalettes caused such demand, the Secret Service intervened!

Spotting Soley: The Collector’s Field Guide

Signature Styles That Sing

From delicate prayer medals to grand commemoratives, Soley’s work spans three collectible categories that make specialists’ hearts race:

• Lord’s Prayer Series: Miniature marvels (13-23mm) with microscopic text—true tests of a press’s might
• Event Medals: Showstoppers like the 1889 Brooklyn Bridge medal (Musante GW-1086), dripping with period charm
• Political Tokens: Rarities like the HK-71 Grant Memorial that bridge exonumia and formal numismatics

Authentication Red Flags & Revelations:

• Seek Soley’s name (appears on 30% of pieces)—when present, it screams collectibility
• Study portrait profiles—his Washington busts have distinctive Barber-esque luster
• Marvel at precision only achievable through reduction technology
• Note recurring themes—historical figures, infrastructure celebrations, expositions

Metal Matters: Composition Clues

Recent forum breakthroughs reveal crucial material insights:

• Common in bronze/white metal—but eye appeal varies wildly
• Silver specimens exist! Only 2 confirmed “God and Our Country” examples known
• Post-1892 pieces may bear Scovill Manufacturing’s mark
• Key diagnostic: 23.7mm copper pieces surface frequently

Treasure Maps: Prime Hunting Grounds for Soley Medals

1. Estate Sale Goldmines

As forum member SilverSleuth proved, jaw-dropping finds await in unassuming boxes. Their 1876 Pennsylvania Cabinet store card discovery? Priceless. Pro tips:

• Ransack “misc metal” boxes—history hides in plain sight
• Inspect 19th-century token albums page by page
• Watch for Frank Stewart’s Mint history books—often paired with Soley medals

2. Bulk Token Lots: Diamonds in the Rough

User fretboard’s triumphant post about 13mm double-sided tokens proves bulk buys deliver. My strategy:

• Buy unsorted lots by weight—more volume, more surprises
• Screen for intricate miniatures—bring your loupe!
• Spot Lovett collaborations—that distinctive Houdon-style portraiture

“Discovering that Lovett engraved my Brooklyn Bridge token’s obverse?”, fretboard marveled. “That’s when attribution becomes addiction!”

3. Coin Roll Hunting: The Ultimate Thrill

While scarce, forum members have scored—like the Pan-American Expo medalette in a silver roll. My field tactics:

• Target early 1900s bank bags—time capsules of forgotten history
• Examine edges meticulously—Soley’s tiny text hides there
• Rescue holed pieces—often dismissed as jewelry but treasure to us

Market Realities: What Collectors Actually Pay

Recent confirmed sales reveal fascinating valuations:

• Bronze Prayer Medals: $15-50—but patina matters
• Silver Rarities: $400+ (only 2 public sales)
• 1892 Railway Medalette: $141.50 (eBay hammer)
• HK-71 Grant Dollar: $850+ in EF with original surfaces
• 1882 William Penn: Priceless (unique specimen)

Condition reigns supreme. As Zoins cautions: “Most surface worn or holed.” But find one with mint-state luster? That’s retirement-fund material.

The Attribution Challenge: Separating Soley from Imposters

With no definitive catalog (yet!), authentication requires detective work. Coinosaurus nailed it: “We’re still mapping Soley’s universe.” Arm yourself with:

• Die Studies: Cross-reference with fretboard’s album
• Provenance Trails: Scovill ties or Mint correspondence are golden
• Collaboration Patterns: Barber/Lovett design fingerprints don’t lie
• Metallurgy: Weight and composition testing separates originals from copies

Why We Chase Soley: A Collector’s Manifesto

Soley’s creations represent everything we love: technical mastery, historical resonance, and that electric thrill of discovery. As forum threads prove weekly, previously unknown varieties still emerge from attics and auction lots. Every find—whether in a coin roll or estate sale—rewrites numismatic history slightly.

So next time you’re sifting through tokens, remember: That bronze disc with peculiar strike could be Soley’s rarest Barber collaboration. Keep your loupe polished and your passion bright—the hunt never ends!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Mastering the Market: Strategic Acquisition Guide for George Soley Medals and Medallettes – Building Your George Soley Medal Collection: A Collector’s Guide George Bache Soley’s medals represent some …
• Crafting History: Evaluating George Soley Medals for Jewelry Transformation – Not every coin deserves the hammer and mandrel. As a coin ring artisan with twenty years of transformation tales etched …
• Preserving History: Expert Conservation Techniques for George Soley Medals and Medallettes – I’ve Witnessed History Fade: A Conservator’s Heartfelt Appeal After thirty years preserving 19th-century num…