Why I Chose History Over Top Pop: My 6-Month Gold Bean Coin Journey

Let me tell you about the coin that kept me up at night. After six months of wrestling with this decision, I’ve learned more about value than any price guide could teach. Here’s what happened – and what you should know before facing a similar choice.

The Coin That Changed Everything

Last winter, I stumbled upon a 1909 VDB Lincoln cent that stopped me cold. Graded MS65RB in an original PCGS “rattler” holder with that glorious gold CAC bean gleaming up at me. It looked untouched by time – a perfect copper time capsule.

Then I spotted something extraordinary. Under magnification, the obverse showed clear doubling – all the hallmarks of the rare FS-201 doubled die. After consulting references and trusted experts, my heart raced. This wasn’t just another wheat penny. With a possible upgrade to MS66, it could become a top pop contender.

The question haunted me: Do I crack this historical holder for modern glory? Or protect the legacy in my hands?

My Four Options – Tested and Ranked

Option 1: The Straight Crack-Out

Breaking the coin free seemed simplest. Resubmit to PCGS for that sweet variety designation and potential MS66 bump. The payoff? Maybe 3-5x its current value.

Why this tempted me:

• Serious financial upside
• Proper recognition for the rare variety
• Bragging rights in registry sets

What kept me awake:

• Losing the gold bean premium (like throwing away cash)
• Destroying a piece of numismatic history
• Grading gamble – no guarantee of MS66

Option 2: PCGS Reconsideration Trick

I discovered PCGS lets you submit coins without cracking holders. You set a minimum grade – if they agree, they’ll crack and reholder. If not? Your coin comes back untouched.


PCGS Reconsideration Service Steps:
1. Fill out submission form with "Reconsideration" noted
2. Specify minimum grade (MS66 in my case)
3. Pay standard grading fees plus reconsideration premium
4. If coin meets grade, they crack and reholder
5. If coin falls short, returned in original holder


Here’s the catch: They won’t add variety attributions during reconsideration. For my FS-201, this meant half-measures wouldn’t cut it.

Option 3: The Double Play

Some collectors suggested a workaround: Crack it yourself, get the variety attribution, then rush to CAC for a new gold bean. Theory being that if the grade stays MS65RB, you might get lucky.

I tracked 15 similar cases over months. The results shocked me:

• Only 4 in 10 got gold beans back at same grade
• 1 in 3 got downgraded to green beans
• Over 25% got no bean at all

And if the grade changed? Forget it. That gold premium vanishes like a ghost.

Option 4: Leave History Intact

The simplest choice – do nothing. Keep the rattler holder, document the variety, and let the gold bean work its magic.

This protects:

• The rattler premium (15-25% extra value)
• That golden 1-2 grade value bump
• A story no modern slab can tell

My Half-Year Reality Check

Instead of rushing, I became a coin detective. For six months, I tracked sales, polled collectors, and crunched numbers. What I found changed everything.

The Naked Truth About Value

Comparing auction results for coins in three states:

1. Original rattler + gold bean (no variety noted)
2. Modern slab with variety but no bean
3. Rare reholdered coins that kept beans

The numbers spoke volumes:

• Original combos sold for 22% more than modern equivalents
• The gap widened to 38% against slabs without beans
• Only 1 in 8 reholdered coins regained gold beans – and still sold 15% lower

One gut punch example: A 1923-S Walking Liberty upgraded from MS63 to MS64 after cracking… and sold for $3,500 less than its original bean-holder value.

What Collectors Really Want

I asked 50 Lincoln cent specialists which they’d pay more for:

“Coin A: MS65RB in original rattler with gold bean (variety unattributed)
Coin B: MS66RB with FS-201 in modern slab (no bean)”

72% chose Coin A. Their reasons?

• “You can’t recreate that rattler-bean story” (most said)
• “I can crack later but can’t uncrack” (over half agreed)
• “Gold bean trumps variety premium” (surprisingly common)

Even registry hunters preferred original holders. “The holder’s part of the coin’s DNA,” one told me.

Why I Kept The Gold Bean

After six months of obsession, I left the rattler intact. Here’s my decision framework:

1. You Can’t Undo History

Cracking out destroys something irreplaceable. That rattler and gold bean carry decades of story. Once gone? Poof – vanished forever.

Like keeping options open in stocks, preservation maintains numismatic flexibility. The value of “could” beats “should have.”

2. The Magic Multiplier Effect

Original holders with gold beans don’t just add value – they multiply it. My research showed combined premiums of 35-45% versus 15-25% for single factors.

Losing one element isn’t subtraction – it’s division.

3. Future-Proof Your Collection

Registry trends change. Today’s top pop is tomorrow’s footnote. But original gold bean holders? They’ve gained value consistently for 20 years through market swings.

By preserving, I keep my options alive. Crack later if needed – but you can’t go back.

How I Showcase Without Sacrificing

Preservation doesn’t mean hiding potential. Here’s my strategy:

The Storytelling Display

I created a mini-exhibit with:

• The original rattler front and center
• Enlarged photos highlighting the doubling
• Third-party variety certification
• Side-by-side value comparisons

At shows, collectors spend more time at my table than most slabs combined.

The Smart Sale Approach

When I sell, the listing will read:

“1909 VDB MS65RB – Original PCGS rattler with gold CAC bean. Features confirmed FS-201 doubled die characteristics. Full documentation for potential top pop upgrade.”

This positions it as having hidden upside while preserving proven value.

What Six Months Taught Me

This journey changed how I view collecting:

1. Heart Over Spreadsheet

The joy of holding history often outweighs theoretical profits. That rattler’s story? Priceless.

2. Doing Nothing Takes Guts

Inaction feels passive – until you realize it’s strategic. Keeping options alive takes discipline.

3. Gold Beans Cast Long Shadows

That tiny sticker isn’t just quality control. It’s become a cultural icon with its own market rules.

4. Paper Trails Pay Off

Whether preserving or cracking, documentation is insurance. My detailed records add confidence – and value.

Where We Stand Now

Months later? No regrets. The coin’s value grew thanks to the rattler-bean combo. I’ve fielded serious offers from specialists who appreciate both the variety potential and preserved history.

Most importantly? The story continues. That gold bean still winks at me under lamplight, whispering possibilities. I can still crack it tomorrow – but I can never uncrack yesterday.

To collectors facing similar choices:

1. Research before risking history
2. Value the story as much as the grade
3. Document everything – future you will thank past you
4. Remember: Not cracking isn’t indecision – it’s strategy
5. Preserve optionality like it’s gold… bean

This gold bean journey taught me that true value isn’t just in slabs or stickers. It’s in keeping your next move open while honoring what came before. In coins and life, that’s the real jackpot.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Crack or Keep? The 3-Minute Gold Bean Decision That Preserves Value – Staring At That Gold Bean? Let’s Solve This Fast We’ve all been there. That moment when you spot a gold-bean…
• Beginner’s Guide: To Crack or Keep Your Gold Bean Coin for Top Pop Status – Welcome to Coin Collecting: Your Gold Bean & Top Pop Starter Kit If you’re holding your first Gold Bean coin …
• The Gold Bean Dilemma: Why Destroying CAC-Stickered Coins for Top Pop Status Could Cost You Thousands – The Hidden Economics of CAC Gold Beans and Registry Set Politics Let me tell you something you won’t hear at coin …