
Chasing a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel in the Wild: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Proof, Mint State, and Straight Grades
October 5, 2026
Are Privy Marks a Fad? A Collector’s Guide to Scheduling, Appraisals, and Insurance
October 5, 2026With some coins, the metal inside is worth more than the face value. With the 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel, however, I would not start there. I can calculate its gross metal content and melt value, but those figures tell only part of the story. Its numismatic value can change sharply according to proof fabric, grade, eye appeal, scarcity, and certification. The question I ask is not simply “What is it worth?” but “What makes this particular 1913 Type 1 desirable to collectors?”
The original forum discussion captures that distinction perfectly. The coin appeared exceptionally sharp, with squared rims, strong details, little or no contact marking, and a small spot near the reverse rim. Opinions ranged from MS66 to PR65, PR66, and even PF67. That is not a trivial disagreement. A high-grade 1913 Type 1 in mint condition and a certified proof from the same year can occupy very different markets.
When I evaluate a coin, I keep two calculations in mind: one for the contained metal and another for the numismatic object. The first measures melt value; the second considers strike, luster, handling marks, color, patina, provenance, and eye appeal. I also weigh whether the issue is a rare variety and whether certification gives collectors confidence in the grade. Treating the metal figure as the coin’s entire value is one of the most common mistakes I see in coin collecting.
Metal content establishes a theoretical floor. It does not identify proof fabric, determine a grade, or guarantee that a rare coin will sell above its melt value.
First, the Surprise: A Buffalo Nickel Contains No Silver or Gold
Here is the surprise: the 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel contains no silver or gold. The coin weighs 5.0 grams and is composed of 75% copper and 25% nickel. Its bullion value is therefore tied to base-metal prices rather than a precious-metal premium. Age and dramatic artwork do not change the composition, and an impressive five-cent piece can still be worth far more as a collectible than as metal.
James Earle Fraser designed the Type 1 Buffalo nickel, introduced in 1913. The obverse features his Native American portrait, while the reverse depicts an American bison. On the Type 1, the small letter F appears beneath the bison’s tail, a placement that helps distinguish it from the later Type 2. That tiny detail matters: for many collectors, the scarcer Type 1 is a rare variety with lasting collectibility. A bold strike, original luster, restrained handling marks, and appealing patina can add substantially to its eye appeal, while solid provenance and a respected certification can make the coin more attractive to serious buyers.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Chasing a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel in the Wild: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Proof, Mint State, and Straight Grades – You do not need a dealer to find a 1913 Type 1 Buffalo nickel. The best discoveries rarely look dramatic at first glance…
- Privy Marks vs. Mintmarks at Auction: How to Maximize Your Hammer Price – I have watched the same privy-mark coin tell two very different stories at sale. On eBay, a listing competes for clicks,…
- 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel as Jewelry: Proof or MS66? A Coin Ring Artisan’s Guide – Not every coin belongs in a ring—and I say that as a coin ring artisan who is always drawn to a striking design. Before …








