Beyond Official Minting: Tokens and Exonumia Related to the 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway Numismatic Heritage — A Collector’s Deep Dive into Hard Times Tokens, Civil War Tokens, Merchant Tokens, and Historical Counterfeits

Sometimes the unofficial money tells a far more compelling story than anything a government mint ever produced. That’s exactly where I want to take you today.

As a lifelong exonumia collector, I’ve always been drawn to the stories that unofficial currency preserves — the economic desperation, the entrepreneurial ingenuity, and the raw political commentary that never made it onto government-issued coinage. When a forum thread about the 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway Numismatic Heritage coin landed on my screen, I immediately recognized it as the perfect launching point to explore the broader, deeply fascinating world of tokens and exonumia that run parallel to official railway and transportation coinage. From Hard Times tokens of the 1830s to Civil War tokens of the 1860s, from merchant tokens to historical counterfeits, the unofficial side of numismatics is every bit as rich — and often more revealing — than the official record.

What Is Exonumia and Why Should Collectors Care?

The term exonumia covers numismatic items that fall outside the category of official government-issued coins and paper money. We’re talking tokens, medals, scrip, badges, counterstamped coins, and a wide variety of other collectible objects that served as currency, commemoration, or advertisement. For collectors who have exhausted the standard date-and-mint-mark sets, exonumia opens up an entirely new universe.

In my three decades of grading and cataloging exonumia, I’ve found that these items often carry more historical weight than their official counterparts. A Civil War token doesn’t just tell you about a shortage of small change — it tells you about the political sentiments of a specific merchant in a specific city during a specific year. That level of granularity is what makes exonumia endlessly fascinating.

The 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway Coin: A Modern Commemorative with Deep Roots

The forum discussion that inspired this article centered on the 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway Numismatic Heritage coin — a modern commemorative issue from Mexico that celebrates the country’s railway history. One collector shared images of their recently graded example, and the conversation quickly expanded to include related pieces, including a 1947 pattern 5 Peso coin that one member described as the closest known pattern to the legendary “Railroad Peso” series. That 1947 pattern, graded at PCGS MS-62, was described as potentially unique — the collector had never encountered another example.

What struck me about this thread was how naturally the discussion migrated from the official commemorative issue to the broader world of railway-related exonumia. One forum member joked, “Now you need a real Ferrocarril!” — a nod to the fact that serious collectors of railway numismatics don’t stop at government mints. They pursue the tokens, medals, and scrip that circulated alongside — or in place of — official coinage.

This is exactly the kind of collecting philosophy I advocate. The 2012-Mo 100 Pesos is a beautiful coin, but its story is incomplete without understanding the token economy that railways and transportation companies fostered across the Americas and beyond.

Hard Times Tokens: America’s First Great Token Crisis (1832–1844)

To understand the tradition that railway tokens and transportation exonumia belong to, we need to go back to one of the most important chapters in American numismatic history: the Hard Times tokens of 1832 to 1844.

What Caused the Hard Times?

The Hard Times era was triggered by President Andrew Jackson’s war on the Second Bank of the United States and his issuance of the Specie Circular of 1836, which required that public lands be purchased with gold or silver coin rather than paper money. The resulting economic depression led to a severe shortage of small-denomination coinage. Merchants, politicians, and entrepreneurs responded by issuing their own tokens — crude, often politically charged pieces that served as both currency and propaganda.

Key Characteristics of Hard Times Tokens

When I examine Hard Times tokens, I look for several defining features:

• Size: Most are approximately the size of a large cent (about 27–29 mm in diameter), though some are smaller.
• Metal composition: Primarily copper or brass, with occasional white metal examples.
• Political themes: Many feature anti-Jackson or anti-bank slogans, such as “SUB TREASURY” or “NO MONOPOLY.”
• Merchant advertising: Others served as business cards in metal form, advertising everything from dry goods to livestock.
• Design types: The Low and Russell numbering systems (Low-Russell) are the standard classification system, with over 500 distinct varieties cataloged.

Collectibility and Value

Hard Times tokens remain highly collectible, with common varieties available for $20–$50 in circulated condition and rare political types commanding $500 to $5,000 or more in Choice Uncirculated grades. The key factors that determine numismatic value are:

1. Rarity: Some varieties are known from only a handful of examples. A rare variety in any condition will always attract attention.
2. Condition: As with all numismatics, grade is king. A Hard Times token in MS-63 or above can be worth 5 to 10 times the price of a Fine example.
3. Historical significance: Tokens with strong political messages or ties to specific historical events tend to command premiums.

Civil War Tokens: Currency Born of Necessity (1861–1864)

If Hard Times tokens represent America’s first great token crisis, Civil War tokens represent its second — and in many ways, its most dramatic.

The Coin Shortage of the 1860s

When the Civil War erupted in 1861, Americans on both sides of the conflict began hoarding gold, silver, and even copper-nickel cents. Within months, small change virtually disappeared from circulation. The federal government’s initial response — the issuance of fractional currency (paper notes as small as 3 cents) — was deeply unpopular. People didn’t trust paper for small transactions, and the notes quickly became dirty and ragged.

Merchants once again stepped into the void. Between 1861 and 1864, an estimated 25 million or more Civil War tokens were issued by thousands of businesses across the Northern states. These tokens are broadly divided into two categories:

• Store cards: Tokens that advertise a specific business, often with the merchant’s name, address, and type of goods sold on the reverse.
• Patriotic tokens: Tokens that feature patriotic slogans, flags, eagles, and political messages supporting the Union cause.

Notable Varieties and Rarities

In my experience grading Civil War tokens, some of the most sought-after varieties include:

• Lindenberger & Company (New York): Store cards from this merchant are highly prized for their detailed die work and strong eye appeal.
• Knickerbocker Currency: Patriotic tokens with the “Knickerbocker” design are among the most iconic of the series.
• Blacksmith tokens: Crude, hand-struck pieces made by actual blacksmiths — these are rare and historically fascinating.
• Unlisted die varieties: New die combinations are still being discovered, making this an active area of research.

The Government Crackdown

The proliferation of Civil War tokens eventually prompted federal action. In April 1864, Congress passed the Coinage Act of 1864, which introduced the bronze two-cent piece and, crucially, made the issuance of private tokens a criminal offense. This effectively ended the Civil War token era, making all issues from this period historical artifacts of a specific, bounded moment in American history.

Merchant Tokens: The Advertising Currency of the Industrial Age

Beyond the crisis-driven tokens of the Hard Times and Civil War eras, there exists a vast and varied world of merchant tokens — pieces issued by businesses for advertising, change-making, or internal use. This is where railway and transportation exonumia truly comes into its own.

Railway Tokens and Transportation Scrip

Railways across North America and Latin America issued an enormous variety of tokens and scrip. These served multiple purposes:

• Fare tokens: Used to pay for rides on streetcars, subways, and railways. Cities like Mexico City, New York, and Chicago produced millions of transit tokens.
• Company scrip: Issued by railway companies to pay employees, redeemable only at company stores. These are deeply controversial from a labor history perspective but are highly collectible with strong provenance when documented.
• Commemorative medals: Issued to celebrate railway openings, anniversaries, and milestones — directly analogous to the 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway commemorative.

Mexican Railway Numismatics

Given that the forum thread that inspired this article focused on a Mexican railway commemorative, it’s worth noting that Mexico has a particularly rich tradition of railway exonumia. The Ferrocarriles Nacionales de México (National Railways of Mexico) issued tokens, medals, and scrip throughout the late 19th and 20th centuries. The “Railroad Peso” referenced by forum members is a legendary piece in this series — and the 1947 pattern 5 Peso mentioned in the thread, graded MS-62, represents the kind of rarity that serious railway exonumia collectors dream about.

Key areas of Mexican railway exonumia to pursue include:

• Tokens from the Ferrocarril Mexicano (the main line between Mexico City and Veracruz)
• Tokens from the Ferrocarril Interoceánico (Interoceanic Railway)
• Tokens from the Ferrocarril del Pacífico (Pacific Railway)
• Commemorative medals from railway inaugurations and anniversaries
• Company scrip from mining railways in Chihuahua, Sonora, and other states

Historical Counterfeits: The Dark Side of Token Collecting

No discussion of exonumia would be complete without addressing historical counterfeits — and this is an area where I urge collectors to exercise particular caution.

Counterfeit Hard Times and Civil War Tokens

Even during the 19th century, tokens were being counterfeited. Some counterfeits were contemporary — made to deceive merchants and users — while others are modern fabrications created to deceive collectors. The key differences I look for when authenticating tokens include:

• Weight and diameter: Counterfeits often deviate from genuine specifications.
• Metal composition: Modern counterfeits may use different alloys than the originals.
• Die characteristics: Genuine tokens show consistent die characteristics across known examples. Counterfeits often have telltale differences in letter spacing, design details, or edge treatment.
• Patina and surface: Artificial aging can often be detected under magnification. A genuine patina develops over decades; a chemically induced one looks uniform and wrong.

The “Padfeet” and Other Notorious Counterfeits

In the world of Civil War tokens, certain counterfeit varieties are well-known to experienced collectors. The so-called “padfeet” — tokens with crude, oversized design elements — are among the most commonly encountered fakes. I always recommend that collectors purchase Civil War tokens from reputable dealers or, better yet, in PCGS or NGC holders with verified authenticity.

Counterfeit Commemorative Medals

Modern commemorative medals, including railway issues, are also targets for counterfeiters. The 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway commemorative, being a relatively recent issue, is less likely to have significant counterfeit problems — but as these pieces age and become scarcer, counterfeits will inevitably appear. My advice:

1. Always buy graded examples from PCGS, NGC, or ANACS when possible.
2. Study the genuine article — know the correct weight, diameter, edge type, and design details.
3. Be wary of deals that seem too good to be true — especially on online auction sites.
4. Join collector communities where authentication questions can be crowd-sourced from experienced members.

Building a Thematic Collection: Where to Start

For collectors inspired by the 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway commemorative who want to explore the broader world of exonumia, here is my recommended approach to building a meaningful thematic collection:

Step 1: Define Your Theme

The most successful exonumia collections have a clear focus. Railway tokens, transportation scrip, merchant tokens from a specific city or region, or political tokens from a specific era are all viable themes. The key is to be specific enough to create a coherent collection but broad enough to allow for ongoing acquisition.

Step 2: Invest in Reference Materials

Essential references for exonumia collectors include:

• “United States Hard Times Tokens” by Russell Rulau (the standard reference)
• “Civil War Tokens” by George and Melvin Fuld
• “American Political Badges and Medalets” by Edmund B. Sullivan
• “Russell Rulau’s World of Exonumia” series for international tokens
• Specialized catalogs for Mexican railway tokens and scrip (often available through Mexican numismatic societies)

Step 3: Network with Other Collectors

The forum thread that inspired this article is a perfect example of how collector communities function. Members shared images, asked questions about patterns and varieties, and helped each other identify and authenticate pieces. I cannot overstate the value of joining organizations like:

• The Token and Medal Society (TAMS)
• The Civil War Token Society (CWTS)
• The American Numismatic Association (ANA)
• Regional and online collector forums

Step 4: Prioritize Condition and Authenticity

As with all numismatics, condition matters enormously. For tokens, I recommend focusing on examples graded AU-50 or above for circulated pieces and MS-60 or above for uncirculated examples. Always verify authentication, especially for rare or expensive pieces.

Grading Exonumia: What to Look For

Grading tokens and exonumia follows the same general principles as grading coins, but with some important differences. Here’s what I examine when evaluating a token:

• Strike: Was the token fully struck up? A full, sharp strike dramatically improves eye appeal. Weak strikes are common with tokens, especially merchant issues.
• Surface: Look for scratches, corrosion, cleaning, or other impairments. Original surfaces are highly prized — they speak to honest provenance and careful storage.
• Color and toning: For copper and brass tokens, attractive natural toning adds significant value. I’m always drawn to pieces with rich, even color.
• Luster: Even on tokens, original mint luster can survive. It’s a beautiful thing to see on a piece that’s over a century old.
• Edge: Check for damage, filing, or alterations.
• Centering: While less critical for tokens than for modern coins, poor centering can affect overall presentation.

For the 1947 pattern 5 Peso mentioned in the forum thread, the MS-62 grade indicates a well-struck example with minor marks or hairlines — an excellent grade for a pattern coin, which often suffers from handling during the minting and approval process. Finding one in true mint condition is no small feat.

The Investment Case for Exonumia

While I collect primarily for the love of history and the thrill of the hunt, I’d be remiss not to mention the investment potential of exonumia. Several trends are driving increased demand and long-term collectibility:

• Growing interest in American history, particularly the Civil War and Jacksonian eras, is bringing new collectors to Hard Times and Civil War tokens.
• Transportation collecting is a well-established niche with strong institutional support from railway museums and historical societies.
• Mexican numismatics is experiencing a renaissance, with collectors worldwide recognizing the quality and historical significance of Mexican coinage and exonumia.
• Rarity: Many exonumia varieties exist in very limited quantities, creating scarcity that supports long-term value appreciation.

In my experience, the best investment strategy is to buy the finest examples you can afford of historically significant varieties. A PCGS MS-64 Hard Times token or a NGC MS-63 Civil War store card from a rare merchant will almost always outperform a collection of lower-grade common pieces.

Conclusion: The Unofficial Story of Money

The 2012-Mo 100 Pesos Southeast Railway Numismatic Heritage coin is a beautiful piece, and the forum discussion surrounding it — from the graded example shared by one collector to the tantalizing mention of a 1947 pattern 5 Peso in MS-62 — illustrates how official commemoratives can open doors to much deeper collecting journeys.

Hard Times tokens tell the story of economic crisis and political upheaval in Jacksonian America. Civil War tokens reveal the grassroots response to wartime scarcity. Merchant tokens document the rise of industrial capitalism and the advertising age. And railway exonumia — from Mexican Ferrocarril tokens to American transit fare pieces — chronicles the transportation revolution that reshaped the modern world.

Historical counterfeits remind us that the desire to profit from scarcity is as old as money itself, and they underscore the importance of authentication and expert guidance in building a collection.

Whether you’re a seasoned numismatist or a newcomer drawn in by a single commemorative coin, I encourage you to explore the world of exonumia. The unofficial money is, as I said at the outset, often more interesting than the official issues — and the stories it tells are every bit as valuable.

Happy collecting, and may your next acquisition be a rare one.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Currency Connection: Paper Money from the Era of the 2012-Mo 100 P Southeast Railway Numismatic Heritage – Coins never circulated in a vacuum. So let’s talk about the fascinating paper money that changed hands right along…
• The Science of the Strike: The Metallurgy of the 1952 Washington-Carver Half Dollar and the Gold Sticker Phenomenon – The way a coin ages, tones, and wears is entirely dependent on its metal alloy. Here is a scientific breakdown of this p…
• Can You Still Find Treasure at Flea Markets and Pawn Shops? A Professional Picker’s Guide to Haggling, Raw Coin Evaluation, and Building Pawn Broker Relationships – The days of easy finds are mostly gone, but there is still treasure out there if you know exactly what you are looking f…