Grading 1913 Buffalo Nickels: How Condition Separates $10 Coins from $1,000 Rarities

Historical Significance: The 1913 Buffalo Nickel Revolution

When it comes to Buffalo Nickels, condition isn’t just important—it’s everything! Let’s dive into the fascinating world of 1913 Type 1 and Type 2 varieties, where a millimeter of wear can transform a five-cent piece into a four-figure treasure. James Earle Fraser’s iconic redesign didn’t just change American coinage—it created two distinct legends in a single year. The Type 1 “Flat Ground” nickel, with its clean exergue beneath the buffalo, and the Type 2 “Raised Ground” variety, featuring reinforced lettering and base, represent a watershed moment in U.S. minting history. For collectors, recognizing these differences is the first step toward unlocking true numismatic value.

Identifying Key Markers: The Professional Grader’s Checklist

1. Wear Patterns: Nature’s Report Card

What separates a common find from a numismatic treasure? Follow this battle-tested approach:

• Buffalo’s Hip and Shoulder: These high points wear faster than morning dew in July. Preserved mint luster here? You’ve likely got an uncirculated gem
• Indian’s Cheekbone and Headband: Feather details softening like butter in the sun? That’s your AU/MS grade boundary marker
• Type 1 Base Line: That delicate flat ground disappears faster than cookies at a coin show. Any break means your coin danced through circulation

“When buffalo rims lose their bite, the coin’s lost its fight” – Wisdom from the Bison Collectors Forum

2. Luster: The Coin’s Living Skin

Original luster sings the truth about a nickel’s history. On these copper-nickel beauties, watch for:

• Circulation strikes: That satin glow—like moonlight on fresh snow—never fully mirrored
• Matte Proofs (the holy grail!): A distinctive sandy texture that’ll make your fingertips tingle just looking at it

The forum’s Type 1 specimen showcases classic Philly satin—warm and welcoming, like your favorite leather coin album.

3. Strike Quality: The Devil’s in the Details

Philadelphia’s presses worked overtime in 1913, creating striking variations:

• Weak Strikes: Type 1’s Achilles’ heel—look for ghostly horn tips and shy “FIVE CENTS” lettering
• Proof Perfection: Requires knife-edge lettering, buffalo hair you could comb, and rims sharp enough to slice paper (absent in both forum examples)

4. Eye Appeal: Love at First Sight

Two coins with identical grades can differ wildly in collectibility because of:

• Toning that dances between russet sunrise and stormcloud gray
• Cheek marks fainter than a buffalo’s whisper
• Centering so dramatic it could star in a Wild West show

Our forum’s Type 1 proves eye appeal conquers all—commenters rightly praised its “stunning presence” despite technical imperfections.

Circulation Strikes vs. Proofs: Hunting the White Buffalo

“Could this be proof?”—the question that quickens every collector’s pulse. Genuine 1913 Matte Proof Buffalo Nickels demand:

• Rims square enough to build a log cabin on
• Details sharper than a Comanche arrowhead
• Surfaces textured like freshly tanned buffalo hide

As old-timers say, “Proofs don’t whisper—they shout.” Only 3,034 proofs left the mint across both types, with survivors often bearing carbon spots like battle scars from improper storage.

Decoding the Grading Scales: PCGS/NGC Unveiled

Third-party grading separates the curious from the serious:

• MS-65: Luster covering three-quarters of the field, fewer marks than a choirboy’s record
• MS-63: Half the original glow, acceptable “character marks” from its journey
• AU-55: Just-kissed high points with lingering mint freshness
• Proof-64: Matte surfaces surviving like a frontier fort at high noon

The forum’s Type 1? A solid AU-55 to MS-62 candidate—the kind of coin that makes you smile. The Type 2? A Fine-15 to Very Fine-20 warrior showing its years of service.

Value Guide: What’s Your Buffalo Really Worth?

Current market snapshots (PCGS/CAC recognized):

• Type 1 MS-60: $125-$150 – weekend getaway money
• Type 1 MS-63: $300-$400 – a fine display case candidate
• Type 1 Matte Proof-64: $20,000+ – a life-changing rarity
• Type 2 VF-20: $10-$15 – less than a decent steak dinner
• Type 2 MS-65: $1,800-$2,500 – a crown jewel for any collection
• Type 2 Proof-64: $15,000+ – the stuff of legends

This spread explains why we obsess over details: That “common” Type 2 in your drawer could be lunch money or a down payment!

Conclusion: The Collector’s Manifesto

While neither forum coin proved to be a proof, their journey taught us this: Every Buffalo Nickel carries hidden stories waiting for knowledgeable eyes. Remember these three commandments:

1. Proofs don’t compromise—their rims stand at attention like soldiers
2. Luster never lies—satin means business, matte means museum
3. Wear patterns confess all—study them like a frontier tracker

Whether you’re holding a Type 1 masterpiece or a humble Type 2, remember: In our world, knowledge doesn’t just light the way—it fills the bank. Now go check those buffaloes in your collection!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Authenticating 1913 Buffalo Nickels: Proof vs. Circulation Strikes and How to Spot Counterfeits – Counterfeit Crisis: Why Your 1913 Buffalo Nickel Demands a Keen Eye After three decades of examining early 20th-century …
• Buffalo Nickel Treasure Hunt: Spotting Errors and Proofs in 1913 Type 1 & Type 2 Varieties – When you hold a 1913 Buffalo Nickel, you’re not just handling pocket change – you’re gripping a piece …
• 1913 Buffalo Nickels: Unraveling the Historical Secrets of Type 1 and Type 2 Varieties – The Hidden Stories Stamped in Nickel and Time As collectors, we know every coin whispers secrets of its era. The 1913 Bu…