Grading Long Island Collection Connecticut Coppers: How Pedigree and Preservation Turn Colonial Coins into Crown Jewels

For collectors of early American coppers, condition isn’t just important – it’s everything. Learning to read those subtle details could mean the difference between a $10 curiosity and a four-figure treasure. Let’s explore what makes these Long Island Collection-pedigreed Connecticut Coppers truly special.

Historical Significance: The Ghost Collection That Shaped Our Hobby

The Long Island Collection remains one of numismatics’ most enigmatic chapters. As noted by forum user @numis1652, this legendary grouping traces back to Donald G. Partrick, a discerning collector who learned from the great John Ford Jr. What makes these coins extraordinary? Partrick acquired them through Ford’s network during an era when provenance wasn’t just noted – it was earned through decades of numismatic detective work. His Connecticut Coppers in particular showcase Ford’s legendary eye for historical significance and carefully curated eye appeal.

“Don’s mentor was John Ford Jr until Don’s acquisition of Donald Miller’s token colln thru Ford. But that’s another story.” – @numis1652

These 1785-1788 New Haven mint coppers circulated during America’s most formative years. The Long Island pedigree matters because Partrick selected specimens with exceptional surfaces and provenance long before third-party grading existed. When you examine one of these coppers, you’re holding a piece that passed through the hands of titans who defined 20th-century collecting.

Identifying Key Markers: A Collector’s Grading Guide

Wear Patterns: Reading the Coin’s Journey

Connecticut Coppers present unique grading challenges – the devil’s in the details. Focus first on these high points:

• Obverse focal points: Liberty’s forehead, cheekbone, and shield rim
• Reverse critical areas: Warrior’s spear tip, knee, and left foot

The forum images reveal a specimen with strong VF details – Liberty’s forehead shows sharp definition while the shield exhibits moderate wear. This uneven patina tells a story of selective circulation, perhaps from repeated handling in colonial merchant exchanges.

Luster: Where Value Hides

Original surfaces separate pedigreed treasures from cleaned commons. Under proper lighting, hunt for:

• That magical cartwheel effect in protected fields
• Telltale parallel lines from improper cleaning (grade killers)
• The mottled olive-brown patina characteristic of Long Island specimens

Our example shows honest cabinet friction, not harsh cleaning. This is exactly why NGC would likely assign a “details grade” recognizing its original surfaces.

Strike Quality: Weak Strike or Circulation Wear?

These coppers are notorious for inconsistent strikes. Key diagnostic features:

• LIBERTY legend completeness (often faint on left)
• Detail in warrior’s right hand (first to show strike weakness)
• Edge denticles (complete=strong strike)

The forum coin displays a typical slightly off-center strike with full LIBERTY impression – a major plus despite some softness at the knee.

Eye Appeal: The Deal-Maker

This intangible quality separates good coins from great ones. For Connecticut Coppers, premium eye appeal means:

• Flawless planchets free of corrosion
• Toning that accentuates design elements
• Minimal distracting marks (allow 2-3 significant hits in XF)

Our Long Island specimen’s rich chocolate-brown surfaces with russet highlights would likely earn a PQ (Premium Quality) designation despite minor rim nicks – proof that eye appeal drives numismatic value.

Value Guide: When Provenance Meets Preservation

Grading Spectrum vs. Real World Prices

Current valuation benchmarks for Connecticut Coppers:

• VG-8: Partial LIBERTY, clear shield outline ($75-$150)
• F-12: Worn but defined cheekbone ($200-$400)
• XF-40: Light high-point wear, full legends ($800-$1,500)
• AU-55: Traces of mint luster ($2,500-$4,000)

Our forum coin sits solidly in F-15 to VF-20 range. Without pedigree? Maybe $300-600. But with Long Island provenance and original surfaces, recent auctions tell a different story:

• Heritage 2021: F-15 (PCGS) with Partrick pedigree – $1,880
• Stack’s Bowers 2022: VF-25 (NGC) no pedigree – $660

The Pedigree Premium: Slabbing Strategy

As @lordmarcovan wisely asked: “Is pedigree notation worth the submission cost?” Our advice:

• Sub-XF grades: 25-50% premium only if certified on label
• AU+ coins: Provenance can double value (Ford-pedigreed pieces often triple guide!)
• Always submit documentation – provenance without proof is just provenance

Conclusion: More Than Metal

This Long Island Connecticut Copper embodies why we collect – historical significance meets numismatic excellence. While its VF details might not dazzle at first glance, the Partrick-Ford provenance transforms it from colonial curiosity to collectibility icon. As grading services increasingly recognize historical importance alongside technical merit, such coins become dual-threat treasures. Handle it with reverence – you’re safeguarding both early American history and the legacy of numismatic passion.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Crafting History: Evaluating Fairmont-Pedigreed Coins for Jewelry Potential – Before transforming history into wearable art, let’s explore what makes these Fairmont Collection coins so special…
• Authenticating Fairmont Collection Coins: Detecting Counterfeit Gold Eagles and Indian Heads – With Counterfeits Circulating, Spotting True Fairmont Collection Coins Matters Now More Than Ever The Fairmont Collectio…
• Hidden Treasures: Expert Guide to Identifying Valuable Errors in Fairmont-Pedigreed Coins – The Allure of Fairmont-Pedigreed Coins While most see only currency, collectors recognize history hidden beneath the sur…