Grading Two More Classic Commems Added to the Stable: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000

Condition Is Everything: How to Determine the True Grade of the 1936-D and 1938-S Boone Commemorative Half Dollars

When it comes to classic commemoratives, condition is everything. I’ve spent decades handling these pieces, and I can tell you that two coins from the same series, struck from the same dies, can command dramatically different prices based solely on their preservation. The Boone commemorative half dollar series is a perfect case study in how subtle gradation differences translate into massive value disparities. In this article, I’ll walk you through the grading breakdown of two recent additions to my stable — the 1936-D and the 1938-S Boone half dollars — examining wear patterns, luster, strike quality, and eye appeal through the lens of PCGS and NGC standards.

Historical Context: The Boone Commemorative Series and Its Distribution

The Daniel Boone Bicentennial Commemorative Half Dollar was authorized by Congress to honor the legendary frontiersman on the 200th anniversary of his birth. The series ran from 1934 through 1938, with multiple mintmarks produced across those years at the Denver (D) and San Francisco (S) facilities. What makes this series particularly fascinating to collectors is the dramatic decline in mintages as the late 1930s progressed — a period when the commemorative coin market, in my assessment, had become thoroughly saturated and “all played out,” as collectors of that era would say. The collectibility of these dates hinges heavily on surviving populations and original condition.

The 1936-D Boone commemorative was produced in a mintage of approximately 5,000 pieces, sold directly to the public and through distributors. The 1938-S, with a mintage of only 2,100 coins, is tied for the second-lowest mintage in the entire series and represents a true rare variety. These are genuinely scarce dates that reward the knowledgeable grader who can identify subtle condition differences that separate a coin worth $10 from one worth $1,000 or more.

An important note for collectors: distribution of these commemoratives often came through specific channels. I want to clarify that Stacks was a distributor for the Arkansas commemorative set in 1937, not the Boone set as some sources have incorrectly stated. The Boone set, however, was frequently offered in presentation cases, and the surviving population of these cases adds another layer of collectibility and grading consideration. Provenance from these original packages significantly boosts the numismatic value of a piece that was never removed from its original packaging.

The 1936-D Boone Commemorative: Grading Breakdown

The 1936-D Boone half dollar presents unique grading challenges that I have encountered many times over the years. With a mintage of roughly 5,000 pieces, survival rates are low, but the coins that do survive are often found in circulated condition, having been purchased as souvenirs or pocket pieces by the public during the late 1930s. Finding one in true mint condition today is a real treat.

Obverse Examination: Daniel Boone’s Profile

When grading the obverse of the 1936-D, I focus first on the high points of Daniel Boone’s portrait — specifically the cheekbone, the forehead, and the hair above the ear. These are the first areas to exhibit friction wear in everyday circulation. In a coin graded PCGS VF-20, you will see clear flattening on Boone’s cheek with the detail beginning to soften. At AU-50, the cheek retains a hint of rounded dimensionality, and the hair above the ear still shows some definition, though the very highest point may show the first signs of planar wear.

Key grading markers on the obverse include:

• Forehead: The highest point of the design; wear here appears earliest and is the most reliable indicator of grade.
• Cheekbone: Friction from pocket carry and handling wears this area down before any other feature.
• Hair detail above the ear: The last area to retain full detail in uncirculated examples.
• Date and mintmark (D): The “3” in “1936” and the “D” mintmark are susceptible to wear; sharpness here confirms the grade.

Reverse Examination: The Frontier Pioneer Scene

The reverse of the 1936-D features a detailed scene of a frontier pioneer and a Native American. The high points on this side include the figures themselves, the tree line in the background, and the inscription “HALF DOLLAR.” In my experience, the reverse tends to show slightly less wear than the obverse because it was the side facing outward when coins were stored or displayed, but friction on the central figures is still a primary grading factor. When evaluating the reverse, I pay particular attention to strike quality and the following areas:

• The pioneer figure’s raised arm and rifle: These protruding elements are the first to lose detail.
• The Native American figure’s facial features and headdress: Wear here is a reliable secondary indicator.
• The lettering of “HALF DOLLAR”: The high points of the serifs on the letters are vulnerable to abrasion.
• The background tree line and mountain detail: Fine lines in the reverse field are among the first design elements to disappear in lower grades.

The 1938-S Boone Commemorative: Grading Breakdown

The 1938-S Boone half dollar is the rarer of the two coins, with only 2,100 pieces struck. This low mintage, combined with the fact that the series was winding down and public interest was waning, means that uncirculated examples are genuinely scarce and command significant premiums. As a professional grader, I find the 1938-S to be a coin where every single grade point matters enormously.

Understanding the Strike Quality of the 1938-S

One of the most critical factors in grading the 1938-S Boone is understanding its strike characteristics. The San Francisco Mint produced this coin late in the commemorative era, and the dies were not always prepared with the same care as earlier issues. I have observed that the 1938-S typically exhibits moderate strike weakness on the obverse, particularly in the hair detail and the folds of Boone’s clothing. This means that a coin with full strike for its era is worth a notable premium, even at the same numerical grade. When I am evaluating the 1938-S for a submission to PCGS or NGC, I consider the following strike-related factors:

1. Full definition of Boone’s hair curls: Coins that retain complete detail in the hair receive the highest marks for strike quality.
2. Sharpness of the portrait outline: A fully struck 1938-S will show a clean, well-defined border between Boone’s profile and the background.
3. Reverse central figures: The pioneer and Native American should both display full facial detail; weakness here is common and factored into the overall assessment.
4. Edge preservation: Sharp reeding without bulges or irregularities indicates a well-struck specimen.

The 1938-S in circulated grades

In circulated grades, the 1938-S Boone shows wear patterns consistent with other half dollars of the era, but because of its low mintage, even lightly worn examples are valuable. A coin graded VG-8 will show moderate wear on Boone’s highest points, with the date still readable but softened. At AU-50, the coin should exhibit only the faintest traces of wear on the high points, with the majority of the surface retaining original luster. Sometimes, you’ll even find attractive patina developing on these surfaces, which adds to the coin’s overall charm.

Luster and Surface Preservation: The Heart of Grading

Luster is the single most important factor in determining the grade of any classic commemorative, and the Boone half dollars are no exception. Original luster — the microscopic texture of the coin’s surface created during the striking process — is what separates a coin graded by PCGS or NGC from one that merely looks shiny.

In my experience grading the Boone commemoratives, I look for the following luster characteristics:

• Original cartwheel luster: This is the rainbow-like iridescence visible when the coin is tilted under a light source. On the 1936-D and 1938-S, original cartwheel luster is a strong indicator that the coin has never been dipped, cleaned, or otherwise impaired.
• Surface texture: The fields of a well-preserved Boone half dollar should exhibit a slightly granular, velvety texture. This is the natural result of the coin’s strike and is a hallmark of originality.
• Tonal variations: The 1936-D often displays warm golden or amber tones in the fields, while the 1938-S can show cooler, silvery tones or subtle patina. These tonal qualities do not directly affect the numerical grade but significantly impact eye appeal and market value.

When submitting either coin to PCGS or NGC, I always note whether the coin has been dipped or cleaned, as this information is recorded in the grading service’s population reports and affects the coin’s long-term value trajectory. A naturally toned, original-surface Boone half dollar will always outperform a dipped example of the same numerical grade.

Eye Appeal: Beyond the Numerical Grade

Eye appeal is the intangible quality that separates a coin worth the base value for its grade from one that commands a significant premium. In my professional grading experience, eye appeal is determined by a combination of factors that ultimately dictate the numismatic value of the piece:

1. Luster quality and intensity: A coin with brilliant, undisturbed luster immediately catches the eye and suggests a higher grade than one with muted surfaces.
2. Tonal attractiveness: Rich, even toning — whether golden, amber, or silver — adds visual appeal that collectors and investors are willing to pay for.
3. Absence of distracting marks: Hairline scratches, environmental damage, or contact marks in the fields or on the high points of the design detract from eye appeal and can effectively lower the perceived grade.
4. Strike sharpness relative to the date: A fully struck 1938-S Boone with sharp details will look more impressive than a weakly struck example at the same numerical grade, and the market reflects this difference.
5. Surface cleanliness: Original surface free of oxidation spots, residue, or environmental damage is a major contributor to eye appeal.

For the Boone commemoratives specifically, I have found that coins with original, unblemished surfaces and attractive toning consistently achieve prices at the upper end of their grade bracket. When buying or selling, always request high-resolution images of both the obverse and reverse, paying close attention to the fields and high points.

PCGS and NGC Standards: How the Major Grading Services Evaluate Boone Commemoratives

The Professional Coin Grading

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Design Evolution: Tracing the Artistic Lineage of Variation #49/50 — From Previous Types to Succeeding Designs and the Legacy of Mike Byers – Coin Designs Don’t Appear Out of Nowhere; They Evolve Every coin tells a story, but the story of its design — the …
• Can’t Afford the Key Date? The Best Budget Alternatives to Chasing the World’s Most Famous Coin Dealer – Not everyone has thousands to drop on a single piece of metal—and honestly, I don’t think they should have to. Her…
• Is Your 1936-D & 1938-S Boone Commemorative Real? The Authentication Expert’s Guide to Spotting Fakes – Introduction: Why the Boone Commemoratives Demand Authentication Expertise Why let a counterfeit steal your piece of his…