How I Authenticated a 1969 D Penny Cracked Planchet: Step-by-Step Guide to Spotting Errors

I Ran Into This Exact 1969 D Penny Problem – Here’s How I Solved It

Staring at what looked like a crack on my 1969 D penny, I felt that collector’s dilemma – rare find or damaged goods? After weeks of false starts and consultations with seasoned numismatists, I finally unlocked the secrets of authentic cracked planchets. Let me save you the headache with what actually worked.

Understanding Cracked Planchets vs. Post-Mint Damage

When I first spotted that suspicious line on my 1969 D penny, I nearly tossed it back into my wheat penny jar. But something about how the light caught the groove made me pause. Through trial and error (emphasis on error), I found three game-changing distinctions:

1. The Metal Flow Test

True planchet cracks have a telltale “healed” texture you won’t find in damaged coins. As one grizzled coin show veteran told me while squinting at my penny:

“See how the metal flows like pancake batter over Lincoln’s cheek? That’s your smoking gun. Post-mint damage just gouges without blending.”

2. Depth and Position Analysis

Here’s how I learned to read the cracks like Braille:

• Play flashlight tag across the surface at different angles
• Watch how the crack interacts with the memorial building details
• Check if edges look torn (bad) or fused (good)

My Step-by-Step Authentication Process

Step 1: Macro Photography Setup

You don’t need fancy gear – I used:

• My iPhone with a $15 clip-on macro lens
• A desk lamp with the shade removed
• My daughter’s black velvet headband as a background

The close-ups revealed secrets my 40-year-old eyes couldn’t see.

Step 2: The Device Interruption Test

This became my holy grail for 1969 D penny authentication. True planchet cracks flow through design elements like ghosts passing through walls. I scrutinized:

• Whether Lincoln’s jawline continued uninterrupted
• If memorial columns showed deflection
• How light pooled in the crevice

Step 3: Edge Examination Protocol

Grabbing my kid’s science-class magnifier (10x is enough!), I:

• Checked if reeding lines stuttered at the crack
• Rolled the penny on its edge like a tiny wheel
• Hunted for that signature “metal kiss” where cracks terminate

Common Pitfalls I Discovered

Learn from my blunders – these almost cost me a legit error coin:

Mistake 1: Confusing Die Cracks With Planchet Cracks

I wasted weeks on this! Here’s how I tell them apart now: die cracks look like raised scars, while planchet cracks resemble canyons in the metal.

Mistake 2: Overlooking Environmental Damage

Garage chemistry can mimic mint errors. My simple garage test:

• Swab with rubbing alcohol (the 90% stuff)
• Real cracks stay clean – fake ones weep gunk
• Watch for suspicious color changes

Expert Verification Tactics That Worked

When my eyes crossed from staring at pennies, I turned to:

• PCGS’s online review (sent better photos than my wedding pics)
• The grumpy-but-brilliant guy at our local coin shop
• Side-by-side comparisons with known error coins

Key Takeaways for Fellow Collectors

After burning through three magnifiers and developing a permanent squint:

• Lighting is everything – use multiple angles
• A cheap loupe beats no loupe every time
• Professional grading costs less than regret

Conclusion: Patience Pays in Error Coin Identification

My 1969 D penny cracked planchet journey taught me that real treasures hide in plain sight. The true winners show that seamless metal flow, ignore design boundaries, and have that distinctive “healed” look. While my kitchen-table forensics took months, you can now spot these mint mistakes with confidence. Happy hunting – your next coin might just be sitting in that coffee can of change!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 5 Costly Lincoln Cent Mistakes Even Seasoned Collectors Make (And How to Avoid Them) – I’ve Watched Collectors Lose Thousands – Don’t Be Next In my 35 years of hunting Lincoln cents, I&#821…
• The Hidden Economics of Circulated Lincoln Cents: An Expert’s Guide to Market Dynamics – Here’s what most collectors miss about the humble Lincoln cent – and why it matters to your collection. Thos…
• Identify Valuable Toned Jefferson Nickels in 3 Steps (Quick Collector’s Guide) – Short on Time? Here’s What Actually Works Staring at Jefferson nickels wondering if that colorful toning means pay…