How to Spot Rare Errors on Do You Think That it is Time to Get Rid of the Presidents on Coins

Introduction: The Details That Separate Common from Rare

Do you think it is time to get rid of the presidents on coins? I hear that debate constantly, but honestly? It misses the forest for the trees. Whether you love the legacy of Washington or think it’s time for a change, one thing remains undeniably true: these coins are packed with hidden treasure. Most people flip through rolls of presidential copper looking for dates or mint marks. But the real hunt? It’s about spotting a rare variety that transforms pocket change into a fortune. I’ve spent over two decades examining these coins under magnification, and I can tell you, the numismatic value isn’t in the portrait—it’s in the imperfections. From the Lincoln cent to the Presidential dollar series, every denomination carries die cracks, double strikes, and mint mark quirks waiting to be found. This is my Variety & Error Guide, Variation #3, dedicated to uncovering what hides in your change jar.

Die Cracks: The Silent Signatures of Worn Dies

Die cracks are the bread and butter of error hunting. When a mint die takes a beating, microscopic stress fractures develop. They show up as thin, raised lines on the struck coin, tracing the contours of the original design. Some are invisible without a loupe; others scream for attention.

Key Die Crack Locations on Presidential Coins

Here is where I focus my eyes when I’m sorting through rolls:

• Lincoln Cents (1909–present): Look along Lincoln’s cheek, through the word “LIBERTY,” and near the wheat stalks on pre-1959 reverses. The 1955 doubled die is famous, but die cracks on earlier VDB cents are just as rewarding for collectors seeking a rare variety.
• Roosevelt Dimes (1946–present): I often find cracks running through Roosevelt’s nose, along the torch, or across the fasces. Early dimes from 1946 and 1947 show dramatic cracking due to the high relief of the original strike.
• Jefferson Nickels (1938–present): Check Monticello’s dome, the “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” inscription, and the bison’s horn on pre-1938 Buffalo predecessors. The 1960 and 1970 small date nickels are legendary for their die patterns.
• Washington Quarters (1932–present): A goldmine for crack hunters. Look through Washington’s hair, across the eagle’s wings, and along “IN GOD WE TRUST.” The Statehood and America the Beautiful quarters offer entirely new patterns still being catalogued today.

Why Die Cracks Matter for Value

Not every crack is a money-maker. In my experience, a minor line that doesn’t ruin the coin’s eye appeal might only add a small premium. But a dramatic crack cutting through “LIBERTY” or Washington’s eye? That multiplies the value significantly. Documentation is key. I always photograph these features under consistent lighting at 10x magnification, comparing them against the Cherrypickers’ Guide. The provenance of the crack—where it sits relative to the design—is what separates a common scratch from a highly collectible rare variety.

Double Dies: The Crown Jewels of Error Hunting

If die cracks are the bread and butter, true double dies are the filet mignon. A genuine doubled die happens when the hub misaligns during the hubbing process, leaving a secondary image offset from the primary design. Don’t confuse this with mechanical doubling—caused by a coin shifting during the strike—which is common and barely worth the copper.

Presidential Double Die Varieties You Need to Know

1. The 1955 Doubled Die Lincoln Cent: The undisputed king. The doubling on the date and “LIBERTY” is visible to the naked eye. I’ve seen MS-65 examples sell for over $1,500.
2. The 1972 Doubled Die Lincoln Cent: This comes in three die positions. The most valuable shows doubling in “TRUST” and the date digits. Subtle, but unmistakable under a loupe.
3. The 1995 Doubled Die Lincoln Cent: A modern rarity showing doubling on the obverse portrait. Mostly found in proof sets, but occasionally circulates.
4. Double Die Reverse Washington Quarters: Less common than Lincoln cents, but highly sought after. Look for doubling in the eagle’s feathers or “E PLURIBUS UNUM.”
5. Roosevelt Dime Double Dies: True double dies on dimes are rare but documented. The 1968 and 1970-S dimes have known doubled die obverse varieties that command serious premiums.

How to Distinguish True Doubled Dies from Mechanical Doubling

This is where novices lose their way. Mechanical doubling creates a flat, shelf-like secondary image parallel to the design. A true doubled die shows a distinct offset with slight rotation and curvature. I use a 10x triplet loupe and rotate the coin under a light. If the doubling looks uniform and flat, it’s mechanical. If the secondary image follows the contours of the design with depth, you might be holding a genuine doubled die that will elevate the coin’s collectibility.

Mint Mark Variations: Small Characters, Big Consequences

Mint marks are tiny, but they hold massive weight. The position, size, and style of a mint mark can determine whether a coin is just another piece of circulation or a rare variety worth hundreds. Every mint mark has a provenance, a story of where it was punched and why it ended up slightly off-center.

Mint Mark Positions and Their Significance

• Lincoln Cents: Mint marks have moved three times: below the wreath, below the date on wartime steel cents, and below the date today. The 1943 steel cent is a major variety, but even within that series, the alignment of the “D” and “S” marks varies by die pair—a key diagnostic for collectors.
• Roosevelt Dimes: Mint marks sit above the date. The 1968-S proof dime was the first struck at San Francisco since 1955. I’ve also found repunched mint marks on early dimes, a classic VAM diagnostic that boosts collectibility.
• Jefferson Nickels: Look above Monticello’s dome on the reverse. The 1950-D/S is a famous overdate where the “S” was punched over a “D.” It remains a holy grail for error hunters.
• Washington Quarters: Early quarters (1932–1964) show the mint mark below the eagle. From 1965 to 1967, mint marks vanished. From 1968 onward, they returned above the date. The 1971-S without a mint mark is a known error—extremely rare and highly valuable.

Repunched Mint Marks and Overdates

Repunched mint marks happen when a worker strikes the mark, realizes it’s misaligned, and punches it again. These are catalogued in the VAM system. I’ve personally identified several VAM varieties on Washington quarters and Roosevelt dimes. Depending on the severity of the repunch and the coin’s mint condition, these pieces have sold for premiums ranging from $50 to over $2,000. The provenance of that double punch is what gives the coin its story.

Off-Center Strikes and Other Mechanical Errors

Beyond cracks and doubles, presidential coins show off other mechanical errors. An off-center strike happens when the blank isn’t aligned in the collar. The percentage of the missing design directly impacts the value. I’ve seen Lincoln cents with 10% to 40% of the design missing, worth $50 to $200 based on the visibility of the date and the overall strike quality.

Other mechanical errors I always check for include:

• Clipped Planchets: A blank improperly cut from the strip, leaving a crescent-shaped missing area along the rim.
• Broadstrikes: Coins that escaped the collar entirely, spreading flat beyond their normal diameter with a featureless rim.
• Struck Through Errors: Debris, a retaining clip, or another coin trapped between the die and planchet, leaving a ghostly impression on the strike.
• Lamination Errors: Partial delamination of the coin’s layers, especially on clad post-1965 quarters and dimes where the outer layer separates from the core.

How to Build a Presidential Error Collection

Ready to start hunting? Here is my approach after years of pulling coins from rolls:

1. Get a 10x loupe and a strong light. You can’t spot most varieties without magnification. A triplet loupe reduces optical distortion and reveals the true eye appeal of a coin’s surface.
2. Buy the Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties. Authored by Bill Fivaz and J.T. Stanton, this is the essential reference. It covers every major presidential series with photos and descriptions.
3. Join a variety attribution community. The VAM community is incredibly active. Online forums and Facebook groups connect you with experienced hunters who can confirm your finds.
4. Sort by date and mint mark first. Searching unsorted rolls is like finding a needle in a haystack. Sort your coins, then examine each group systematically.
5. Get your best pieces certified. If you find a significant error, submit it to PCGS or NGC. A certified coin in mint condition carries far more value and credibility than an uncertified specimen.

The Collectibility Factor: Why Presidential Errors Endure

The debate over presidents on our coins is cultural and aesthetic. But from a numismatic perspective, over a century of continuous production means the pool of varieties and errors is virtually inexhaustible. Every new year brings new die cracks, new double die occurrences, and new mint mark anomalies for collectors to discover.

Whether you are hunting for a 1955 doubled die cent in your pocket change or spending hours under a microscope cataloguing VAM varieties, this pursuit connects you to a living tradition of American numismatics. The coins carry the faces of presidents we love or loathe, but the errors within them are universal. They are the fingerprints of the minting process—imperfections that give each coin its unique collectibility and historical weight.

Conclusion: Every Coin Tells a Story

Presidential coinage is more than just currency—it is a canvas for the minting process. Every die crack, double strike, and mint mark variation tells a story about the conditions under which that coin was created. As an error hunter, I find this endlessly fascinating. Whether you are casually searching rolls or a serious variety specialist chasing VAM listings, the presidential series offers a lifetime of discovery.

The next time you receive a presidential coin in change, take a moment to look closely. Examine the hairline details, check the mint mark position, rotate the coin under a light to look for doubling, and feel the surface for any unusual patina, texture, or luster. You might just find the next rare variety hiding in plain sight. And in the world of error coin hunting, that is the thrill that keeps us coming back roll after roll, coin after coin, year after year.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Hidden History Behind Do You Think That it is Time to Get Rid of the Presidents on Coins: A Numismatic Journey Through America’s Coinage Legacy – Every relic tells a story, and I’ve spent my life pulling those stories from rolls of silver and copper. The debat…
• How to Integrate New Shipwreck Coin Acquisition into a Master Type Set: The SS Republic Seated Liberty Dollar – Introduction: Why Shipwreck Coins Deserve a Place in Your Type Set Building a type set is the ultimate numismatic journe…
• Teaching Kids About History with Proof Half Dollars: A Parent-Educator’s Guide to 1939, 1951, and 1952 Coins – Holding History in Small Hands: Why Coins Make Perfect Teaching Tools Holding a piece of history in your hand is the bes…