How to Spot Rare Errors on New not-PCGS Counterfeits: A Collector’s Guide

The Growing Threat of Sophisticated Counterfeits

Most collectors overlook the tiny details that can transform a common coin into a rarity worth thousands. Today’s counterfeiters are becoming alarmingly sophisticated, producing fakes that can deceive even seasoned numismatists. The specimens discussed in this thread represent a particularly troubling development in the world of numismatic fraud.

Understanding the Current Threat Landscape

These counterfeit coins appear to be 1796-dated pieces, but they’re actually struck from dies based on the 1795 far-left obverse design. This subtle distinction is crucial for authentication. What makes these counterfeits especially dangerous is their appearance in not-PCGS slabs with identical barcodes that fail to scan properly.

Key Markers for Authentication

Die Characteristics and Variations

When examining potential counterfeits, pay close attention to die characteristics. The “1796” specimens mentioned use the same counterfeit die pair discussed in previous threads. Look for:

• Inconsistent die cracks that don’t match known genuine examples
• Unusual doubling patterns suggesting transfer dies rather than genuine hub doubling
• Irregular mint mark placement or style variations

Slab Authentication Issues

The new counterfeits come in slabs with a distinctive “4 prong gasket” – a feature reportedly only found in fake PGCS slabs. Additionally, collectors have noted that the plastic in these counterfeit slabs is unusually brittle and develops spiderweb fractures shortly after encapsulation, even without apparent cause.

Specific Error Types to Watch For

Die Cracks and Breaks

Genuine die cracks follow predictable patterns based on the die’s stress points and usage. Counterfeit dies often show:

• Overly crisp or exaggerated die cracks
• Cracks in locations inconsistent with genuine die wear patterns
• Multiple crack directions suggesting poor die preparation

Double Die Varieties

While genuine doubled dies command premium numismatic value, counterfeit doubling often appears suspicious. Look for:

• Uniform doubling across all design elements (genuine doubling is usually isolated)
• Sharp, almost 3D-like doubling rather than the softer appearance of true hub doubling
• Doubling that affects the coin’s surface texture rather than just the design

Mint Mark Variations

Counterfeiters often struggle with accurate mint mark reproduction. Examine:

• The size and shape consistency with known genuine examples
• Placement relative to the date and other design elements
• Whether the mint mark appears to be part of the original die or a later addition

Quality Indicators and Red Flags

Surface Analysis

The quality of these new counterfeits is described as “scary” and “just keeps getting better and better.” However, even high-quality fakes often reveal themselves through:

• Inconsistent luster across the coin’s surface
• Unnatural color or toning patterns
• Surface textures that don’t match the expected wear patterns for the coin’s alleged age

Weight and Dimensions

While not mentioned in the thread, always verify that suspect coins match the standard specifications for their type. Even minor deviations in weight, diameter, or thickness can indicate a counterfeit.

Historical Context and Provenance

The 1796 Bust Dollar Connection

The counterfeits discussed appear to be targeting the valuable 1796 Bust Dollar series. Understanding the historical context is crucial:

The “1796” is roughly the same counterfeit die pair that we discussed in a thread last week. The fake in last week’s thread had simulated wear and damage and was in a real PCGS slab (oops).

Previous Discussions and Research

This isn’t the first time these counterfeits have appeared. The thread references a February 2025 article (which cites 2022 and 2020 articles) on this family of fakes based on the 1795 far-left obverse design. This ongoing research highlights the importance of staying current with authentication developments.

Value Guide and Market Impact

Financial Implications

The increasing sophistication of counterfeits has serious financial implications for collectors. A single undetected fake can result in losses of thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars. The fact that these counterfeits are appearing in slabs (even if not genuine PCGS holders) makes them particularly dangerous.

Authentication Best Practices

Given the evolving threat, collectors should:

• Always verify slab barcodes through official channels
• Be especially cautious with high-value dates and varieties
• Consider professional authentication for any suspicious pieces
• Stay informed about the latest counterfeit detection techniques

Conclusion: Vigilance in the Modern Market

The counterfeit coins discussed in this thread represent a significant challenge for today’s collectors. With quality that’s “just keeps getting better and better,” traditional authentication methods may no longer be sufficient. By understanding the specific markers discussed – from die cracks and doubling patterns to slab characteristics and historical context – collectors can better protect themselves and their investments.

Remember that even experienced collectors can be fooled by sophisticated counterfeits. When in doubt, seek professional authentication and always buy from reputable sources. The numismatic community’s collective vigilance is our best defense against the growing threat of high-quality counterfeits.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Hidden History Behind 1796 Bust Dollar Counterfeits: A Numismatic Mystery – The Birth of American Silver Dollars 1796 witnessed a defining moment in American numismatics. Just four years after est…
• Market Value Analysis: The Rising Threat of Advanced Counterfeit Coins in Modern Holders – Introduction: A New Era of Counterfeiting True numismatic value isn’t just about price guides—it’s the thril…
• Finding Rare Coins in the Wild: A Cherry Picker’s Guide to Circulation Hunting – Introduction: The Thrill of Coin Sleuthing Forget dealer showcases—some of our field’s most electrifying discoveri…