Is Your Chinese Cash Coin Real? Authentication Guide for Qianlong, Daoguang, and Japanese Kanei Coins

Introduction: The Authentication Crisis in Ancient Coin Collecting

With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for Chinese cash coins is critical. These small, round copper coins with square holes were the backbone of Chinese currency for over two millennia, but their simple appearance makes them prime targets for modern counterfeiters. In this comprehensive authentication guide, we’ll examine three coins from a recent collector’s inquiry and provide you with the tools to verify authenticity yourself.

Historical Context: Understanding Chinese Cash Coins

Chinese cash coins, known as “wen” or “qian,” were first introduced during the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BCE) and remained in circulation until the early 20th century. Their distinctive design features a square hole in the center, allowing them to be strung together for easier counting and transport. The coins discussed here span different periods and regions, each with unique characteristics that aid in authentication.

The Qianlong Emperor Coin (1736-1795)

The top coin in the collection belongs to the Qianlong Emperor’s reign, catalogued as KM#391. This coin represents one of the most prolific periods of Chinese coinage, with billions produced across multiple mints. The Board of Works mint, identified on this specimen, was one of the primary government-operated facilities during this era.

The Japanese Kanei Coin (1603-1868)

The middle coin, initially mistaken for Chinese, is actually Japanese. The Kanei period (1603-1868) saw the production of distinctive square-holed coins that were heavily influenced by Chinese designs but maintained their own unique characteristics. These coins were produced in various Japanese provinces and often bear different inscriptions than their Chinese counterparts.

The Daoguang Emperor Coin (1820-1850)

The bottom coin dates to the Daoguang Emperor’s reign, also produced at the Board of Works mint. This period saw significant economic challenges in China, which affected coin production quality and consistency. These later coins often show more wear and less precise craftsmanship than earlier specimens.

Authentication Methods: Testing for Authenticity

Weight Verification: The First Line of Defense

Authentic Chinese cash coins have specific weight ranges that vary by period and mint. For Qianlong period coins, expect weights between 3.2 to 4.0 grams. Daoguang period coins typically weigh slightly less due to economic pressures and metal shortages. Japanese Kanei coins have their own distinct weight ranges, usually between 2.5 to 3.5 grams.

To test weight accurately:

• Use a precision digital scale accurate to 0.01 grams
• Weigh multiple specimens of the same type for comparison
• Account for natural wear and corrosion, which can reduce weight over centuries

Magnetic Properties: A Simple but Effective Test

Most authentic Chinese cash coins are made from bronze or brass alloys containing copper, tin, and zinc. These should not be attracted to magnets. If your coin is strongly magnetic, this is an immediate red flag suggesting modern steel-based counterfeits.

However, some later Chinese coins and Japanese Kanei coins may contain small amounts of iron in their alloy, resulting in weak magnetic attraction. This makes the magnetic test useful but not definitive on its own.

Die Markers and Manufacturing Characteristics

Authentic ancient coins show specific manufacturing characteristics that are difficult to replicate perfectly in modern counterfeits:

Qianlong Period Markers

• Sharp, well-defined characters with consistent stroke width
• Slight irregularities in character spacing due to hand-operated presses
• Natural patina development with verdigris in protected areas
• Edge filing marks from the casting process

Daoguang Period Markers

• Less precise character formation due to economic pressures
• More pronounced casting sprues and filing marks
• Thinner overall coin thickness compared to earlier periods
• Varied patina colors from dark green to brownish tones

Japanese Kanei Markers

• Distinctive character style different from Chinese inscriptions
• Often shows more pronounced casting seams
• May have different metal composition, sometimes with higher zinc content
• Characters typically read clockwise when viewed from the front

Visual Inspection: What to Look For

High-quality photographs are essential for authentication. Look for these specific details:

Surface Characteristics

“The bottom coin shows signs of age-appropriate wear, with a natural patina that has developed over centuries of handling and environmental exposure. The character definition remains clear despite the wear, which is characteristic of genuine specimens.”

Patina Analysis

Authentic coins develop natural patina over centuries. Look for:

• Verdigris (green copper carbonate) in protected areas
• Even wear patterns consistent with circulation
• Natural color variations rather than uniform artificial toning
• Crystallization patterns in the patina that are difficult to fake

Edge and Rim Examination

The edges of authentic coins often show:

• Evidence of filing to remove casting sprues
• Natural wear from centuries of handling
• Consistent thickness with minor variations typical of hand production
• No modern tool marks or sharp, unworn edges

Common Counterfeits and How to Spot Them

Modern Cast Counterfeits

The most common fakes are created using modern casting techniques. These often show:

• Soft, indistinct character edges
• Uniform patina that looks artificially applied
• Incorrect weight (usually too heavy due to modern metal composition)
• Lack of natural wear patterns

Tooled and Enhanced Coins

Some genuine coins are altered to appear more valuable:

• Characters sharpened or enhanced with modern tools
• Patina artificially added or removed
• Coins combined from multiple genuine specimens
• Modern cleaning that removes natural patina

Modern Struck Counterfeits

High-quality machine-struck fakes can be particularly deceptive:

• Perfectly uniform characters with no hand-struck irregularities
• Incorrect metal composition detectable only through advanced testing
• Modern die wear patterns that don’t match historical manufacturing
• Often too perfect in appearance

Advanced Testing Methods

Specific Gravity Testing

This non-destructive test compares the coin’s density to known standards for bronze and brass alloys. Authentic coins should fall within specific gravity ranges of 8.5-8.9 g/cm³ for typical Chinese cash coin alloys.

XRF Analysis

X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy can determine exact metal composition without damaging the coin. This is particularly useful for detecting modern alloys that may look authentic but contain incorrect proportions of copper, tin, and zinc.

Microscopic Examination

Under magnification, authentic coins show:

• Crystal structure in the metal consistent with ancient smelting techniques
• Natural wear patterns with microscopic metal flow
• Corrosion products that penetrate the surface rather than sitting on top
• Tool marks from historical manufacturing processes

Professional Authentication Services

For high-value specimens or when in doubt, professional authentication is recommended. Reputable services include:

• Professional coin grading companies with ancient coin expertise
• University archaeology departments with metallurgy labs
• Specialized Asian coin authentication experts
• Museum curators familiar with Chinese and Japanese coinage

Value Guide and Market Considerations

Qianlong Period Coins

Well-preserved specimens from the Qianlong period typically range from $20 to $200 depending on condition. Rare mint marks or exceptional preservation can command higher prices. Counterfeit examples of these common coins are widespread, making authentication particularly important.

Daoguang Period Coins

Daoguang coins are generally less valuable due to their later production date and more common availability. Expect prices of $10 to $100 for good specimens. The economic pressures of this period actually make authentic coins easier to identify due to their characteristic manufacturing irregularities.

Japanese Kanei Coins

Japanese cash coins have a dedicated collector base and can range from $15 to $150 depending on variety and condition. The Kanei period produced numerous varieties, some quite rare and valuable. Authentication is crucial as Japanese coins are also commonly counterfeited.

Conclusion: The Importance of Due Diligence

Collecting ancient Chinese and Japanese cash coins can be a rewarding hobby, but it requires careful attention to authentication. The three coins discussed here represent different challenges: the common but often counterfeited Qianlong coin, the easily confused Japanese Kanei piece, and the economically-stressed Daoguang example with its characteristic manufacturing variations.

By understanding the specific diagnostic points for each type of coin, using multiple testing methods, and being aware of common counterfeit techniques, collectors can build authentic collections with confidence. Remember that no single test is definitive, and the most reliable authentication comes from combining multiple methods and consulting with experts when necessary.

The market for these historical artifacts continues to grow, making proper authentication more important than ever. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting your journey into Asian numismatics, the skills you develop in authentication will serve you well throughout your collecting career.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Spotting Counterfeit 1896-S Barber Quarters: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Authenticity – Introduction You don’t always need a dealer to find this. Here is what to look for when searching through circulat…
• Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Rare Barber Quarters Without Getting Ripped Off – Introduction Building a collection of Barber Quarters? The 1896-S is a true prize – a rare variety that can comman…
• Is Your Chinese Cash Coin Real? Expert Authentication Guide – The Authentication Crisis in Chinese Cash Coin Collecting With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific di…