Preserving Your 1917 Buffalo Nickel: Expert Conservation Strategies for Unique Varieties

I’ve Held History in My Hands – Don’t Let These Mistakes Destroy Your Buffalo Nickel

That intriguing 1917 Philadelphia Buffalo nickel you’re holding – with its distinctive front leg details whispering stories of die polishing or striking anomalies – deserves better than becoming another cautionary tale. As someone who’s handled thousands of coins, I can tell you nothing breaks a numismatist’s heart faster than seeing a rare variety ruined by well-meaning but misguided care. Your coin’s unique characteristics, whether abrasions, struck-through errors, or other quirks, aren’t just features – they’re irreplaceable chapters in its numismatic story.

Why Your 1917 Buffalo Nickel is More Fragile Than You Think

Let’s talk brass tacks: that 75% copper composition makes your Buffalo nickel a ticking time bomb against environmental threats. The copper-nickel alloy reacts unpredictably, especially when we examine specimens like yours with unusual topography. Those micro-crevices around the front leg detail? They’re contamination magnets. I’ve seen coins with similar characteristics develop verdigris blooms in mere months when stored improperly. This isn’t just about maintaining eye appeal – it’s about preserving numismatic value for future generations.

When Unique Features Become Conservation Nightmares

Your coin’s distinctive features demand specialized care. Consider these hidden risks:

• Surface irregularities trap moisture like microscopic swamps
• Differential oxidation creates patchy, destructive toning
• Micro-abrasions accelerate environmental damage exponentially
• Standard holders can actually worsen preservation for non-standard topography

The Great Patina Debate: Beauty vs. Beast

Here’s where collectors often stumble. That rainbow toning developing on your Buffalo nickel? It could be a prized natural patina – or the first death rattle of destructive oxidation. I’ve auctioned coins where delicate lavender hues added 300% to the hammer price, but I’ve also consigned pieces where black sulfurous corrosion ate through the date in under a decade. Your 1917 specimen’s value hinges on recognizing which toning enhances collectibility and which destroys it.

Toning Red Flags Every Collector Must Memorize

Watch for these telltale signs of trouble:

• Verdigris (the “green death”) clustering in protected areas
• Black sulfur compounds etching into the bison’s flank
• Chalky oxidation that flakes off like dandruff
• Concentric toning rings indicating harmful air exposure

PVC: The Silent Assassin in Your Collection

Let me show you something tragic – a 1916-D Buffalo nickel I recently conserved. Its owner stored it in a “protective” PVC flip for just three years. The result? Acidic ooze pooled in the date crevices, permanently etching the surface. PVC damage isn’t just ugly; it’s a death sentence for numismatic value. For coins like your 1917 with complex topography, the plasticizer migration becomes catastrophic, pooling in every depression and anomaly.

PVC Warfare: Identification and Rescue Tactics

If you suspect PVC contamination:

• Look for oily rainbows or sticky green residue
• Test holder flexibility – rigid usually means safer
• Never rub affected coins – you’ll grind acids into the surface
• Professional conservation within 48 hours offers the best hope

Armor for Your Artifact: Storage Solutions That Work

Storing your Buffalo nickel isn’t about containment – it’s about creating a microclimate. After documenting my own collection through decades of preservation, here’s what truly works:

• Material: Archival polyester (Mylar) or crystal-clear inert plastics
• Seal Type: Heat-sealed, never adhesive-lined
• Thickness: 3 mil is the sweet spot for protection without bulk
• Fit: Snug enough to prevent movement, loose enough to avoid pressure marks

Special Housing for Special Coins

Your unusual 1917 specimen demands custom care:

• Oversized holders prevent contact with raised anomalies
• Anti-static materials keep dust from nesting in crevices
• Consider museum-grade encapsulation for rare varieties
• Avoid anything containing wood pulp or acidic papers

The Unforgivable Sin: Why Cleaning Spells Disaster

I’ll be blunt – cleaning collectible coins is numismatic heresy. That peculiar leg detail on your 1917 Buffalo? Cleaning could turn it from a fascinating anomaly into a meaningless abrasion. I’ve held coins where owners used everything from baking soda to jewelers’ rouge, erasing thousands in value and all historical credibility. Remember: toning can be conserved, but cleaning scratches are forever.

How “Helping” Destroys History

• Hairlines from wiping obliterate original luster
• Chemical dips leach out mint-caused toning layers
• Polishing rounds sharp strikes into mushy details
• Removing patina destroys provenance evidence

‘I wish Ron could have seen it and spoke of it’ – this lament from our forums echoes through numismatic history. Once original surfaces are gone, so is the coin’s authentic voice.

Your Conservation Manifesto: Preserving Legacy

Protecting your Buffalo nickel requires military precision:

1. Document: Shoot macro photos under natural light before storage
2. Environment: 68°F and 45% RH is the preservation sweet spot
3. Handling: Cotton gloves only, and never breathe directly on surfaces
4. Location: Far from exterior walls, windows, and chemical fumes
5. Vigilance: Inspect quarterly with a 5x loupe for early warnings

Final Thought: More Than Metal

Your 1917 Buffalo nickel isn’t just a coin – it’s a time capsule from the dawn of modern minting techniques. Whether it displays striking anomalies, die deterioration, or honest circulation marks, these features tell America’s story in three grams of alloy. By preserving it properly, you’re not just maintaining numismatic value; you’re safeguarding history. And remember – the most valuable coins aren’t always the shiniest, but those that reach future collectors exactly as the mint (and time) intended them.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 1917 Buffalo Nickel Authentication Guide: Spotting Counterfeits in the Wild – With Counterfeits Circulating, Your 1917 Buffalo Nickel Needs This Forensic Eye Friends, if your coin cabinet holds a 19…
• 1917 Buffalo Nickel Errors: A Hunter’s Guide to Die Cracks, Varieties & Hidden Value – Most folks walk past tiny details that can transform pocket change into rare treasures worth thousands. As an error coin…
• The 1917 Buffalo Nickel: Witness to America’s Industrial Ascent and Artistic Ideals – Hold history in your palm. The 1917 Buffalo nickel sparking collector debates isn’t just pocket change – it&…