Shipwreck and Hoard Treasure: S.S. Central America, Redfield, Saddle Ridge, and Sea-Salvage Grades

Some Coins Really Do Spend Centuries Underwater

Some coins have spent centuries sealed inside a shipwreck or hidden in masonry, soil, or a forgotten corner of an old home. The stories are irresistible: a steamship sunk in 1857, thousands of California gold coins buried in New York, and more than 1,400 gold pieces uncovered inside a wall in Texas.

When I appraise shipwreck and hoard treasure, I do not start with the headline value. I start with three harder questions. What is the coin? What condition is it in? And what evidence supports its claimed origin?

Those questions guide every coin associated with the S.S. Central America, the Redfield Hoard, and the Saddle Ridge Hoard. A shipwreck coin may have corrosion, deposits, scratches, or a history of conservation. A celebrated hoard may contain mostly common dates despite dramatic early reports. Provenance can add historical interest and numismatic value, but it cannot strengthen a weak strike, restore luster, or turn a circulated coin into one in mint condition.

I also want to acknowledge a numismatic community tribute to Stefanie Haydu, better known online as @coinsarefun. Friends remembered her love of toned coins, tokens, hard-times pieces, Ron Landis material, and the research behind unusual exonumia. The forum did not provide enough identification to connect the objects pictured in that thread to the three caches discussed here, so

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Emergency Coins in Wartime: Metal Substitutes, Survival, and Stefanie Haydu’s Exonumia Legacy – When global conflict strained supply and demanded metal, mints had to adapt fast. Gold, silver, copper, nickel, and zinc…
• eBay vs. Coin Shows for Selling an 1881-CC Morgan: Fees, Dealer Offers, and Authenticity – When I decide where to sell an 1881-CC Morgan dollar, I look well beyond the headline offer. The venue can change my net…
• Why Wealth Managers Are Adding In memory of coinsarefun Stefanie Haydu to Client Portfolios: A Tribute to Exonumia, Toned Coins, and Tangible Wealth Strategy – When clients ask why wealth managers are adding coins to client portfolios, I start with a simple principle: diversifica…