Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Morgan Dollars Without Getting Ripped Off

Introduction: The Strategic Collector’s Approach

Building a Morgan Dollar collection requires more than just enthusiasm—it demands strategy. These iconic American coins, minted from 1878 to 1921, offer both numismatic value and a tangible connection to American history. With millions produced across various mints and years, the market presents both opportunities and pitfalls for collectors at every level.

Understanding the Morgan Dollar Market

Morgan Dollars were struck at five different mints: Philadelphia (no mint mark), New Orleans (O), San Francisco (S), Carson City (CC), and Denver (D – only in 1921). The Carson City issues are particularly sought after, with the 1889-CC being one of the most exciting acquisitions mentioned in collector discussions. These coins contain 90% silver and 10% copper, weighing 26.73 grams with a diameter of 38.1mm.

Where to Buy Morgan Dollars

The forum discussions reveal several purchasing channels that collectors successfully use:

• Local Dealers: Several collectors mention purchasing from dealers who had multiple years available in the same grade. This allows for direct comparison and selection of the best-looking specimen with optimal luster and strike.
• Online Auctions: GreatCollections is specifically mentioned as a platform where collectors have successfully acquired valuable specimens, including rare white label PCGS slabs with exceptional eye appeal.
• Direct Trades: One collector mentioned an exciting trade that resulted in acquiring an 1889-CC, demonstrating that networking within the collecting community can yield excellent results and uncover rare varieties.
• Raw vs. Slabbed: The discussion shows collectors purchasing both raw coins for albums and graded specimens for their collections, indicating both markets remain active and viable for different collecting strategies.

Red Flags to Watch For

Based on the forum content and general market knowledge, here are critical warning signs:

• Overpriced Common Dates: While not explicitly mentioned in the discussion, collectors should be wary of dealers asking premium prices for common dates like the 1881-S in average circulated conditions.
• Questionable Toning: One collector explicitly states they won’t “battle it out with the toning aficionados,” suggesting that artificially toned coins can be problematic and may not represent true value or authenticity.
• Slab Verification: The detailed discussion about PCGS white label rattler slabs with low certification numbers (1080017, 1102279) highlights the importance of verifying slab authenticity and understanding generation differences to avoid counterfeits.
• Image Quality: A collector apologizes for poor images, which serves as a reminder that inadequate photography can hide flaws or misrepresent a coin’s condition, potentially masking surface issues or strike quality.

Negotiating Tips for Morgan Dollar Purchases

The forum doesn’t explicitly discuss negotiation, but several strategies can be inferred:

1. Multiple Selection Advantage: When a dealer offers “six different years to choose from and all the same grade,” you have leverage to select the best-looking coin and potentially negotiate a better price based on comparative quality.
2. Grade Range Strategy: One collector mentions hanging out in the MS63-64 range, suggesting that targeting specific grade ranges where you can be more competitive may yield better deals than chasing top-tier specimens in perfect mint condition.
3. Understanding Market Values: The mention of an 1881-S PCGS MS63 selling for $119,062 (though this appears to be an error in the original post) underscores the importance of knowing current market values to avoid overpaying for common dates.
4. Building Relationships: Regular purchases from the same dealer, as implied by multiple posts about new acquisitions, can lead to better deals over time through established trust and repeat business.

Raw vs. Slabbed: Making the Right Choice

The forum discussion reveals collectors pursuing both raw and slabbed Morgans for different purposes:

Raw Morgans: Several collectors mention purchasing raw coins “for my album,” indicating that unslabbed coins are ideal for date-and-mint mark sets where the focus is on completing a collection rather than investment-grade specimens. Raw coins typically cost less per piece, allowing collectors to acquire more coins for their budget and expand their collection.

Slabbed Morgans: The detailed discussion about PCGS white label rattlers with low certification numbers shows that some collectors specifically target graded coins, particularly those with historical significance like early slab generations. The 1900-O and 1921 examples mentioned as “the only graded Morgans in my collection” suggest that slabbed coins are often reserved for special or high-grade specimens with exceptional strike or luster.

Decision Factors: Consider slabbing raw coins if you believe they might grade higher than their purchase price justifies, or if you’re acquiring potentially valuable varieties. Leave common dates raw if you’re building a collection for personal enjoyment rather than investment purposes, focusing on completing your set rather than maximizing numismatic value.

Understanding Slab Generations and Their Value

The forum contains valuable information about PCGS slab generations that collectors should understand:

According to the PCGS slab generation reference, Generation 1.0 white label rattlers were used in early February 1986 with serial numbers beginning around 1080001. Generation 1.1 improved the dot-matrix printing and was used for about one week with serial numbers up to around 1082378.

This information is crucial because early slab generations often command premiums from collectors who appreciate the historical significance of these holders. A low serial number like 1102279 (mentioned in the discussion) falls just outside the earliest generation but still represents an early specimen with historical provenance.

Conclusion: Building Your Morgan Dollar Collection Strategically

The Morgan Dollar remains one of the most collected American coins for good reason. Their historical significance, silver content, and variety make them appealing to collectors at all levels. By understanding where to buy, recognizing red flags, mastering negotiation strategies, and making informed decisions about raw versus slabbed coins, you can build a meaningful collection without overpaying.

Whether you’re targeting the elusive Carson City issues, hunting for early slab generations, or simply building a date set in the MS63-64 range, the key is approaching each purchase with knowledge and patience. The collectors in this forum discussion demonstrate that successful collecting involves a mix of research, relationship-building, and strategic purchasing decisions. Your Morgan Dollar collection can be both personally rewarding and potentially valuable if you apply these principles consistently, focusing on quality, authenticity, and your personal collecting goals.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving Your Morgan Dollars: Expert Conservation Tips for Future Generations – The Silent Threat to Your Collection I’ve seen too many valuable pieces ruined by improper cleaning or storage. He…
• Grading Morgan Dollars: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – Why Morgan Dollar Grading Matters Condition is everything when it comes to Morgan Dollars. A single grade difference can…
• Is Your Morgan Dollar Real? How to Spot a Fake – Introduction With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for this item is critical. Mo…