The Artisan’s Dilemma: Crafting Jewelry From a Flawed Susan B. Anthony PR70 DCAM

Not Every Coin Is Meant For The Anvil

After twenty years of breathing new life into coins as wearable art, I’ve developed an instinct for which pieces sing under the jeweler’s torch – and which deserve preservation in mint condition. The heated forum debate over a Susan B. Anthony PR70 DCAM dollar stopped me mid-scroll. Here’s why this controversial specimen represents not a collector’s disappointment, but an artisan’s golden opportunity. Let’s explore through four critical dimensions: metallic truth, structural integrity, design potential, and that elusive quality we call eye appeal.

Metal Composition: The Copper-Nickel Reality

First, let’s address the elephant in the vault: this 1979-S SBA dollar contains absolutely zero silver content. For jewelry conversion, that copper-nickel clad construction tells a complex story:

• Outer layers: 75% copper, 25% nickel
• Inner core: 100% copper
• Total weight: 8.1 grams

Unlike silver coins that develop a graceful patina over time, copper-nickel tends to lose its luster when worked. Yet that copper core creates striking edge effects when carved – a visual drama I’ve learned to harness through expert finishing techniques that combat oxidation. The metal’s very “flaws” become features when viewed through an artisan’s lens.

Metal Hardness: The Crafting Sweet Spot

With a Vickers hardness rating of 140-150, this SBA dollar hits the Goldilocks zone for jewelry conversion:

• Yields beautifully under controlled pressure
• Maintains structural integrity better than pure silver
• Less stubborn than modern nickel coins
• Develops character with wear

The vertical blemish near Anthony’s cheekbone? To a collector, it’s a grading tragedy. To me, it’s a roadmap – showing exactly where to apply careful reinforcement during doming to prevent stress fractures. This “flaw” literally guides my hammer strokes.

Design Details: A Numismatic Blueprint

That PR70 DCAM designation isn’t just bragging rights – it’s a treasure map for artisans. Under magnification, we find:

• Deep Cameo Contrast: Frosted devices floating above mirror fields
• Crisp Collar Details: 13 stars radiating like tiny suns
• Portrait Depth: Anthony’s features struck with museum-quality precision

These numismatic virtues translate spectacularly to jewelry. The strong portrait becomes a natural focal point for signet rings, while the reverse eagle soars as pendant centerpiece. Even the forum-noted discoloration between eye and ear presents an opportunity – I’d position this “flaw” to catch light unexpectedly, transforming perceived weakness into visual intrigue.

“Grading inconsistencies break a collector’s heart but make an artisan’s hands itch. That ‘imperfect perfect’ coin you’re side-eyeing? It’s singing its swan song to jewelers.”

Aesthetic Alchemy: Flaws Into Features

What collectors dismiss as defects, we reinterpret as design elements:

• Discoloration: Becomes dramatic topography in acid-etched landscapes
• Contact Marks: Add provenance and vintage charm
• Field Imperfections: Create captivating light play when polished

That controversial vertical mark near the cheekbone? I’d deliberately position it at a ring’s stress point (6 o’clock position) where natural wear creates organic aging. What graders call a deficiency, wearers will call character.

Crafting Economics: When Numismatic Value Fades

This case exemplifies why “slab-worthy” and “bench-worthy” often diverge:

• Grading controversies evaporate numismatic value
• PR70 pedigree still commands premium materials pricing
• Jewelry conversion multiplies worth 3-5x
• Rare variety becomes wearable history

Once a coin’s collectibility declines due to visible imperfections, its transformation into functional art becomes economically compelling. That’s when we jewelers pounce.

The Artisan’s Verdict

This Susan B. Anthony PR70 DCAM represents prime conversion material precisely because of its collecting shortcomings:

• Ideal metal composition for enduring wear
• Design elements that dance in ambient light
• “Flaws” that telegraph authentic history
• Liberated from slab prison to live on human hands

True craftsmanship isn’t about obeying grading sheets – it’s about seeing what metal yearns to become. This controversial coin, with its copper-nickel heart and debated pedigree, doesn’t belong in a dark safe. It deserves a second life where its “imperfections” become conversation starters, its weight comforts a finger, and its story continues evolving. The collector’s loss is quite literally the jeweler’s gain.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving Perfection: Expert Conservation Strategies for Susan B. Anthony PR70 DCAM Coins – The Delicate Art of Protecting Numismatic Perfection After twenty years conserving coins, my heart still breaks seeing i…
• Grading SBA PR70 DCAM Coins: The Microscopic Margin Between Perfection and Reality – For collectors, few moments rival the thrill of holding a pristine Susan B. Anthony Proof – especially one that might ac…
• Susan B. Anthony PR70 DCAM: The Authentication Guide Every Collector Needs – Counterfeits Are Everywhere – Here’s How to Protect Your Susan B. Anthony Treasure As someone who’s he…