The Capital Gains and Tax Guide for Selling 1922-D Lincoln Cent Variations: What Every Collector Needs to Know Before Cashing In

Selling high-value collectibles comes with specific tax rules that most hobbyists ignore until it’s too late. Here’s a breakdown of the financial implications. As a CPA who has spent over a decade specializing in collectibles taxation, I can tell you firsthand that the difference between proper planning and winging it can amount to thousands of dollars — especially when we’re talking about sought-after pieces like the 1922-D Lincoln cent and its many die varieties.

The 1922-D Lincoln cent is one of the most fascinating and widely collected issues in all of American numismatics. With its seven recognized die pairings — from Die Pair #1 Weak D to Die Pair #4 No D — and countless die states featuring reverse die cracks at the 9, 11, and 2 o’clock positions, this issue commands serious money in today’s market. A PCGS MS66RB CAC example, of which only seven exist at that grade across PCGS and NGC combined, can fetch five or even six figures. But when it comes time to sell, the IRS takes its cut, and the rules for collectibles are not the same as they are for your stock portfolio.

In this guide, I’m going to walk you through everything you need to know about the tax implications of selling 1922-D Lincoln cents and other high-value collectibles. Whether you’re a casual collector who just inherited a roll of 1922-D cents or a serious VAM hunter with a PCGS MS65+RD CAC in your vault, this information will save you money and keep you on the right side of the tax code.

Understanding Capital Gains Tax on Collectibles

The first thing every collector needs to understand is that the IRS treats collectibles differently from other capital assets. When you sell stocks, bonds, or real estate, you benefit from long-term capital gains rates that currently top out at 20% for high-income taxpayers. Collectibles, however, are subject to a maximum capital gains rate of 28% — nearly a third higher than the standard long-term rate.

This 28% rate applies to “collectibles” as defined by the Internal Revenue Code, which explicitly includes:

• Any work of art
• Any rug or antique
• Any metal or gem (with certain exceptions for bullion)
• Any stamp or coin
• Any alcoholic beverage
• Certain other tangible personal property

Yes, your 1922-D Lincoln cents — whether they’re raw weak reverse examples or certified PCGS MS63RB pieces — fall squarely into the “coin” category and are taxed at the collectibles rate. This is true regardless of whether you’re a casual collector or a full-time dealer.

Here’s how it works in practice. Let’s say you purchased a 1922-D Die Pair #1 No D in PCGS MS64RB five years ago for $8,000, and you sell it today for $15,000. Your capital gain is $7,000. If you’re in the 37% ordinary income tax bracket, you’ll pay 28% on that gain — which comes to $1,960 in federal capital gains tax alone. State taxes could add several hundred dollars more depending on where you live.

Key takeaway: The 28% collectibles capital gains rate is one of the highest long-term rates in the tax code. Always factor this into your selling decisions, and never assume your coin sale will be taxed at the same rate as your stock investments.

The 1099-K Reporting Rules: What Triggers a Form

One of the most common questions I get from collectors is: “Do I have to report the sale of my coins?” The short answer is yes — but the reporting mechanism has changed significantly in recent years, and many collectors are caught off guard.

Under current IRS rules, payment platforms like PayPal, eBay, and other third-party settlement organizations are required to issue Form 1099-K to sellers who meet certain thresholds. As of the 2024 tax year, the reporting threshold for 1099-K forms is $600 in aggregate payments — a dramatic reduction from the previous $20,000/200-transaction threshold.

What this means for coin collectors is straightforward: if you sell a 1922-D Lincoln cent — or any combination of coins — through an online platform and receive more than $600 in total payments during the year, you will receive a 1099-K. The IRS will receive a copy as well.

Here’s what collectors need to watch for:

1. eBay sales: If you sell coins on eBay and receive payment through eBay’s managed payments system (or PayPal), those transactions are aggregated. Sell a few 1922-D cents throughout the year totaling $600 or more, and you’ll get a 1099-K.
2. PayPal Goods & Services: Payments received through PayPal for coin sales count toward the $600 threshold. Note that “Friends & Family” payments are not reported on 1099-K, but using this method to sell coins is a violation of PayPal’s terms of service and could create other problems.
3. Coin show and in-person sales: Cash transactions at coin shows or private sales are not reported on 1099-K. However, this does not exempt you from reporting the income — you are still legally required to report all capital gains regardless of whether you receive a 1099 form.
4. Dealer-to-dealer transactions: If you’re buying and selling coins as a dealer (more on dealer status below), different reporting rules may apply, including potential 1099 reporting from other dealers.

I’ve seen too many collectors get blindsided by 1099-K forms they didn’t expect. One client of mine sold a collection of 1922-D cents — mostly lower-grade weak D and no D varieties — through various online platforms over the course of a year. The total was just over $2,000, but because it was spread across multiple platforms, he didn’t think he’d receive any 1099s. He ended up with three 1099-K forms and a very uncomfortable letter from the IRS.

Actionable tip: Keep a running total of all your online coin sales throughout the year. If you’re approaching $600 in aggregate payments from any single platform, start preparing your records and consult with a tax professional.

Cost Basis Tracking: The Most Important Record You’ll Keep

If there’s one piece of advice I give to every collector I work with, it’s this: track your cost basis from the day you acquire a coin. Cost basis is the amount you paid for an asset, and it’s the foundation of your capital gains calculation. The higher your documented cost basis, the lower your taxable gain — and the less you owe the IRS.

For coin collectors, cost basis includes:

• The purchase price of the coin
• Shipping and insurance costs
• Authentication and grading fees (PCGS, NGC, ANACS submission costs)
• Any auction house or dealer premiums paid at the time of purchase
• Sales tax paid on the purchase (in states where applicable)

Let me share a real example that illustrates why this matters so much. A few years back, a collector came to me after selling a 1922-D Die Pair #4 No D in PCGS MS65RD — a genuinely rare variety with exceptional luster and eye appeal — for $22,000. He had purchased it at a major auction roughly eight years earlier but had kept almost no documentation. No invoice. No auction catalog. Nothing. We eventually tracked down the auction house’s archived records and reconstructed a cost basis of $11,500, but it took weeks of effort and cost him several hundred dollars in research fees. Had he simply filed away his original receipt, the process would have taken five minutes.

Now imagine that same scenario with a coin whose provenance is harder to establish — say, a raw 1922-D cent you picked up at a small-town estate sale with no paperwork. Without documentation, the IRS may assign you a cost basis of zero, meaning you’d owe capital gains tax on the entire sale price. That’s a painful outcome that’s entirely avoidable.

Here’s my recommended system for tracking cost basis on your numismatic holdings:

1. Save every receipt. Auction invoices, dealer invoices, PayPal confirmations, even handwritten bills of sale from coin shows. Scan them and store them digitally.
2. Record grading submission costs separately. When you send a 1922-D cent to PCGS or NGC for certification, those grading fees are added to your cost basis. I’ve seen collectors forget this entirely, leaving legitimate deductions on the table.
3. Note the date of acquisition precisely. The holding period determines whether your gain is short-term (taxed as ordinary income) or long-term (taxed at the 28% collectibles rate). For a coin that might be worth five or six figures, that distinction is enormous.
4. Document inherited coins carefully. If you inherited your 1922-D cents rather than purchasing them, your cost basis is generally the fair market value at the date of the previous owner’s death. Get a professional appraisal at that time — it’s one of the smartest moves you can make.

My strong recommendation: Start a dedicated spreadsheet or use a coin inventory app today. Record every acquisition with its date, price, and associated costs. Future you — the one sitting across from a tax preparer — will be grateful.

Dealer vs. Collector Status: Why It Changes Everything

Not everyone who sells coins is treated the same way by the IRS, and understanding the distinction between dealer and collector status can have a significant impact on your tax bill. This is an area where I see a lot of confusion, so let me break it down clearly.

If you’re a collector — meaning you buy coins primarily for personal enjoyment and hold them with the intent of long-term appreciation — your sales are treated as capital gains transactions. You report them on Schedule D and Form 8949, and you benefit from the 28% collectibles capital gains rate on long-term holdings.

If you’re a dealer — meaning you’re regularly buying and selling coins as a trade or business — your inventory is treated as ordinary income property. You report sales on Schedule C, and your profits are taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, which could be as high as 37%. On the flip side, dealers can deduct business expenses like travel to coin shows, subscription costs for numismatic publications, and home office expenses.

The tricky part is that the line between collector and dealer isn’t always clear. The IRS looks at factors like the frequency and regularity of your transactions, your intent at the time of purchase, and whether you hold yourself out as a dealer. I’ve had clients who thought of themselves as serious collectors but whose selling patterns — dozens of transactions per year, consistent advertising, regular booth presence at shows — clearly indicated dealer activity.

For most of you reading this, your 1922-D Lincoln cent sales will fall squarely on the collector side. But if you’re actively buying and selling with regularity, it’s worth having an honest conversation with your tax professional about your status. Getting it wrong can trigger an audit and a hefty reassessment.

Timing Your Sale: Strategies to Minimize Your Tax Burden

Here’s where things get interesting — and where a little planning can save you real money. The timing of your 19222-D cent sale isn’t just about catching the right buyer at the right price. It’s also about managing your tax liability.

Hold for long-term treatment. If you’ve owned your coin for more than one year, your gain qualifies for the 28% collectibles rate. Sell before the one-year mark, and your gain is taxed as ordinary income — potentially 37% or more. I’ve watched collectors leave thousands of dollars on the table by selling a few weeks too early. If you’re close to the one-year holding period, wait it out.

Harvest losses to offset gains. This is one of the most powerful strategies available to collectors. If you have numismatic holdings that have declined in value — maybe a batch of lower-grade 1922-D cents that didn’t appreciate as you’d hoped — selling them at a loss can offset your gains from other sales. This is called tax-loss harvesting, and it works beautifully in numismatics because values can fluctuate significantly based on market demand, condition census updates, and shifts in collectibility trends.

Let’s say you sell your PCGS MS65RD 1922-D No D for a $10,000 gain, but you also have a set of weakly struck 1922-D Die Pair #2 cents that are currently worth $2,000 less than you paid for them. Selling those at a loss reduces your net capital gain to $8,000 — saving you $560 in federal tax at the 28% rate.

Consider your income year. If you expect to have a lower-income year — perhaps you’re retiring, changing jobs, or taking time off — that might be the ideal time to sell a high-value coin. The 28% collectibles rate is a maximum; if your ordinary income is low enough, you might pay 0% on long-term collectibles gains. Yes, zero. I’ve structured sales for clients in exactly this situation, and the savings have been substantial.

Beware the net investment income tax. High-income collectors may also be subject to the 3.8% net investment income tax (NIIT) on top of the capital gains rate. For a collector in the highest brackets selling a six-figure 1922-D cent, the combined federal rate can approach 32%. Factor this into your planning.

Donating Coins: A Tax-Savvy Alternative to Selling

What if you don’t want to sell your 1922-D cents at all — or at least not yet? Donating to a qualified charitable organization can be a remarkably tax-efficient strategy, especially for coins with strong numismatic value and well-documented provenance.

When you donate a coin you’ve held for more than one year to a 501(c)(3) organization, you can generally deduct the full fair market value at the time of the donation — not just what you paid for it. That means if you bought a 1922-D Die Pair #4 No D in mint condition for $5,000 and it’s now worth $18,000, you could potentially deduct the full $18,000 as a charitable contribution.

But there are important rules to follow:

• The donation must be made to a qualified charitable organization — museums, educational institutions, and certain numismatic foundations typically qualify.
• For donations of collectibles valued at more than $5,000, you’ll need a qualified written appraisal from a professional appraiser. This isn’t optional — it’s an IRS requirement.
• The charity must use the coin in a way related to its tax-exempt purpose. If the organization sells the coin immediately, your deduction may be limited to your cost basis rather than fair market value.
• Keep meticulous records: the appraisal, a written acknowledgment from the charity, and photographs documenting the coin’s condition, strike, and any notable patina characteristics.

I’ve helped several clients donate significant numismatic holdings to museums and university collections. Not only do they receive a meaningful tax deduction, but they also get the satisfaction of knowing their coins — pieces with real historical significance — will be preserved and appreciated for generations. A 1922-D Lincoln cent with a dramatic die crack or a pristine, fully red example tells a story about American minting history. There’s something deeply fitting about ensuring that story endures.

State Tax Considerations: Don’t Forget Where You Live

Everything I’ve covered so far deals with federal taxes, but your state may have its own rules — and they can vary dramatically. Some states, like Florida, Texas, and Nevada, have no state income tax at all, which means your 1922-D cent sale is only subject to federal rates. Others, like California and New York, can add 10% or more on top of your federal bill.

A few state-specific issues worth noting:

• Sales tax on purchases: In states that collect sales tax on coin purchases, that tax is added to your cost basis. But some states exempt certain bullion and numismatic purchases from sales tax — know your state’s rules.
• Residency changes: If you’re planning a move, the timing relative to a major coin sale can matter. Selling after establishing residency in a no-income-tax state could save you a significant amount.
• State-level 1099 reporting: Some states have their own reporting requirements that mirror or differ from federal rules. Don’t assume federal compliance means state compliance.

This is an area where working with a tax professional who understands both numismatics and your specific state’s tax landscape is genuinely worth the investment.

Common Mistakes I See Collectors Make

After years of working with collectors, I’ve noticed the same mistakes coming up again and again. Here are the ones that cost people the most money:

1. Not reporting cash sales. Just because you sold a 1922-D cent at a coin show for cash doesn’t mean the income disappears. All capital gains must be reported, period. The IRS has become increasingly sophisticated at tracking unreported income, and the penalties for willful non-reporting are severe.
2. Failing to account for grading costs. Every dollar you spend on PCGS or NGC submissions, shipping to grading services, and insurance during transit adds to your cost basis. Track these expenses — they add up fast, especially for an active collector.
3. Confusing personal and dealer activity. If you’re selling regularly, keep your dealer-like transactions separate from your personal collection sales. Commingling the two creates a reporting nightmare and can jeopardize your collector status.
4. Ignoring inherited coin basis. As I mentioned earlier, inherited coins generally receive a stepped-up basis to fair market value at the date of death. Failing to document this properly means you could be paying tax on gains that accrued entirely before you ever owned the coin.
5. Selling without understanding the market. This isn’t strictly a tax issue, but it has tax consequences. Selling a rare variety 1922-D cent in a weak market means a smaller gain — which sounds good until you realize you left money on the table. Conversely, selling at the peak of a market cycle maximizes your gain and your tax bill. Understanding numismatic value trends helps you time sales strategically.

Building Your Tax-Smart Selling Plan

Let me bring this all together with a practical framework. When I sit down with a collector who’s thinking about selling — whether it’s a single PCGS-certified 1922-D No D or an entire collection of die varieties — here’s the process I recommend:

1. Get a current professional appraisal. Know exactly what your coins are worth in today’s market. For high-value pieces, this means a formal appraisal from someone who understands the nuances of 1922-D die varieties, strike quality, luster, and eye appeal — not just a dealer’s casual offer.
2. Reconstruct your cost basis. Gather every receipt, invoice, and grading record you can find. If documentation is missing, start the reconstruction process now — auction archives, old credit card statements, and even emails with dealers can help establish your basis.
3. Determine your holding period. Calculate exactly how long you’ve owned each coin. If you’re within a few months of crossing the one-year threshold for long-term treatment, consider waiting.
4. Assess your overall tax picture. Look at your expected income for the year, any losses you can harvest, and your state tax situation. The goal is to sell when your combined tax burden is lowest.
5. Choose your selling channel wisely. Auction houses, private sales, and dealer buys each have different implications for reporting, fees, and ultimately your net proceeds. Factor in auction premiums and dealer spreads — these affect your net gain and your tax calculation.
6. Consult a tax professional before you sell. I cannot stress this enough. A CPA or tax attorney who understands collectibles taxation can identify strategies you’d never find on your own. The fee for that consultation is almost always a fraction of the tax savings it generates.

Final Thoughts

The 1922-D Lincoln cent is more than just a tax planning subject — it’s one of the most historically rich and collectible issues in American numismatics. Every die variety tells a story about the Denver Mint’s operations in 1922, about the pressures of high-volume production, and about the subtle variations that make this hobby so endlessly fascinating. Whether you’re holding a weakly struck Die Pair #1 or a blazing red Die Pair #4 No D with exceptional eye appeal, you’re holding a piece of history.

But history doesn’t pay the IRS. When it comes time to sell, being informed about the tax implications isn’t just smart — it’s essential. The 28% collectibles capital gains rate, the 1099-K reporting thresholds, cost basis documentation, and the dealer-versus-collector distinction are all factors that directly affect how much of your sale proceeds you actually keep.

My advice? Start your record-keeping today, even if you have no plans to sell anytime soon. The best time to prepare for a tax-smart sale is long before the sale happens. And when the moment does come — when you’re ready to part with that prized 1922-D cent — make sure you’ve got a qualified tax professional in your corner.

Because in this hobby, the thrill of the find is only half the equation. Keeping what you’ve earned is the other half.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Auction House Secrets: How to Maximize Profits Selling Slabbed Coins and Display-Worthy Numismatic Items at Auction – There is a massive difference between selling on eBay and consigning to a major auction house. Let’s look at how t…
• Inherited a Collection of Slabbed Coins? An Estate Liquidator’s Guide to Valuation, Taxes, and Selling Without Leaving Money on the Table – So you’ve inherited a collection of slabbed coins — maybe it was a parent’s lifelong passion, or an uncle&#8…
• The Crack-Out Game: Should You Resubmit Your Modern Commemorative Coins for a Higher Grade? – Sometimes the plastic holder is holding the coin back. Let’s talk about the risks and rewards of trying to upgrade…