Silver Stacks: Understanding Peace Dollar Melt Value vs. Collector Worth
February 15, 2026The Hidden History Behind the 1917 George Washington Medal
February 15, 2026
Introduction: Beyond the Price Guide
To uncover this medal’s true worth, we must look beyond catalog values and feel the pulse of today’s collector market. When evaluating historic commemoratives like this George Washington piece, several factors command attention: metal content, condition, rarity, provenance, and–critically–what passionate collectors are actually bidding at auction. What makes this 1917 medal fascinating? Its story demonstrates how collector enthusiasm and historical connections can transform perceived value overnight.
Historical Context and Identification
Our featured medal presents Washington in left-facing profile–a classic uniface design. While resembling Dieges & Clust productions from 1915, subtle differences in surface texture caught our forum members’ attention. That engraved “Harry Eisman” signature? That’s where things get thrilling! Such personalization can make or break collectibility depending on its historical significance.
The distinctive surface texture suggests casting rather than striking–a crucial distinction. Struck medals from established mints typically carry premium numismatic value due to superior detail. Yet this 1917 artifact hails from America’s patriotic commemorative boom, when fraternal societies and civic groups produced medals like this as membership tokens.
Current Market Analysis
Recent auction hammer prices reveal consistent demand for early 20th-century Washington medals:
- Common examples with average eye appeal: $25-75
- Superior strikes from known mints: $100-300
- Rare varieties or pieces with documented provenance: $500-1,500+
While this market segment shows stable growth, that “Harry Eisman” engraving is the wildcard. If research links this name to historical events or organizations, we could see explosive collector interest. Without provenance? It risks being viewed as damage despite its charming patina.
Factors Affecting Value
Four pillars determine this medal’s market standing:
Metal Composition
Initial hopes of silver content face doubt–the luster suggests base metal. Silver specimens command 3-5x premiums, so we recommend a simple magnet test or professional assay. That metallic character dramatically impacts intrinsic and numismatic value.
Condition Assessment
Surface quality appears reasonably preserved though photos obscure details. For medals like this, condition grades spanning Poor (P-1) to Mint State (MS-65) create massive value gaps–each grade upgrade can boost worth 20-50%. Don’t fret about the blank reverse; uniface designs were period-typical!
Provenance and Historical Connection
“Harry Eisman” transforms this from commodity to mystery. Could he be linked to fraternal orders like the Odd Fellows? If so, we’re looking at dedicated collector niches that pay premiums for authenticated connections. Provenance turns medals into historical documents.
Market Demand and Collector Interest
Washington imagery guarantees baseline interest, but cast pieces face headwinds against struck counterparts. Today’s collectors crave pieces whispering stories–making that inscription our make-or-break element. Eye appeal matters immensely!
Investment Potential
Considering this medal for your collection? Weigh these factors:
Upside Potential: Confirmed historical ties could triple value. Recent auctions show fraternal pieces with documented provenance outperforming the market.
Risk Factors: Cast construction and potential “defacement” concerns may limit buyer pool. Without provenance, it becomes another anonymous medal.
Market Trends: Early 1900s Americana enjoys steady 3-5% annual appreciation. Washington’s iconic status provides solid demand floor.
Authentication and Professional Assessment
Given the unknowns, expert evaluation is wise. A certified numismatist can:
- Verify metal content non-destructively
- Determine manufacturing method (that cast vs. strike question!)
- Provide official condition grading
- Help trace the Eisman connection
At $50-150, authentication costs less than potential value discovery–and gives buyers confidence in your offering.
Comparable Sales and Market Data
Recent auction highlights:
- Dieges & Clust Washington medals (1915): $150-400 (condition-dependent)
- Early 1900s Washington medals: $75-250
- Fraternal society pieces: $100-500+
The pattern? Provenance and preservation dominate. Medals with stories and mint condition consistently outperform.
Conclusion: A Historical Puzzle Worth Solving
This 1917 Washington medal presents that thrilling collector’s dilemma: surface questions versus hidden potential. While cast manufacturing raises eyebrows, “Harry Eisman” whispers of undiscovered history.
Current valuation sits at $75-200 without provenance. But unlock that signature’s secret? Suddenly we’re eyeing $300-600 territory. That gap represents the exhilarating risk/reward dance of numismatics!
Ultimately, medals like this remind us that true value lives at the intersection of preservation, history, and passionate collectors. Before considering acquisition, invest in professional authentication. The modest fee might unveil a museum-worthy story–and that’s where real numismatic magic happens.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Peace Dollars with Luster – Old Girlfriends Without Getting Ripped Off – Introduction: The Enduring Charm of Peace Dollars Ready to welcome one of these American classics into your collection? …
- Preserving Peace Dollars with Luster: A Conservationist’s Guide to Long-Term Protection – Introduction: The Silent Killers of Coin Value Throughout my years in numismatics, I’ve witnessed too many valuabl…
- Barber Dime Silver Content & Value: When Spots Don’t Affect Melt Value – Understanding Barber Dime Composition and Melt Value The silver content in Barber dimes often exceeds their face value, …
