The Untold Stories Behind America’s 1920s Commemorative Coins: Lafayette Dollars and Grant Stars

Unlock the Secrets of America’s Past Through Two Iconic Coins

What if your pocket change could transport you to the Roaring Twenties? The 1925 Lafayette Dollar and 1922 Grant with Star commemoratives aren’t just silver relics—they’re time capsules from an era of profound national transformation. Let’s explore why these coins still make collectors’ hearts race a century later.

History Comes Alive in Silver

Commemorative Fever in the Jazz Age

As America emerged from World War I’s shadow, our nation turned to history for comfort. Between 1918-1939, Congress authorized 32 commemorative coins—more than any period before or since. These weren’t mere currency; they became bronze and silver monuments that everyday citizens could hold in their hands. The Lafayette and Grant issues epitomize this golden age of commemoratives, blending artistry with storytelling in ways that still define numismatic value today.

“These coins let ordinary Americans carry history in their purses,” observes legendary numismatist Q. David Bowers. “The premium pricing wasn’t just about profit—it bought you a piece of national memory.”

The Lafayette Dollar (1925): A Revolutionary Design

Struck to fund Lafayette’s Paris monument, this coin broke tradition like the man it honored. Look closely at its 90% silver surfaces and you’ll discover:

• Obverse: Washington and Lafayette cheek-to-cheek—the first time a foreign citizen graced U.S. coinage
• Reverse: A stunning equestrian statue that transports you to Paris’ Place du Carrousel

With only 36,956 minted, finding one with original luster feels like uncovering buried treasure. I’ve handled three in my career, and that distinctive cheekbone definition on Lafayette’s portrait? That’s your authenticity guarantee.

The Grant with Star (1922): A Tiny But Telling Detail

This half-dollar’s secret lies in its star—literally. The elusive five-pointed addition beneath “E PLURIBUS UNUM” marks a special tribute to Illinois’ statehood during Grant’s centennial. Key collecting insights:

• Rarity Reality: Just 10,016 star varieties struck (compare to 4,256 without)
• Diagnostic Tip: Check for die doubling on “DEPARTMENT”—a telltale sign of early strikes

Spotting an authentic Star Grant requires Sherlock-level scrutiny. I’ve seen too many added stars on otherwise genuine coins—always verify under 10x magnification!

Spotting the Real Deal

Lafayette Dollar Telltales

When authenticating these giants of commemorative coinage, I always check three things:

• Weight Precision: 26.73g—any deviation spells trouble
• Edge Poetry: 143 reeds that sing when you run your thumb across them
• Patina: Original toning that resembles twilight on the Seine

Grant Star Authentication Tricks

Don’t get fooled by counterfeit stars! True specimens reveal:

• Star Placement: Precisely at 5 o’clock relative to Grant’s epaulet
• Eye Appeal: A cartwheel effect on well-preserved fields
• Provenance: Paper trails tracing to original subscription sales

The Political Drama Behind the Designs

These coins emerged during America’s monumental obsession—a time when:

• Civil War veterans’ groups wielded real political power
• The Daughters of the American Revolution shaped historical narratives
• Memorials became battlegrounds for national identity

The Lafayette Dollar’s Franco-American symbolism soothed postwar tensions, while Grant’s star quietly acknowledged Illinois’ role in Reconstruction politics. Holding these coins today means grasping the very tools of 1920s cultural diplomacy.

Why Collectors Chase These Icons

The Allure of Scarcity

Let’s talk numbers—the language of collectibility:

These aren’t just coins—they’re rare variety trophies that make advanced collectors weak in the knees.

Market Insights from the Bourse Floor

After three decades handling early commemoratives, I’ve observed:

• Lafayette Dollars with original envelopes command 20% premiums
• Grant Stars showing minimal bag marks consistently outperform market averages
• Both issues benefit from “generational wealth transfer” as Baby Boomer collections hit the market

The Collector’s Holy Grail

Imagine holding a coin that survived 100 years without a single fingerprint marring its fields—that’s the dream driving our passion. Recent PCGS submissions reveal only 57 Lafayette Dollars and 83 Grant Stars in mint condition MS-65 or better across all grading services. When one surfaces, the collecting community takes notice.

Enduring Legacy in Silver

These coins whisper stories across generations—from Depression-era children spending “special money” at the five-and-dime, to modern collectors scrutinizing every hairline under LED lights. Their value lies not just in silver content or rarity, but in how they bridge past and present.

As we preserve these metallic time capsules, we become stewards of America’s complex history. Whether displayed in velvet-lined cases or secured in climate-controlled vaults, the Lafayette Dollar and Grant Star remain the crown jewels of U.S. commemoratives—each surviving specimen a miracle of numismatic survival.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving Your 1890-CC Half Eagle: Expert Conservation Tips – The Allure of the 1890-CC Half Eagle Struck at the legendary Carson City Mint, the 1890-CC Half Eagle isn’t just g…
• Is Your 1890-CC Half Eagle With a Shiner Real? How to Spot a Fake – Introduction In the heart-pounding world of coin collecting, few challenges rival the thrill of authenticating an 1890-C…
• The 1960-D Small Date Cent: Silver Potential vs. Collector Value for Bullion Investors – When Hidden Treasures Outshine Face Value Picture this: a humble Lincoln cent that could secretly be worth fifty thousan…