The Weird Denominations: Why the Seated Liberty Dollar Survived While the 2-Cent Piece, 3-Cent Silver, and Half Dime Vanished

Introduction: The Failed Experiments of American Coinage

The history of money is filled with failed experiments and odd denominations. As a monetary historian who has spent decades examining, grading, and authenticating the physical remnants of American economic evolution, I find that the coins that didn’t survive often tell us more about our monetary system than the ones that did.

When collectors post their Seated Liberty Dollars—those magnificent silver workhorses designed by Christian Gobrecht and struck from 1840 through 1873—they are showcasing the culmination of a long denominational struggle. The Seated Liberty Dollar wasn’t just a coin; it was the survivor. It outlasted the half dime, outlasted the 2-cent piece, and rendered the 3-cent silver obsolete. Understanding why those denominations failed while the dollar coin persisted until the Coinage Act of 1873 (and eventually evolved into the Morgan Dollar) is essential context for any serious collector.

In my experience grading everything from worn contemporary counterfeits to pristine proof Seated Liberty Dollars, I’ve always maintained that the story of a coin is inseparable from the story of the economy that demanded it. Today, let’s explore the fractional and odd-denomination experiments that paved the way for the coins we collect today.

The Half Dime: The Tiny Silver Predecessor

Origins and Early Years

Before we can understand the Seated Liberty Dollar, we must understand the coin that preceded it in the smaller denominations: the half dime. The half dime (five-cent silver piece) was one of the original denominations authorized by the Mint Act of 1792. The early half dimes, struck from 1794 to 1805, were tiny—measuring just 16.5 millimeters in diameter and containing a mere 2.08 grams of silver. These were the half dismes, and they were genuinely small enough to lose in a pocket.

The Capped Bust half dime, designed by John Reich, ran from 1829 to 1837, and then the Seated Liberty half dime joined the series from 1837 through 1873. I’ve examined hundreds of these pieces over my career, and even in well-circulated grades, the detail on the seated figure of Liberty is remarkable given the diminutive planchet size.

Why the Half Dime Failed

So why did the half dime disappear? The reasons are both practical and economic:

• Size and practicality: At just 15.5 millimeters in diameter for the Seated Liberty version, the half dime was genuinely difficult to handle. Merchants complained about losing them. The public found them inconvenient.
• Silver price instability: Throughout the 1850s and 1860s, the price of silver fluctuated dramatically, particularly during and after the Civil War. Small-denomination silver coins were especially vulnerable to hoarding and melting.
• The nickel alternative: The introduction of the copper-nickel 3-cent piece in 1865 and the nickel 5-cent piece (the “nickel”) in 1866 provided a durable, practical alternative that didn’t carry the same intrinsic metal value concerns.
• Legislative action: The Coinage Act of 1873—the so-called “Crime of ’73″—demonetized silver and eliminated the half dime, the 3-cent silver, and the standard silver dollar (temporarily, as it turned out).

For collectors today, the Seated Liberty half dime series (1837–1873) represents an affordable entry point into early American silver. Key dates include the 1837-O (the first year of issue with no stars on the obverse), the 1853-O (the only New Orleans issue), and the 1870-S (a major rarity with only a handful known). I always advise new collectors that the half dime series is undervalued relative to its historical significance and numismatic value.

The 3-Cent Silver: A Civil War Emergency Coin

Born from Crisis

The 3-cent silver piece is one of the most fascinating odd denominations in American numismatics. Authorized by the Act of March 3, 1851, it was created specifically to facilitate the purchase of postage stamps. At the time, three cents was the standard rate for a half-ounce letter, and the postage stamp had only been introduced to the American public in 1847.

The coin was struck in an unusual alloy of 75% silver and 25% copper—a deliberate debasement that made the coin less attractive to melting than the standard .900 silver coinage. The design, by James B. Longacre, featured a star on the obverse with the Roman numeral III on the reverse. It was tiny—just 14 millimeters in diameter—and weighed only 0.8 grams.

The Three Phases of the 3-Cent Silver

In my experience grading these pieces, I categorize them into three distinct phases, each with its own character and collectibility:

1. Type 1 (1851–1853): The original design with no outlines around the star. These are the most desirable to type collectors and command strong premiums, particularly in mint condition. The 1851-O is the only branch mint issue of this type.
2. Type 2 (1854–1858): Modified design with three outlines added to the star and a smaller “C” in the denomination. Production dropped significantly during this period.
3. Type 3 (1859–1873): Further design modifications with two outlines on the star. Production continued to decline, with several dates seeing mintages under 1,000 pieces. The 1868 and 1873 (the latter being the final year) are particularly scarce.

Why the 3-Cent Silver Became Obsolete

The 3-cent silver’s demise was driven by multiple converging factors:

• Postage rate changes: When the domestic letter rate dropped to 2 cents in 1883 (and had already been unstable during the Civil War era), the coin lost its primary utility.
• Competition from base-metal coinage: The copper-nickel 3-cent piece, introduced in 1865, was far more durable and practical. It didn’t suffer from the same hoarding and melting pressures.
• Size: At 14 millimeters, the 3-cent silver was arguably the least practical regular-issue coin in American history. It was smaller than a dime and easily lost.
• The Coinage Act of 1873: This legislation eliminated the 3-cent silver along with other minor silver denominations.

For collectors, the 3-cent silver series is a treasure trove of rarities. The 1855 is a key date with a mintage of only 139,000, and proof issues from the 1860s and 1870s are genuinely rare. I’ve seen proof 3-cent silvers from 1868 and 1873 sell for five and even six figures at auction when they appear in PCGS or NGC holders with CAC approval—their eye appeal and luster in those top grades simply cannot be ignored.

The 2-Cent Piece: The First “In God We Trust”

A Wartime Innovation

The 2-cent piece holds a special place in American numismatic history for one very specific reason: it was the first coin to bear the motto “In God We Trust.” Authorized by the Act of April 22, 1864, during the darkest days of the Civil War, the 2-cent piece was born from the same crisis that gave us the 3-cent nickel and the paper fractional currency.

The Civil War created a severe coinage shortage. Gold and silver disappeared from circulation, hoarded or melted. The government responded by issuing paper notes in denominations as small as 3 cents—the so-called “shinplasters”—which were universally despised. The 2-cent piece was designed to replace these notes with a base-metal coin that the public would actually accept.

James B. Longacre designed the coin with a heraldic shield on the obverse and the denomination “2 CENTS” surrounded by a wheat wreath on the reverse. It was struck in a bronze alloy (95% copper, 5% tin and zinc) and measured 23 millimeters in diameter—substantial enough to be practical.

Why the 2-Cent Piece Failed

Despite its noble origins and its historic motto, the 2-cent piece was a denominational dead end. Here’s why:

• No clear economic niche: The 2-cent piece didn’t correspond to any specific postage rate or common transaction amount. It was an awkward denomination that didn’t fit neatly into the decimal system.
• Competition from the nickel: When the 5-cent nickel was introduced in 1866, it provided a more useful base-metal denomination. Two 2-cent pieces made 4 cents; one nickel made 5 cents. The math simply didn’t favor the 2-cent piece.
• Declining mintages: After the initial burst of production in 1864 (mintage: 19,847,500), mintages dropped steadily. By the 1870s, production was minimal. The final year of issue was 1873, with only 1,100 business strikes produced for collectors.
• Legislative elimination: The Mint Act of 1873 eliminated the 2-cent piece, and subsequent legislation gradually reduced and eventually ended its legal tender status.

From a collecting perspective, the 2-cent piece series is remarkably accessible for most dates but contains some extraordinary rarities. The 1873 is a major key date, and the 1864 “Small Motto” variety is one of the most sought-after varieties in all of American numismatics. I’ve examined specimens where the difference between the Small Motto and Large Motto varieties represented a five-figure swing in value. Always check your 1864 2-cent pieces carefully—the Small Motto variety has the words “GOD” and “TRUST” separated by a visible space on the ribbon, while the Large Motto shows the letters nearly touching. It’s a rare variety that rewards close inspection.

The Seated Liberty Dollar: The Survivor

Why the Dollar Coin Endured

Against this backdrop of failed denominations, the Seated Liberty Dollar stands as the ultimate survivor. Struck from 1840 to 1873, it was the largest silver denomination in regular circulation and served as the backbone of Western commerce, particularly in the gold rush territories of California where small change was scarce and silver dollars were the standard unit of trade.

The Seated Liberty Dollar’s endurance can be attributed to several factors that the smaller denominations lacked:

• Clear economic utility: The dollar was the standard unit of account. It had intrinsic value, international recognition (Spanish milled dollars had circulated in America for over a century), and practical use in large transactions.
• Western demand: The California Gold Rush created enormous demand for silver dollars in the West, where they circulated alongside gold coins as the primary medium of exchange.
• Trade dollar connection: The Seated Liberty design was adapted for the Trade Dollar (1873–1885), which was specifically designed for commerce with Asia, extending the design’s legacy.
• Collector and dealer support: Even after the Coinage Act of 1873 temporarily eliminated the silver dollar, the numismatic community recognized the Seated Liberty Dollar’s importance, ensuring strong collector demand that persists to this day.

Key Dates and Varieties for the Seated Liberty Dollar

For collectors assembling a Seated Liberty Dollar collection, I always emphasize the importance of understanding the series’ key dates and varieties. Here are the essential pieces:

• 1846-O: A key date with a low mintage and strong demand in all grades.
• 1851-O: Extremely rare in mint state; one of the toughest dates to locate with any remaining luster.
• 1852-O: Another New Orleans rarity that commands significant premiums.
• 1858: Struck only in proof (approximately 800 pieces). A major rarity and one of the most counterfeited dates in the series. I always recommend third-party authentication for any 1858 Seated Liberty Dollar.
• 1870-S: The famous “twelve known” issue. These were struck for specific presentations and are among the most valuable Seated Liberty Dollars.
• 1873-S: Despite being the final year, this San Francisco issue is surprisingly available, though always in demand.

The Carson City issues deserve special mention. A complete run of CC silver dollars—Seated Liberty, Trade, and Morgan—is a tremendous achievement. The 1873-CC Seated Liberty Dollar is a cornerstone of any Carson City collection, and examples with original surfaces, attractive patina, and CAC approval command substantial premiums.

Authentication and Grading Considerations

The Counterfeiting Problem

As a professional appraiser, I must emphasize that the Seated Liberty Dollar series is one of the most heavily counterfeited in all of American numismatics. The 1858, as I mentioned, is particularly targeted, but virtually every key date has been reproduced. Modern counterfeits from overseas have become increasingly sophisticated.

Here are my authentication guidelines for Seated Liberty Dollars:

1. Weight: A genuine Seated Liberty Dollar should weigh exactly 26.73 grams. Any deviation of more than 0.3 grams warrants further investigation.
2. Diameter: The coin should measure 38.1 millimeters. Counterfeits often deviate slightly.
3. Edge: Genuine coins have a reeded edge with consistent, sharp reeding. Cast counterfeits often show pitting or irregular reeding.
4. Surfaces: Genuine coins show natural toning patterns that develop over 150+ years. Artificial toning on counterfeits often appears “too perfect” or shows unnatural color transitions that lack the depth of a genuine patina.
5. Third-party grading: For any Seated Liberty Dollar valued at more than $1,000, I strongly recommend PCGS or NGC certification. The CAC “bean” sticker adds additional assurance of quality within the assigned grade and confirms superior eye appeal.

Understanding Variety Attribution

For Morgan and Peace Dollars, the VAM (Van Allen-Mallis) variety system is well-established. For Seated Liberty Dollars, variety collecting is less systematic but no less important. Die varieties, repunched dates, and mint mark positions can significantly affect value and collectibility. The 1870-S, for example, exists with different die characteristics that affect rarity and desirability.

I always encourage collectors to examine their Seated Liberty Dollars under strong magnification and to consult specialized reference works for the series. Understanding the strike characteristics and die states of your coins adds a deeper layer of appreciation—and can uncover hidden value in pieces you already own.

The Coinage Act of 1873: The Great Denominational Purge

What Happened and Why

The Coinage Act of 1873, signed into law by President Ulysses S. Grant on February 12, 1873, was the single most significant piece of legislation affecting American coinage since the Mint Act of 1792. It effectively reorganized the Mint, updated coin designs, and—most controversially—eliminated several denominations that had served the American public for decades.

The denominations eliminated or modified included:

• The 2-cent piece (eliminated entirely)
• The 3-cent silver piece (eliminated entirely)
• The half dime (replaced by the nickel 5-cent piece)
• The standard silver dollar (temporarily eliminated, replaced by the Trade Dollar)
• The 3-cent nickel (retained but eventually eliminated in 1889)

The motivations were complex: a desire to simplify the coinage system, pressure from mining interests (particularly silver producers who wanted the government to resume silver purchases), and a general movement toward a more “modern” and efficient monetary system. The elimination of the silver dollar, in particular, would have enormous consequences, leading directly to the Free Silver movement and the pivotal election of 1896.

The Aftermath: How Collectors Preserved These Coins

What’s remarkable is how many of these “failed” denominations were preserved by collectors even as they disappeared from circulation. The proof issues of the 2-cent piece, 3-cent silver, and half dime from the 1860s and 1870s were often saved by contemporary collectors, creating a numismatic record that would otherwise have been lost.

I’ve handled proof 2-cent pieces from 1868 and 1869 that were clearly saved at the time of issue and have remained in collector hands ever since. These coins, with their mirror fields and frosted devices, represent a direct connection to the era when these denominations were being phased out. They carry a provenance that ties us to the minting floor itself. They are, in a sense, memorials to monetary experiments that didn’t work—but whose collectibility endures precisely because of their brief, fascinating existence.

Building a Collection Around Denominational History

A Thematic Approach

For collectors interested in the denominational history I’ve outlined, I recommend building a type set that tells the story of American coinage evolution. Here’s a suggested framework:

1. Half Dime (Seated Liberty, 1837–1873): The smallest silver denomination, representing the pre-nickel era.
2. 3-Cent Silver (1851–1873): The postage-stamp coin, a Civil War-era emergency issue.
3. 2-Cent Piece (1864–1873): The first “In God We Trust” coin, another Civil War innovation.
4. Seated Liberty Dollar (1840–1873): The standard silver dollar that survived the Coinage Act of 1873 (temporarily).
5. Trade Dollar (1873–1885): The Seated Liberty design’s successor, created for Asian commerce.
6. Morgan Dollar (1878–1921): The Bland-Allison Act’s answer to the silver question, continuing the dollar coin tradition.

This six-coin type set tells the complete story of American silver coinage from the 1830s through the early 20th century, with each piece representing a different chapter in the denominational saga.

Investment Considerations

From an investment perspective, the “failed denomination” coins—particularly the 3-cent silver and 2-cent piece—offer compelling numismatic value relative to their historical significance. While the Seated Liberty Dollar commands strong premiums (especially for key dates and Carson City issues), many 3-cent silver dates can be acquired in mint condition for a fraction of the cost of comparable Seated Liberty Dollars.

The half dime series, too, remains undervalued. A complete set of Seated Liberty half dimes in VF-XF grades can be assembled for less than the cost of a single gem mint state Seated Liberty Dollar. For collectors on a budget, this represents an opportunity to own genuine 19th-century American silver with historical significance and genuine eye appeal.

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of Denominational Experimentation

The Seated Liberty Dollar, as showcased by collectors in forums and at coin shows across the country, represents the culmination of a century of American monetary experimentation. It survived while the half dime, 3-cent silver, and 2-cent piece vanished into history. It endured the Coinage Act of 1873, the rise of the nickel, and the transition from Spanish colonial currency to a distinctly American monetary system.

When you hold a Seated Liberty Dollar—whether it’s a common-date circulated example or a rare Carson City issue like the 1873-CC—you’re holding a piece of monetary history that outlasted its competitors. The half dime was too small. The 3-cent silver was too specialized. The 2-cent piece was too awkward. But the Seated Liberty Dollar was just right—at least for its era.

For collectors, the lesson is clear: understanding the denominational context of any coin enhances both the collecting experience and the investment potential. The Seated Liberty Dollar isn’t just a beautiful silver coin; it’s the last survivor of a monetary ecosystem that included some of the most curious and short-lived denominations in American history. The next time you examine one of these magnificent pieces, remember the half dimes, 3-cent silvers, and 2-cent pieces that came before—and appreciate the Seated Liberty Dollar all the more for having outlasted them all.

As I always tell my clients: in numismatics, context is value. The provenance of a coin—not just its ownership history, but its place in the broader story of American money—adds immeasurable depth to every piece in your collection. The more you know about why a coin exists—and why its competitors disappeared—the better collector and investor you’ll be. Happy collecting.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Beyond the Mint: Exonumia & Tokens of the Two Cent Piece Era — Hard Times, Civil War Merchant Tokens, and Historical Counterfeits – Sometimes the unofficial money tells the real story. As I sort through another box of 19th-century tokens at a recent sh…
• Trading the Gold-to-Silver Ratio Using Seated Liberty Dollars: A Numismatist’s Guide to Ratio Swapping with 90% Silver – Smart Stackers Don’t Just Hold; They Trade the Ratios Here’s how this coin fits into a broader precious meta…
• Whatnot Livestream Coin Errors: A Variety & Error Hunter’s Guide to Spotting Hidden Treasures in the Digital Auction Age – Most people look right past the tiny details that can turn a common coin into a rarity worth thousands. As an error coin…