
Can You Still Find Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee Meeting Recap Items at Flea Markets and Pawn Shops?
October 23, 2026Comparing the Allure of the 1868 $5 Liberty to Ancient Numismatics: A Specialist’s Perspective
October 23, 2026The Alternative Asset Manager’s Perspective: Diversifying Into Numismatics
For those looking to diversify their portfolio into hard assets, numismatics offers unique opportunities. Let’s analyze the long-term ROI potential here. As an alternative asset manager, my mandate is to identify assets that exhibit low correlation with traditional equities and fixed-income instruments, providing a shock absorber against macroeconomic volatility. Numismatics, particularly specialized varieties, fits this mandate perfectly. When I evaluate a coin like an unattributed Fivaz-Stanton (FS) variety, I am not just looking at a collectible; I am looking at a potential asymmetric upside play within a broader hard asset portfolio.
The recent discourse on the collecting forum regarding an unattributed Fivaz-Stanton variety—a coin currently housed in a PCGS holder with no prior attributions—provides a fascinating microcosm for evaluating long-term investment strategies in numismatics. The central question posed was whether to submit the coin for TPG attribution. To answer this, we must dissect the mechanics of historical price appreciation, market liquidity, inflation hedging, and the realities of alternative investments.
1. Historical Price Appreciation: The Scarcity Premium of the Unattired
The Blank Canvas Effect
In my experience grading and appraising numismatic assets, the most profound driver of long-term value is scarcity, and the most overlooked aspect of scarcity is the absence of a market. When a Fivaz-Stanton variety has never been slabbed by PCGS, NGC, or CACG, it essentially exists in a state of “pre-market.” There are no historical transaction records, no realized prices, and no established demand signals. From an investment standpoint, this is a blank canvas. While one might argue that an unattributed variety is merely speculative, the historical data shows that once a variety gains recognition, its price appreciation can be exponential. The Cherrypicker’s Guide (CPG) assigns the FS number, but until that number appears on a slab, the market does not price it. The “juice will be worth the squeeze,” as the forum participants wisely noted. An unattributed variety represents the purest form of speculative upside available in the numismatic market today.
Evaluating the “Major Variety” Fallacy
One of the critical debates in the forum was whether this variety qualifies as a “major variety.” The poster explicitly stated it is not listed in the Red Book, leading some to question its significance. However, in alternative asset management, we must look beyond mainstream catalogs. Mainstream catalogs like the Red Book often reflect mass-market demand, whereas specialized publications like the Cherrypicker’s Guide and Variety Vista cater to the deep-pocketed enthusiast. A variety that lacks mainstream recognition but possesses a highly visible “Pick Up Point”—as noted by the community members—can still command significant premiums once recognized by top-tier grading services. Historical price appreciation in numismatics often follows a step-function curve: the initial recognition by a TPG’er triggers a sudden influx of buyers, driving the price from a baseline to a premium tier.
2. Liquidity: The Double-Edged Sword of Attribution
Why Unattired Coins Struggle to Trade
Liquidity is the lifeblood of any investment. A coin that cannot be easily sold is a liability, regardless of its intrinsic value. The forum discussion highlighted a crucial market reality: dealers will not offer anything above a normal, unattributed coin if the variety information is not printed on the information insert. This is a severe liquidity constraint. Until a TPG’er recognizes and slabs the variety, the coin remains trapped in a localized collector pool. For an alternative asset manager, this illiquidity is a red flag. You cannot deploy capital efficiently if you cannot exit the position when the market conditions are right.
The Path to Liquidity: TPG Attribution and Beyond
To unlock liquidity, the coin must undergo a transformation. Submitting it for TPG attribution (True Plate Guarantee or Top Plate Guarantee, depending on the specific grading service protocol) is the catalyst. However, as the forum participants pointed out, TPG’ers may not believe the variety is significant enough to warrant the FS number on the slab label. If the grading service declines to attribute the variety, the liquidity remains locked. Therefore, the investment strategy hinges on the probability of successful attribution. Sending the coin in requires capital expenditure, but if it results in a Pop 1/0 designation, the resulting liquidity allows the owner to realize returns far exceeding the initial grading costs.
3. Inflation Hedging: Hard Assets as Portfolio Shields
The Macroeconomic Role of Numismatic Assets
From a macroeconomic perspective, traditional assets like equities and bonds often suffer from inflationary erosion. Hard assets, however, have historically retained purchasing power. Numismatics is a prime example of an asset class that acts as an inflation hedge. Precious metals and rare coins maintain their value relative to fiat currency over decades. But specialized varieties add another layer to this defense. A standard graded coin may appreciate steadily, but an unattributed Fivaz-Stanton variety, once recognized, can appreciate at a much faster rate, effectively hedging against both inflation and market downturns simultaneously.
Strategic Implications for the Collector-Investor
For the long-term investor, holding an unattributed variety is akin to holding a call option on the recognition of that variety. The premium paid for attribution is the cost of the option. If the TPG’ers recognize the variety, the option pays off handsomely. If they do not, the investor is left with a standard graded coin. Given the historical resilience of hard assets during inflationary periods, the downside risk is limited to the grading and attribution fees, while the potential upside is massive. This aligns perfectly with modern portfolio theory, where alternative investments are used to enhance returns while reducing overall portfolio volatility.
4. Alternative Investments: The Non-Correlated Play
Diversification Through Niche Specialization
In the world of alternative investments, few opportunities offer the same level of diversification as niche numismatic varieties. Traditional hedge funds and private equity rely on broad market indices, but the numismatic market operates on entirely different fundamental drivers: die variations, mint records, and collector demographics. An unattributed Fivaz-Stanton variety is a pure bet on the future adoption of the variety by the top-tier grading services. Because the market for this variety does not yet exist, it carries zero correlation with current numismatic market trends. It is a non-correlated asset, making it an ideal addition to a diversified alternative investment portfolio.
The Role of Documentation in Alternative Assets
The forum discussion underscored the importance of documentation. One participant noted that the only image of this variety they had seen was in the Cherrypicker’s Guide, and their coin’s Pick Up Point was clearer. In alternative asset management, due diligence is paramount. Without robust documentation—such as high-resolution PUP (Picture of the Unattired Point) images, comparison charts, and published articles in reputable numismatic magazines—the risk of misidentification is high. An investor spending their “slush fund” on attribution must ensure the documentation is bulletproof. The alternative is pouring capital down the drain on a variety that does not meet the grading service’s evidentiary standards.
5. Actionable Takeaways: Making the Investment Call
Decision Matrix for the Unattributed Fivaz-Stanton
Based on the extensive forum debate, here is the strategic framework for an alternative asset manager evaluating this specific opportunity:
- Confidence Level: High confidence in the variety’s existence, but moderate uncertainty regarding TPG’s recognition threshold. The Pick Up Point is highly visible, suggesting the variety is genuine.
- Cost of Entry: The cost to reholder and submit for TPG attribution must be weighed against the potential ROI. As one participant noted, if it turns into a Pop 1/0, the proceeds will easily cover the grading and reholdering costs.
- Selling Strategy: Do not rely on dealer premiums. List the coin on an online venue for a set price or submit it to an auction house. This ensures fair market value realization once the variety is recognized.
- Documentation Priority: Invest heavily in clear, large-scale images of the PUP and gather any additional published recognition (CoinWorld, Coinweek) before spending money on slab attribution.
- Risk Management: If the TPG’ers decline to attribute the variety, the coin reverts to a standard graded PCGS holder. The downside is limited to the grading fee, but the upside is capped by the lack of variety recognition.
6. Conclusion: The Long-Term Outlook
Is It Worth the Squeeze?
Ultimately, the question of whether to send the unattributed Fivaz-Stanton variety in for TPG attribution boils down to a calculated risk assessment. For the long-term investor, the allure of an unrecognized, highly visible Pick Up Point variety is too compelling to ignore. The historical precedent of varieties transitioning from unattributed to Pop 1/0 status demonstrates the immense potential for historical price appreciation. Furthermore, by securing this attribution, the investor unlocks immediate liquidity and secures a hard asset that serves as a robust inflation hedge.
However, the alternative asset manager must remain disciplined. The cost of entry is not trivial, and the primary risk is that the grading service may not recognize the variety as significant. Therefore, the decision to send it in should be predicated on irrefutable documentation and a high degree of confidence in the variety’s authenticity. If those criteria are met, submitting the coin is not just a numismatic pursuit; it is a strategic allocation of capital into a non-correlated, alternative asset with substantial long-term ROI potential.
The Pick Up Point is obvious, the documentation is strong, and the scarcity is real. For those willing to invest the capital and patience, recognizing an unattributed Fivaz-Stanton variety could yield a significant return in your alternative asset portfolio.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Finding Unattributed FS Varieties in Circulation: A Cherry Picker’s Guide to the Fivaz-Stanton Question – The Thrill of the Unattributed: Why Cherry Picking is the Holy Grail You don’t need a dealer to find this. Here is…
- Smart Buying Guide: How to Attributize an Unattributed Fivaz-Stanton FS Variety Without Getting Ripped Off – Looking to add this to your collection? You need a solid strategy to get the best deal. As someone who has spent years n…
- Can the Fivaz-Stanton Variety Be Crafted into Jewelry? A Coin Ring Artisan’s Guide to Metal Composition, Hardness, and Design Potential – Not every coin is suitable for crafting. Let’s look at the metal composition and durability of this piece for jewe…







