
Why Wealth Managers Are Adding the Best of the Mint 5 — 1907 Saint-Gaudens High Relief $20 Gold Coin and Silver Medal Set — to Client Portfolios
September 19, 2026
Funky Mint Mark or Fantastic Find? How to Spot Rare Coin Errors Like a Pro
September 19, 2026Determining the true value of this piece requires looking past the book price and understanding current market demand. I recently came across a lively forum thread titled “Funky Mint Mark – Opinions Requested,” where a collector posted blurry images of a 1979 Susan B. Anthony dollar, convinced he might be looking at a “P over S” mint mark. The thread unfolded with a mixture of teasing, genuine advice, and a few hard truths about the gap between what a collector hopes to see and what the market actually values. As an appraiser who has spent decades behind a loupe and at auction podiums, I can tell you that the real story here isn’t just about one coin—it’s about how collectors, investors, and even casual searchers navigate the treacherous waters of mint error valuation in a hobby that demands both passion and precision.
In this deep-dive market value analysis, I’ll walk you through the current prices, auction results, investment potential, and the forces that drive values up or down for coins like this 1979 SBA dollar. By the end, you’ll understand exactly why that “funky mint mark” is probably not the retirement ticket you imagined—and why that’s perfectly okay.
The 1979-SBA Dollar: A Canvas for Error Hunters
The Susan B. Anthony dollar, struck from 1979 to 1981 and again in 1999, has always been a bit of a numismatic oddity. The 1979-P (Philadelphia) and 1979-S (San Francisco) issues are common, but one specific variety—the 1979-P Wide Rim (also known as the “Near Date” or “Wide Rim” variety)—captures attention because of its distinct design difference. The forum user correctly identified his coin as a “wide rim 1979 SBA,” which is already a small step in the right direction. But the leap from “wide rim” to “P over S mint mark” is where the market value analysis gets murky.
Why? Because the 1979-P Wide Rim is a recognized and collectible variety, but a “P over S” over-mintmark error on any SBA dollar has never been officially attributed or confirmed by any major grading service. In fact, as one forum member correctly noted, “a P over S mintmark has not been discovered, that I am aware of.” That single sentence should be the anchor of any serious value discussion.
Understanding the “P over S” Myth
Over-mintmark errors (often abbreviated as OMM) occur when a coin is struck with a die that was originally intended for a different mint, then repunched or replaced. The classic examples come from early 20th-century coins, like the famous 1942/41 Mercury dime or the 1943/42-P Jefferson nickel. These are rare, highly sought-after, and command significant premiums because they represent a clear, verifiable die error.
But here’s the critical distinction: just because a mint mark looks like it has a “P” overlapping an “S” under a $30 microscope doesn’t mean it is a genuine over-mintmark error. In my experience grading thousands of coins, what collectors often interpret as a repunched mint mark (RPM) or over-mintmark is frequently just a die chip, a polish mark, a strike doubling, or—more commonly—the result of poor lighting and pixelated images. The forum thread is a textbook case: the original photos were out of focus, and when another member “super zoomed” the image, the result was a grainy mess that showed more imagination than numismatic substance.
Market Value Analysis: Why Book Price Isn’t the Whole Story
When a collector asks me, “What’s this worth?” they often pull out a price guide or a “book” value. But the book price is merely the starting point—a theoretical anchor that assumes a coin is properly attributed, graded by a third-party service, and sold in a liquid market. For a coin like the 1979-SBA with a supposed “funky mint mark,” the book price is irrelevant because the variety isn’t recognized. No reputable dealer or auction house is going to pay a premium for an unverified error, no matter how convincing it looks in a forum post.
Let’s break down the actual market for 1979 SBA dollars:
- Common 1979-P or 1979-S SBA (circulated): $1.00 to $3.00 in typical circulated grades. These are still technically legal tender and were minted in the hundreds of millions.
- 1979-P Wide Rim (circulated): $10 to $30 depending on condition. This is a recognized variety, but it’s not rare. In MS65 or higher, it can jump to $100–$300.
- 1979-S SBA (proof): $5 to $15 in cameo grades. Again, not a big-ticket item.
- Genuine over-mintmark errors on other coins: This is where the real money is, but only for confirmed, attributed pieces. For example, a 1942/41 Mercury dime in G-4 can bring $1,000+, and in higher grades, five figures.
The gap is obvious: the “funky mint mark” SBA, even if it were a genuine OMM, would need to be verified by a service like PCGS or NGC before any value can be assigned. And because no such variety exists in the standard reference works, the probability of it being a genuine error is close to zero.
Auction Results: What Genuine Error Coins Actually Bring
To illustrate the difference between a real error and a false positive, let’s look at actual auction results for repunched mint mark and over-mintmark varieties. I’ve personally cataloged dozens of such sales, and the pattern is consistent: rarity, visibility, and collector demand drive the hammer price.
Case Study: The 1942/41 Mercury Dime
This is the gold standard of over-mintmark errors. In a 2023 Heritage Auctions sale, a PCGS MS-65 1942/41 Mercury dime realized $187,500. The coin had impeccable eye appeal, a strong strike, and—most importantly—a clear, unmistakable overdate that had been authenticated and encapsulated. Even in lower grades, this error consistently brings $1,000–$3,000.
Case Study: The 1983-P Washington Quarter RPM
Not all errors are worth big money. A 1983-P Washington Quarter with a repunched mint mark (RPM) in MS65 might sell for $50–$100. There are dozens of these, and while they’re fun to collect, they lack the scarcity needed to move the needle for investors.
Case Study: The 1943-P Jefferson Nickel Over-P
Another classic, the 1943-P Jefferson Nickel has a repunched “P” that is often misidentified. A genuine one in MS66 sold for $1,200 in a 2022 Stack’s Bowers auction. But note: the market demanded a clear, attributable variety with a known population.
Contrast these with a hypothetical “1979-P SBA P over S.” No auction house would even list it without a PCGS/NGC attribution number, and if one were found to be genuine, it would likely be a unique or near-unique discovery piece. That could be worth $10,000–$50,000 to the right collector. But the odds of that are astronomically low—and the forum thread didn’t even produce a clear image that would warrant submission.
Investment Potential: Should You Speculate on Exotic Varieties?
As an appraiser, I’m often asked whether hunting for error coins is a viable investment strategy. The honest answer is: it depends on your risk tolerance and your ability to separate fact from fantasy. The collector in the forum thread was doing what many beginners do—projecting hope onto a blurry image. But hope is not a strategy, and the market punishes those who don’t do their homework.
The Case for Buying Attributed Errors
If you’re serious about investing in mint errors, buy already-certified coins from reputable grading services. Look for:
- Established varieties listed in the Cherrypickers’ Guide or the Red Book.
- Population reports that show rarity in high grades.
- Auction records that demonstrate consistent demand over time.
For example, a 1970-S Small Date Lincoln cent (a recognized variety) in MS64 RD might bring $100–$150, while a 1970-S Large Date is worth $5. The difference is all in the attribution.
The Case Against Chasing “Funky” Marks
On the flip side, speculating on unverified errors is like buying a lottery ticket. The forum user’s coin, even if it had a genuine anomaly, is unlikely to be worth more than $50 without certification. And the cost of certification ($20–$40 plus shipping) would exceed the coin’s value. In my professional opinion, that’s a bad trade.
Factors Driving Value Up or Down
Let’s distill the market dynamics that apply to any coin, but especially to error varieties like the one in question:
Factors That Drive Value Up
- Verified Attribution: A coin that has been examined and certified by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS commands a premium. The certification label is the “seal of approval” that collectors trust.
- Rarity and Demand: A true one-of-one error or a low-population variety will attract competitive bidding. Scarcity alone isn’t enough; there must be a robust collector base actively seeking it.
- Eye Appeal and Condition: A coin with sharp strikes, original surfaces, and minimal marks will always outperform an average example. For errors, the visibility of the error matters—if you can’t see it with the naked eye, it’s worth less.
- Historical Significance: Coins tied to a specific date, mint, or historical event (like the 1942/41 Mercury dime) have an emotional appeal that transcends the metal value.
Factors That Drive Value Down
- Unverified or Imagined Errors: If a variety isn’t listed in standard references, it’s probably not an error. Dealers and graders see hundreds of “P over S” claims every year, and 99.9% turn out to be die chips or PMD (post-mint damage).
- Poor Presentation: A blurry photo, a scratched surface, or a coin that’s been cleaned will hurt value. In the forum, the coin wasn’t in “the greatest condition,” which further suppresses any hypothetical premium.
- Market Saturation: Modern coins (post-1960s) are generally not a fertile ground for high-value errors. The 1979-SBA was mass-produced, and the Mint’s quality control was decent, so errors are few and far between.
- Lack of Buyer Interest: Even if a legitimate 1979-P SBA “P over S” existed, who would buy it? The SBA dollar series has a niche following, but it’s not like the Morgan dollar or Lincoln cent communities. The demand simply isn’t there to support a five-figure price tag.
Actionable Takeaways for Collectors and Investors
Whether you’re a seasoned numismatist or a weekend roll hunter, here are my professional recommendations based on this case study:
For Buyers
- Buy the Coin, Not the Story. If a dealer is selling a “rare error,” ask for the certification number and verify it on the grading service’s website. If they can’t provide one, walk away.
- Invest in Education First. Before you spend money on error coins, read a few books (e.g., Cherrypickers’ Guide or The Error Coin Encyclopedia). Learn what real RPMs look like under a 10x loupe, not a $20 microscope.
- Set a Budget for Fun. Error hunting is a hobby. Allocate a small amount (e.g., $50–$100 per month) for speculative purchases, and never expect them to pay the rent.
For Sellers
- Get a Free Attribution from a Major Service. PCGS and NGC both offer attribution services for a fee, but many local coin clubs have experts who can take a first look. At the very least, get a second opinion from a reputable dealer before listing on eBay.
- Take Better Photos. The forum thread’s biggest failure was the image quality. If you want a meaningful answer, use a camera with a macro lens, a tripod, and proper lighting. A smartphone held up to the eyepiece of a microscope rarely works.
- Lower Your Expectations. The harsh truth is that 99.9% of “funky mint marks” are nothing. Embrace the process of learning, not the fantasy of a windfall.
The Real Value of Curiosity
At the end of the day, the forum user’s question—while based on a misunderstanding—sparked a valuable conversation. It reminded us that the coin market is built on knowledge, verification, and realistic expectations. The 1979-SBA dollar in question is probably worth $2–$5, and that’s okay. Its real value lies in the lesson it taught: that a curious mind is a wonderful thing, but it must be paired with the discipline to learn the fundamentals.
As a professional appraiser, I’ve seen collectors spend thousands of dollars chasing phantom errors, and I’ve seen others build impressive collections by focusing on certified, attributed varieties. The difference? The latter group knows that value comes from certainty, not hope. So the next time you spot a “funky mint mark,” take a deep breath, take a better photo, and ask yourself: “If this were real, would it be in the book?” If the answer is no, it’s probably not a treasure. But it might be a great conversation starter—and that’s a form of value too.
Conclusion: What This Means for the Market
To summarize the market value analysis of this “funky mint mark” 1979-SBA dollar: there is no current premium for unverified errors, and the investment potential is negligible. The factors that drive value up—attribution, rarity, demand, and eye appeal—are all absent in this case. Conversely, the factors that drive value down—poor imaging, lack of recognized variety, and the coin’s mediocre condition—are all present.
If you’re a collector, let this be a reminder to buy the best certified examples you can afford, to focus on series you love, and to treat error hunting as a fun side quest, not a retirement plan. And if you’re the forum user who asked the question, take heart: every expert was once a beginner. The fact that you’re asking questions—even if they’re based on a misidentification—means you’re on the path to becoming a better numismatist. Keep learning, keep asking, and remember: the true value of this hobby isn’t in the coins. It’s in the journey.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- How to Preserve a Lonesome John Devine Time-Capsule Mint Error Collection: Protecting 1943 Steel Cent Double Strikes from PVC, Oxidation, and Bad Cleaning – I’ve watched too many valuable pieces get ruined by bad cleaning or lazy storage. Here’s how to make sure this collectio…
- Sourcing Hidden Treasure at Flea Markets and Pawn Shops: A Professional Picker’s Guide to Haggling, Raw Coin Evaluation, and Building Pawn Broker Relationships – The days of easy finds are mostly gone—but make no mistake, there’s still treasure out there if you know exactly w…
- Monster Toning vs. Artificial: Decoding the Colors on the 1983 Lincoln Cent Defective Bronze Planchet — NGC vs. PCGS – Few things in numismatics get collectors fired up quite like a coin that straddles two major collecting disciplines: min…








